- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Darwin's journey and the logic of natural selection
Follow the observations and inferences that led Darwin and Wallace to natural selection, and apply the logic to a simple population with numbers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Charles Darwin did not simply announce an idea. He gathered observations over years, and then drew conclusions from them in steps. The steps are so clear that you can put them in a chain, and exam questions often ask you to complete the chain or to apply it to a new case. In this lesson we go through the story and the logic, and then do an example with numbers.
The journey and the clues
As a young man, Darwin sailed around the world on the ship HMS Beagle. He collected plants, animals and fossils. On the Galapagos Islands, off the coast of South America, he saw that the finches and the giant tortoises differed from island to island, although all resembled the species of the mainland. He also read the essay of Malthus, who argued that human populations tend to grow faster than their food supply. Darwin realised that the same must be true of all living things. Alfred Russel Wallace, working in the islands of south-east Asia, reached the same idea independently, and the two shared the idea in 1858. Darwin's book On the Origin of Species was published in 1859.
The chain of logic
- Observation 1: organisms make more offspring than can survive. (Overproduction)
- Observation 2: the size of a population stays roughly steady, because food and space are limited. So there is a struggle for existence.
- Observation 3: members of a population differ from each other. (Variation)
- Observation 4: much of the variation is passed from parents to offspring. (Inheritance)
- Inference: individuals with variations that suit the environment are more likely to survive and reproduce. (Natural selection, or survival of the fittest)
- Result: over many generations, the helpful variations become common, and the population changes.
Darwin did not know how variation arises or how it is inherited. The explanation came later from genetics and the study of mutation. Note that natural selection acts on individuals, but it is the population that changes. Fitness means the success in leaving offspring, not strength or size.
Worked example 1: green and brown beetles
Suppose, as an illustration, a field has 100 beetles: 60 green and 40 brown. Birds see the brown beetles easily on the green grass. Suppose 80% of green beetles but only 20% of brown beetles survive to breed. Survivors: green 60 × 0.8 = 48; brown 40 × 0.2 = 8. Total survivors 56. The proportion of green beetles among survivors is 48 ÷ 56 = 85.7%, up from 60%. If colour is inherited, their offspring will also be mostly green. After a few generations the brown colour will be rare. No beetle changed its colour; the population changed because green beetles left more offspring.
Worked example 2: fitting the chain to the Galapagos finches
On an island where the seeds are large and hard, finches with stronger, deeper beaks crack the seeds more easily and so survive better. Match the steps. Variation: beak depth differs. Struggle: food is limited. Selection: deep-beaked birds feed better and leave more young. Inheritance: beak shape is passed on. Result: the average beak depth of the population increases over generations.
Worked example 3: spotting a wrong statement
A student writes: 'The giraffes stretched their necks to reach the leaves, and their stretched necks were passed to their young.' Which part conflicts with Darwin's logic? The stretching of the necks during life is not inherited. In Darwin's account, giraffes already differed in neck length, the longer-necked ones fed better, left more young, and the average neck length rose.
Overproduction, struggle, variation, inheritance: the fittest leave more offspring, and so the population changes over generations.
Key takeaways
- Darwin's ideas came from his voyage, the Galapagos, and the essay of Malthus; Wallace reached the same idea independently.
- Natural selection needs overproduction, variation and inheritance.
- Fitness means the number of offspring that survive, not strength.
- Selection acts on individuals, but populations evolve.
- Features gained during life are not inherited.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who independently arrived at the idea of natural selection at about the same time as Darwin?
- Gregor Johann Mendel
- Alfred Russel Wallace
- Hugo de Vries, a botanist
- Louis Pasteur, a chemist
Show answer
Answer: B. Wallace, working in south-east Asia, thought of natural selection independently, and the two ideas were presented together.
-
2. Which idea from Malthus's essay influenced Darwin?
- Populations tend to grow faster than the food supply
- Characters acquired in life are inherited
- Species never change in the course of time
- Fossils are always found in the oldest rocks
Show answer
Answer: A. Malthus's argument that populations outgrow their food led Darwin to see a struggle for existence in nature.
-
3. Which of these is NOT a step in Darwin's reasoning?
- Individuals in a population differ from each other
- More offspring are born than can survive to adulthood
- Use and disuse change an organ and the change is inherited
- Helpful variations are favoured by the environment
Show answer
Answer: C. Inheritance of characters acquired during life is Lamarck's idea, not part of Darwin's argument.
-
4. In the beetle example, the proportion of green beetles among survivors is 48 out of 56. As a percentage this is about:
- 60%
- 80%
- 48%
- 85.7%
Show answer
Answer: D. 48 ÷ 56 = 0.857, which is 85.7%. The original proportion was 60%, and 80% was only the survival rate of green beetles.
-
5. 'Fitness' in Darwin's theory means:
- Great physical strength and size
- Large body size at maturity
- Leaving more surviving offspring
- Long life without ever breeding
Show answer
Answer: C. A fit organism is one that survives and leaves more offspring than others, whatever its strength.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.