- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
The message of the sermon: death, grief and the arrow of lamentation
Explain the Buddha's teaching that all mortals must die and that grief cannot bring peace, interpret his similes and the image of the flickering lights, discuss 'selfishness in grief', and compare his ideas with modern writing on grief.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the main points of the Buddha's sermon in your own words.
- Explain the similes, the metaphor and the symbol in the text.
- Discuss whether Kisa Gotami was selfish in her grief.
- Compare the sermon with modern ideas about grief.
- Answer questions on an unseen passage.
After the story, the Buddha explains its lesson. His words are short and full of images, so learn to put them into plain language.
The sermon in plain words
- Human life is short, troubled and mixed with pain.
- Everyone who is born must die: young and old, foolish and wise.
- No one can save another from death, not even a father his son.
- Weeping and grieving do not bring peace; they only increase pain and harm the body, and they do not bring the dead back.
- The wise do not grieve endlessly, because they understand how the world works.
- Whoever pulls out the arrow of grief and complaint and becomes calm will find peace and be free of sorrow.
Images in the text
| Image | Device | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| City lights flickering on and going out | Symbol | Human lives begin and end, one after another. |
| Ripe fruits in danger of falling | Simile | Once born, mortals are always at risk of death. |
| Earthen pots that end up broken | Simile | Every life, like every clay pot, ends some day. |
| An ox led to slaughter | Simile | People are carried off by death one by one, helplessly. |
| The arrow of lamentation | Metaphor | Grief wounds us like an arrow; we must pull it out to heal. |
| Valley of desolation | Metaphor | The world as a place full of sorrow. |
Was she selfish in her grief?
Usually 'selfish' means caring only for oneself at others' expense. Kisa Gotami was not greedy or unkind. Her selfishness, in the sense she realises, was seeing her loss as the only one, as if death had singled her out, and demanding that the natural order be reversed for her alone. Once she saw that every family grieves, she moved from 'my sorrow' to 'our human condition'. You may agree or disagree with calling this selfishness; give reasons either way.
Worked example 1: why did she understand only the second time?
Working: the first time, she asked only for what she wanted (a cure) and heard only refusals. The second time, the Buddha's task made her ask each family about their dead, so she heard their stories of loss. Answer: the Buddha changed her question, and the new question made her listen to others' grief. Understanding came through experience, not argument.
Old wisdom and modern writing on grief
The book sets two modern texts beside the sermon. A guide on coping with death lists common feelings of grief: sadness, anger, guilt, anxiety, loneliness, tiredness and disbelief, and advises friends to be patient and supportive. In a personal essay, the writer Amitai Etzioni, who lost his wife and later his son, says there is no single right way to grieve, and that his family found comfort by asking not 'why' but 'what' they could do for one another.
The sermon and modern views
-
The Buddha's sermon
- Death is universal; accept it
- Excessive grief brings no peace
- Remove the arrow of sorrow; be calm
- Teaches through the person's own discovery
-
Modern texts
- Grief has many natural feelings
- There is no single right way to grieve
- Anger and sadness are normal
- Comfort comes from caring for one another
Both agree that grief is universal and that peace comes by turning outwards: Kisa Gotami sees the grief of others; Etzioni's family focuses on helping each other. The modern texts are gentler about allowing grief to be felt; the sermon stresses moving beyond it.
Practice passage (written for this lesson)
The Empty Chair. After his grandmother died, Arjun refused to let anyone sit in her chair on the veranda. For weeks he sat beside it every evening, saying nothing. His mother worried, but his grandfather said only, 'Let him be.' One evening a neighbour's small daughter, whose own grandmother had died that winter, wandered in and climbed into the chair. Arjun opened his mouth to scold her, then saw that she was crying. He sat down next to her and, without planning to, began telling her the stories his grandmother used to tell. The next evening she came back, and the evening after that. The chair was never empty again. (A made-up story.)
Worked example 2: questions on the passage
- Why did Arjun stop himself from scolding the girl? Answer: he saw that she was grieving too.
- What does the chair symbolise at the end? Answer: grief turning into shared memory and comfort.
- How does the passage echo Kisa Gotami's story? Answer: like Kisa Gotami, Arjun begins to heal when he recognises that others share his loss.
Death comes to all; grieving without end brings no peace. Seeing others' sorrow frees us from the selfishness of our own.
Key takeaways: the sermon teaches that death is universal and that peace comes by removing the arrow of grief. Its similes and symbols make the idea vivid. Modern writing agrees that grief is shared and that caring for others helps.
Check your understanding
-
1. What did the flickering city lights help Kisa Gotami understand?
- That the city was unsafe at night
- That human lives too begin and end
- That she should go home
- That the Buddha lived in the city
Show answer
Answer: B. Watching lights come on and go out, she reflected that people's lives flicker up and are extinguished in the same way.
-
2. The Buddha compares mortals to earthen pots that end up broken. This is:
- a metaphor
- personification
- a simile
- alliteration
Show answer
Answer: C. The comparison is made with 'as... so', the pattern of a simile, showing that every life ends.
-
3. According to the sermon, what does constant weeping lead to?
- Greater pain and suffering of body, without saving the dead
- Peace of mind
- The return of the dead
- Enlightenment
Show answer
Answer: A. The Buddha says weeping brings no peace; pain increases and the body suffers, yet the dead are not saved.
-
4. What does 'the arrow of lamentation' mean?
- A weapon used in war
- A kind of prayer
- A path to the river
- Grief that wounds us and must be drawn out to heal
Show answer
Answer: D. It is a metaphor: grief hurts like an arrow in the body, and peace comes when it is pulled out.
-
5. What idea do the sermon and Etzioni's essay share?
- Grief should be hidden from everyone.
- Comfort comes from looking beyond one's own grief to others.
- Anger is always wrong.
- Death can be avoided by medicine.
Show answer
Answer: B. Kisa Gotami sees the grief of others; Etzioni's family focuses on what they can do for one another.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.