• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

For Anne Gregory: Yeats on beauty and being loved for oneself

Understand W.B. Yeats's poem For Anne Gregory, a conversation about whether a young woman can be loved for herself alone and not her golden hair; explain the speakers, the honey-coloured ramparts, the refrain and the rhyme.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Identify the speakers and their argument in each stanza.
  • Explain the metaphor of the honey-coloured ramparts.
  • Explain the refrain and the rhyme pattern.
  • Discuss whether people can be loved 'for themselves alone'.

The poem with this chapter, For Anne Gregory, is by William Butler Yeats (1865-1939), the Irish poet, interested in folklore and mythology, who won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1923. It is a short conversation between an older speaker and a young woman about beauty and love. The title names a real young woman, Anne Gregory, to whom the poem is addressed.

The argument, stanza by stanza

  1. Stanza 1 (the speaker): young men, overwhelmed by her beautiful golden hair falling around her ears like great honey-coloured walls, will never love her for herself alone, only for her hair.
  2. Stanza 2 (Anne): she replies that she can dye her hair brown, black or even carrot-coloured, so that young men will love her for herself and not her hair.
  3. Stanza 3 (the speaker): he answers that he heard an old religious man say he had found a text proving that only God can love someone for herself alone and not for her looks.

The conversation

  1. Claim Men will love your hair, not you.
  2. Reply Then I will change my hair colour.
  3. Final answer Only God can love a person purely for herself.

Key images and devices

Notes in our own words.
FeatureIn the poemEffect
MetaphorHer hair is called honey-coloured ramparts at her earGolden, thick hair like the high walls of a fort, both beautiful and a barrier
RefrainEach stanza ends with the idea of being loved for herself alone and not her yellow hairKeeps the central question before us
Dialogue formTwo voices argue in turnsMakes the poem a debate
RhymeIn each six-line stanza, lines 2, 4 and 6 rhyme (despair, ear, hair; there, despair, hair)Ties each stanza to the repeated word hair
IronyChanging the hair colour would not change the problem: people would then love a different outward lookShows outward appearance can never be fully escaped

Worked example 1: why are young men thrown into despair?

Question: What does the speaker mean by the ramparts, and why do they make young men despair? Working: ramparts are the high walls of a fort, like those of the Red Fort; honey-coloured suggests golden. Her thick, golden hair framing her face is compared to such walls. Answer: her hair is so beautiful that young men fall hopelessly in love with it; they despair because they are captivated and perhaps because, like a fort's walls, her beauty seems to keep them out.

Worked example 2: who wins the argument?

Working: Anne thinks the problem is the colour of her hair and can be fixed. The speaker's final reply says the problem is human nature: people are always drawn by outward qualities. Answer: the speaker has the last word, suggesting that only divine love is completely unconditional; human love is always partly drawn by appearance.

Discussion: are people loved for themselves?

Love for qualities or for the person?

  • Love that depends on qualities
    • The public's love for a star or sports hero
    • Liking a friend for being funny or clever
    • Admiring someone for looks or wealth
  • Love that seems unconditional
    • A parent's love for a newborn
    • Love for a child with a disability, no less than for a prodigy
    • A pet's affection for its owner
    • Long friendships that survive change

Elsewhere Yeats asks how we can separate the dancer from the dance: the way a person looks, speaks and moves is part of who they are. A thoughtful answer might say that love often starts with qualities but deepens into love for the whole person.

For Anne Gregory: beauty attracts, but only God loves a person for herself alone, says the speaker.

Key takeaways: the poem is a dialogue about beauty and true love. Golden hair is the honey-coloured ramparts; the refrain repeats the question of being loved for oneself; the last stanza says only God's love is wholly unconditional.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What colour is the young woman's hair?

    1. Black
    2. Brown
    3. Golden yellow
    4. Red
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The poem speaks of her yellow, honey-coloured hair. Brown, black and carrot are colours she says she could dye it.

  2. 2. What does 'honey-coloured ramparts' refer to?

    1. The walls of her house
    2. Her golden hair falling beside her ears
    3. A fort in Ireland
    4. A field of wheat
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Her thick golden hair around her ears is compared to the high walls of a fort, a metaphor.

  3. 3. Why does Anne want to dye her hair?

    1. So that young men love her for herself and not for her hair
    2. Because her hair is turning grey
    3. To follow fashion
    4. Because the old man told her to
    Show answer

    Answer: A. She hopes that changing the colour will make young men value her for who she is.

  4. 4. What does the old religious man's text prove, according to the speaker?

    1. That hair dye is harmful
    2. That beauty lasts forever
    3. That young men are foolish
    4. That only God can love a person for herself alone
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The speaker reports that the old man found a text showing that only God loves someone purely for herself and not her looks.

  5. 5. Which lines rhyme in each stanza of the poem?

    1. Lines 1 and 2
    2. Lines 2, 4 and 6
    3. Lines 1, 3 and 5
    4. None of the lines
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The even lines rhyme in each stanza (for example despair, ear, hair), each stanza ending on the word hair.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery