• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Lamarck and Darwin: two explanations

Compare Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters with Darwin's natural selection, and explain the giraffe's neck both ways.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Once naturalists agreed that living things had changed, they asked how. Two famous answers came from Jean-Baptiste Lamarck of France and Charles Darwin of England. Exam questions love to set them side by side, often using the same example: the long neck of the giraffe. This lesson explains both theories in plain language, shows why Lamarck's idea was rejected, and lists the steps of Darwin's natural selection that you need to know by heart.

Lamarck: use, disuse and acquired characters

Lamarck proposed that organs which are used a lot become stronger and larger, while organs that are not used become weak and may disappear. This is the idea of use and disuse. He then said that such changes, gained during an animal's life, are passed on to its young. This is called inheritance of acquired characters. In his view, giraffes stretched their necks to reach leaves high on trees, their necks grew a little longer, and the longer neck was passed on, so necks grew longer generation after generation.

Why Lamarck's idea was rejected

The weak point is the second step. Changes gained during life, such as strong muscles from exercise or a scar from an injury, are not passed on to children, because they do not change the genes in eggs and sperm. August Weismann tested this by cutting off the tails of mice for many generations; the young were still born with normal tails. A wrestler's children are not born with big muscles. So acquired characters are not inherited, and Lamarck's mechanism fails.

Darwin: natural selection

Darwin travelled around the world on the ship HMS Beagle and studied the plants and animals of many places, including the finches of the Galapagos Islands. He was also influenced by Thomas Malthus's writing about populations growing faster than food. Alfred Russel Wallace, working in the Malay Archipelago, reached a very similar idea independently. Darwin published his theory in the book On the Origin of Species in 1859.

  1. Overproduction: living things produce far more young than can survive.
  2. Struggle for existence: food and space are limited, so individuals compete.
  3. Variation: no two individuals are exactly alike, and many differences are inherited.
  4. Survival of the fittest: individuals with useful variations survive and reproduce more (the phrase was coined by Herbert Spencer).
  5. Natural selection: nature 'selects' these individuals, so useful variations become common over generations.

In Darwin's sense, 'fittest' does not mean strongest. It means best at surviving and leaving offspring in a particular environment, which is called reproductive fitness.

Worked example 1: the giraffe, two ways

Lamarck's version: a giraffe stretches its neck, the neck grows longer during its life, and this longer neck is inherited. Darwin's version: Step 1, giraffes were born with necks of different lengths (variation). Step 2, when low leaves ran short, those with slightly longer necks reached more food (struggle and survival). Step 3, they had more young, who inherited the longer neck (inheritance). Step 4, over many generations the average neck became longer (natural selection). The difference: Lamarck's change happens during life and is then passed on; Darwin's variation already exists at birth.

Worked example 2: a modern case

Many mosquitoes in an area are killed by a new insecticide, but a few survive because they happen to carry a resistance variation. The survivors breed, and the next generation has more resistant mosquitoes. Did the insecticide cause the resistance? No; it only removed the non-resistant ones. That is natural selection, and it is the reason why repeated spraying with one chemical becomes less effective over time.

Lamarck: change gained during life is inherited (rejected). Darwin: variation exists first, and the environment selects which variants survive and breed.

Key takeaways

  • Lamarck: use and disuse plus inheritance of acquired characters.
  • Weismann's tail-cutting experiment showed acquired changes are not inherited.
  • Darwin and Wallace independently proposed natural selection; Darwin published in 1859.
  • Fitness means reproductive success, not strength.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The idea of 'inheritance of acquired characters' was given by:

    1. Darwin
    2. Hugo de Vries
    3. Wallace
    4. Lamarck
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Lamarck proposed that changes gained during life through use and disuse are passed to the young. Darwin proposed natural selection.

  2. 2. Weismann cut off the tails of mice for many generations. What did he find?

    1. The young were still born with normal tails
    2. The young were born with shorter tails each generation
    3. The young were born without tails after a few generations
    4. The mice stopped breeding
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Tails removed during life did not change the genes, so every generation was born with normal tails. This showed that acquired characters are not inherited, against Lamarck.

  3. 3. Who independently reached an idea of natural selection very similar to Darwin's?

    1. Jean-Baptiste Lamarck
    2. Louis Pasteur
    3. Alfred Russel Wallace
    4. Stanley Miller
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Wallace, working in the Malay Archipelago, reached the idea of natural selection independently of Darwin.

  4. 4. In Darwin's theory, the 'fittest' individual is the one that:

    1. Leaves the most surviving offspring in its environment
    2. Is the strongest and largest
    3. Lives the longest
    4. Exercises its organs the most
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Darwinian fitness means reproductive fitness: success in surviving and leaving offspring in a given environment, not physical strength.

  5. 5. After an insecticide is used for several years, most mosquitoes in an area are resistant to it. The best explanation is that:

    1. The insecticide made each mosquito resistant during its life
    2. Resistant mosquitoes already existed, survived and bred, so their share rose
    3. Mosquitoes learned to avoid the insecticide and taught their young
    4. The insecticide created new species of mosquito overnight
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The variation existed before spraying; the insecticide removed non-resistant mosquitoes, and the resistant ones bred. This is natural selection.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery