• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing and speaking: a page on helping, teaching or being unique, and a discussion on grief

Write about a page in three paragraphs on teaching a difficult idea, helping each other through hard times, or seeing oneself as unique or as one among billions; and take part in a sensitive discussion comparing old and new ways of dealing with grief.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Plan and write a reflective three-paragraph composition.
  • Link ideas from the chapter to your own thinking.
  • Discuss a sensitive topic respectfully, with reasons.

The chapter's writing task offers three reflective topics. Each asks you to use ideas from the text (the Buddha's way of teaching, Kisa Gotami's discovery, Etzioni's family) and add your own ideas and experiences.

The three topics

Ideas for each topic

  • Teaching a difficult idea
    • The Buddha let Kisa Gotami discover the truth
    • Learning by doing beats being told
    • Examples, patience and questions
  • Helping each other in hard times
    • Etzioni's family kept busy caring for each other
    • Listening without judging
    • Small practical help
  • Unique, or one among billions
    • Each person's grief feels unique
    • Yet everyone shares joys and sorrows
    • Both views can be true together

Plan for a reflective page

  1. Paragraph 1: introduce the idea and link it to the chapter.
  2. Paragraph 2: develop it with an example from your life or an imagined situation, and a reason.
  3. Paragraph 3: conclude with what you now believe or would do.

Worked example 1: model on teaching a difficult idea (written for this lesson)

The Buddha could have told Kisa Gotami that everyone dies. Instead he gave her a task that let her discover it. I think the best teachers do the same: they lead us to the answer rather than handing it over. / Last year I tried to help my younger cousin understand fractions. Explaining the rules made her more confused. Then we cut a chapati into halves and quarters and shared it among the family. She saw at once that a quarter is smaller than a half, and laughed that she had got the smaller share. The idea became hers because she had seen it. / Since then, whenever I teach someone, I begin with something they can see or do. A truth we discover stays with us; a truth we are told is easily forgotten. Working: paragraph 1 links to the text; paragraph 2 gives a concrete example; paragraph 3 states a belief.

Worked example 2: an opening for 'unique or one among billions'

'When my best friend moved to another city, I felt that no one had ever been so lonely. Then, in the new term, I noticed a boy who sat alone every day; he too had left his friends behind. Kisa Gotami learnt the same lesson in every house she visited: our feelings are our own, but we are never the only ones who feel them.' Working: it starts with a personal feeling, turns with an observation, and links to the chapter.

Speaking: a discussion on grief

The book asks whether the Buddha's ideas and way of teaching still hold meaning, or whether we have found better ways to deal with grief. This is a sensitive subject. Speak about ideas, not about anyone's private loss, unless they choose to share. Useful phrases: I think the sermon still matters because...; I partly agree, but...; The modern guide adds something important:...; Could we combine both ideas?

A balanced view (written for this lesson): 'The sermon's central truth, that death touches everyone, is as true today as ever, and seeing others' sorrow does ease our own. Modern writers add that grief takes many forms and that anger or sadness is not wrong. Perhaps the wisest approach uses both: accept that loss is part of life, allow ourselves to feel it, and, like Etzioni's family, turn towards helping one another.'

Reflective writing: link to the text, give a real or imagined example, end with a belief. Sensitive discussion: ideas, not private details; reasons, not rudeness.

Key takeaways: a reflective page has three clear paragraphs linking the chapter to your own thinking. In discussion, show respect, give reasons and look for common ground between old and new ideas.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the model on teaching, why did cutting a chapati work better than explaining rules?

    1. Chapatis are tasty.
    2. The cousin could see and experience the idea herself.
    3. It took less time.
    4. Rules are always wrong.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Like Kisa Gotami's search, the cousin discovered the idea through experience, so she understood it.

  2. 2. What should the first paragraph of a reflective page do?

    1. List new words
    2. Introduce the idea and link it to the chapter
    3. Give the conclusion only
    4. Describe the weather
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The opening introduces the main idea and connects it to the text; examples and conclusions follow.

  3. 3. Which phrase is a respectful way to partly disagree?

    1. That's nonsense.
    2. You don't know anything.
    3. I partly agree, but I think...
    4. Stop talking about it.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 'I partly agree, but...' acknowledges the other view and leads into a reason.

  4. 4. Which idea from Etzioni's essay fits the topic 'helping each other in hard times'?

    1. Asking what we can do for one another instead of asking why
    2. Avoiding friends
    3. Staying angry forever
    4. Moving to another country
    Show answer

    Answer: A. His family found comfort in focusing on what they could do for each other.

  5. 5. In a class discussion on grief, what should you avoid?

    1. Giving reasons
    2. Listening to others
    3. Linking ideas to the text
    4. Pressing classmates to share their private losses
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Grief is personal. Discuss ideas and let people share only what they choose.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery