- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
For Anne Gregory: Yeats on beauty and being loved for oneself
Understand W.B. Yeats's poem For Anne Gregory, a conversation about whether a young woman can be loved for herself alone and not her golden hair; explain the speakers, the honey-coloured ramparts, the refrain and the rhyme.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Identify the speakers and their argument in each stanza.
- Explain the metaphor of the honey-coloured ramparts.
- Explain the refrain and the rhyme pattern.
- Discuss whether people can be loved 'for themselves alone'.
The poem with this chapter, For Anne Gregory, is by William Butler Yeats (1865-1939), the Irish poet, interested in folklore and mythology, who won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1923. It is a short conversation between an older speaker and a young woman about beauty and love. The title names a real young woman, Anne Gregory, to whom the poem is addressed.
The argument, stanza by stanza
- Stanza 1 (the speaker): young men, overwhelmed by her beautiful golden hair falling around her ears like great honey-coloured walls, will never love her for herself alone, only for her hair.
- Stanza 2 (Anne): she replies that she can dye her hair brown, black or even carrot-coloured, so that young men will love her for herself and not her hair.
- Stanza 3 (the speaker): he answers that he heard an old religious man say he had found a text proving that only God can love someone for herself alone and not for her looks.
The conversation
- Claim Men will love your hair, not you.
- Reply Then I will change my hair colour.
- Final answer Only God can love a person purely for herself.
Key images and devices
| Feature | In the poem | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Metaphor | Her hair is called honey-coloured ramparts at her ear | Golden, thick hair like the high walls of a fort, both beautiful and a barrier |
| Refrain | Each stanza ends with the idea of being loved for herself alone and not her yellow hair | Keeps the central question before us |
| Dialogue form | Two voices argue in turns | Makes the poem a debate |
| Rhyme | In each six-line stanza, lines 2, 4 and 6 rhyme (despair, ear, hair; there, despair, hair) | Ties each stanza to the repeated word hair |
| Irony | Changing the hair colour would not change the problem: people would then love a different outward look | Shows outward appearance can never be fully escaped |
Worked example 1: why are young men thrown into despair?
Question: What does the speaker mean by the ramparts, and why do they make young men despair? Working: ramparts are the high walls of a fort, like those of the Red Fort; honey-coloured suggests golden. Her thick, golden hair framing her face is compared to such walls. Answer: her hair is so beautiful that young men fall hopelessly in love with it; they despair because they are captivated and perhaps because, like a fort's walls, her beauty seems to keep them out.
Worked example 2: who wins the argument?
Working: Anne thinks the problem is the colour of her hair and can be fixed. The speaker's final reply says the problem is human nature: people are always drawn by outward qualities. Answer: the speaker has the last word, suggesting that only divine love is completely unconditional; human love is always partly drawn by appearance.
Discussion: are people loved for themselves?
Love for qualities or for the person?
-
Love that depends on qualities
- The public's love for a star or sports hero
- Liking a friend for being funny or clever
- Admiring someone for looks or wealth
-
Love that seems unconditional
- A parent's love for a newborn
- Love for a child with a disability, no less than for a prodigy
- A pet's affection for its owner
- Long friendships that survive change
Elsewhere Yeats asks how we can separate the dancer from the dance: the way a person looks, speaks and moves is part of who they are. A thoughtful answer might say that love often starts with qualities but deepens into love for the whole person.
For Anne Gregory: beauty attracts, but only God loves a person for herself alone, says the speaker.
Key takeaways: the poem is a dialogue about beauty and true love. Golden hair is the honey-coloured ramparts; the refrain repeats the question of being loved for oneself; the last stanza says only God's love is wholly unconditional.
Check your understanding
-
1. What colour is the young woman's hair?
- Black
- Brown
- Golden yellow
- Red
Show answer
Answer: C. The poem speaks of her yellow, honey-coloured hair. Brown, black and carrot are colours she says she could dye it.
-
2. What does 'honey-coloured ramparts' refer to?
- The walls of her house
- Her golden hair falling beside her ears
- A fort in Ireland
- A field of wheat
Show answer
Answer: B. Her thick golden hair around her ears is compared to the high walls of a fort, a metaphor.
-
3. Why does Anne want to dye her hair?
- So that young men love her for herself and not for her hair
- Because her hair is turning grey
- To follow fashion
- Because the old man told her to
Show answer
Answer: A. She hopes that changing the colour will make young men value her for who she is.
-
4. What does the old religious man's text prove, according to the speaker?
- That hair dye is harmful
- That beauty lasts forever
- That young men are foolish
- That only God can love a person for herself alone
Show answer
Answer: D. The speaker reports that the old man found a text showing that only God loves someone purely for herself and not her looks.
-
5. Which lines rhyme in each stanza of the poem?
- Lines 1 and 2
- Lines 2, 4 and 6
- Lines 1, 3 and 5
- None of the lines
Show answer
Answer: B. The even lines rhyme in each stanza (for example despair, ear, hair), each stanza ending on the word hair.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.