- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Evidence for evolution
Use fossils, homologous, analogous and vestigial organs, embryos and observed changes such as the peppered moth as evidence that evolution has happened.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A scientific idea is only as good as its evidence. Evolution happened over millions of years, so nobody could watch most of it. Instead, biologists collect clues from rocks, from the bodies of living animals and plants, from embryos and from changes that happen fast enough to see. This lesson goes through each kind of clue in simple steps. Exam questions often give you two organs and ask what kind of evidence they are, so pay special attention to the difference between homologous and analogous organs.
Fossils
A fossil is the remains or trace of a living thing preserved in rock, such as a bone, a shell, a leaf print or a footprint. Rocks form in layers, and in undisturbed rock the deeper layers are older. When fossils from many layers are compared, the older layers hold simpler forms and the younger layers hold more complex and more recent forms, and some fossils show features of two groups at once. This is just what we expect if living things changed over time.
Homologous organs: same plan, different jobs
Homologous organs have the same basic structure and origin but may do different jobs. The forelimbs of a human, a cheetah, a whale and a bat are used for grasping, running, swimming and flying, yet all have the same set of bones: upper arm, forearm, wrist and finger bones. The simplest explanation is that these animals share a common ancestor and their limbs became different as they adapted to different lives. This spreading apart from one ancestor is called divergent evolution. In plants, the thorn of Bougainvillea and the tendril of Cucurbita (the gourd family) are homologous.
Analogous organs: different plan, same job
Analogous organs do the same job but have different structures and origins. The wing of a butterfly and the wing of a bird both help in flying, but the butterfly wing is a thin sheet with no bones while the bird wing is a modified forelimb. The eye of an octopus and the eye of a mammal, the flippers of a penguin and a dolphin, and the sweet potato (a root) and the potato (a stem) are other examples. Unrelated organisms facing similar needs came to similar solutions, which is called convergent evolution.
Worked example 1: sorting pairs
Classify three pairs. Pair 1, a bat's wing and a human arm: different jobs, same bones, so they are homologous and show divergent evolution. Pair 2, a bat's wing and a butterfly's wing: same job, completely different structure, so they are analogous and show convergent evolution. Pair 3, a potato and a sweet potato: both store food, but one is an underground stem and the other a root, so they are analogous. The test is always the same: ask first whether the structure and origin match, not whether the job matches.
Vestigial organs, embryos and molecules
Vestigial organs are reduced organs with little or no use in the living organism, though they are useful in related animals. In humans, the vermiform appendix, the tail bone (coccyx), wisdom teeth and the small muscles that move the ear are examples. Early embryos of fish, birds and mammals look surprisingly alike, for example all show gill slits at an early stage. At the chemical level, related living things have similar DNA and proteins, and the more closely related they are, the more similar these molecules are.
Worked example 2: evolution we can watch
In England, the peppered moth exists in a light form and a dark form. Before factories were common, tree trunks were covered with pale lichens and light moths were hidden from birds, so light moths were more common. After industrial smoke darkened the trunks, the dark moths were better hidden and became more common. Step 1: there was variation in colour. Step 2: birds ate the moths that stood out. Step 3: the better-hidden form survived and reproduced more. This change is called industrial melanism. Bacteria becoming resistant to antibiotics is another change seen in a human lifetime.
Homologous = same structure, different function (divergent evolution). Analogous = different structure, same function (convergent evolution). Judge by structure and origin, never by function alone.
Key takeaways
- Fossils in rock layers show change from simpler to more complex forms.
- Forelimbs of human, cheetah, whale and bat are homologous.
- Wings of butterfly and bird are analogous.
- Appendix, coccyx and wisdom teeth are vestigial in humans.
- The peppered moth and antibiotic resistance show evolution in action.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which pair are homologous organs?
- Wing of a butterfly and wing of a bird
- Forelimb of a whale and forelimb of a bat
- Eye of an octopus and eye of a mammal
- Flipper of a penguin and flipper of a dolphin
Show answer
Answer: B. Whale and bat forelimbs have the same set of bones and the same origin but different jobs, so they are homologous. The other pairs do the same job with different structures: analogous.
-
2. Analogous organs are evidence of:
- Divergent evolution
- Spontaneous generation
- Convergent evolution
- Vestigial evolution
Show answer
Answer: C. Analogous organs arise when unrelated organisms evolve similar solutions to similar needs. This is convergent evolution.
-
3. Which of these is a vestigial organ in humans?
- Vermiform appendix
- Heart
- Lungs
- Femur
Show answer
Answer: A. The vermiform appendix is reduced and has little digestive use in humans, while it is larger and useful in some plant-eating mammals. It is a vestigial organ.
-
4. The potato and the sweet potato both store food underground. They are:
- Homologous, because both store food
- Homologous, because both grow underground
- Analogous, because one is a stem and the other a root
- Vestigial, because both are swollen
Show answer
Answer: C. They do the same job but have different origins: the potato is a modified stem, the sweet potato a modified root. Same job, different origin means analogous.
-
5. Why did dark peppered moths become more common in industrial areas of England?
- Smoke changed the colour of each moth during its life
- They were better hidden from birds on smoke-darkened trees
- Dark moths were created by the smoke
- Light moths stopped laying eggs because of noise
Show answer
Answer: B. Birds ate the moths that were easy to see. On dark trunks the dark moths survived and reproduced more, so their share rose. This is natural selection, called industrial melanism.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.