- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Why classify elements: triads, octaves and Mendeleev's periodic law
Trace how chemists moved from Döbereiner's triads and Newlands' octaves to Mendeleev's periodic law, and explain why Mendeleev left gaps and successfully predicted gallium and germanium.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why chemists needed a way to classify the elements.
- Describe Döbereiner's triads and Newlands' law of octaves, and test them with atomic weights.
- State Mendeleev's periodic law and describe how he built his table.
- Explain why Mendeleev left gaps and how his predictions for eka-aluminium and eka-silicon were confirmed.
Imagine trying to learn the chemistry of more than a hundred elements and the millions of compounds they form, one at a time. In 1800 only about 31 elements were known; by 1865 the number had doubled to 63, and today 118 elements have been named. No student, and no scientist, can remember each one separately. Chemists therefore looked for a system: a way of grouping elements so that knowing one member of a family tells you a great deal about the others. A good classification does two jobs. It organises facts already known, and it predicts facts not yet discovered. This lesson follows the early attempts that led to the periodic law.
Döbereiner's triads (1829)
The German chemist Johann Döbereiner was the first to notice trends among similar elements. He found several groups of three elements, which he called triads, in which the elements had closely related properties. In each triad, the atomic weight of the middle element was roughly the average of the other two, and its properties were also in between. Lithium, sodium and potassium formed one triad; calcium, strontium and barium another; chlorine, bromine and iodine a third. The idea was attractive, but it worked for only a handful of elements, so most chemists treated it as a coincidence.
Worked example 1: testing a triad with atomic weights
Take sulphur (32.1), selenium (79.0) and tellurium (127.6), three elements with similar chemistry. Step 1: average the outer two: (32.1 + 127.6) ÷ 2 = 159.7 ÷ 2 = 79.85. Step 2: compare with the middle element: 79.85 is very close to selenium's 79.0, a difference of about 1%. So these three behave like a Döbereiner triad. Now try lithium (6.9), sodium (23.0) and potassium (39.1): (6.9 + 39.1) ÷ 2 = 46.0 ÷ 2 = 23.0, an almost exact match. Finally, try nitrogen (14.0), phosphorus (31.0) and arsenic (74.9), which are also chemically related: (14.0 + 74.9) ÷ 2 = 88.9 ÷ 2 = 44.45, far from 31.0. The rule fails here, which shows why triads could not become a general law.
De Chancourtois and Newlands' law of octaves
In 1862 the French geologist A. E. B. de Chancourtois arranged the known elements in order of increasing atomic weight around a cylinder, so that similar elements fell roughly one above another. His work received little attention. In 1865 the English chemist John Newlands arranged the elements in order of increasing atomic weight and noticed that every eighth element had properties similar to the first, just as the eighth note of a musical scale repeats the first. He called this the law of octaves. It held well for the lighter elements but broke down after calcium. Although his idea was not accepted at the time, the Royal Society later honoured him with the Davy Medal in 1887.
Worked example 2: counting octaves
Write the lighter elements in order of atomic weight as Newlands knew them (the noble gases were not yet discovered): Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F, Na, Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl, K, Ca. Count lithium as the first note. Counting Li (1), Be (2), B (3), C (4), N (5), O (6), F (7), Na (8): sodium is the eighth, and it is indeed a soft, reactive metal like lithium. Start again at fluorine: F (1), Na (2), Mg (3), Al (4), Si (5), P (6), S (7), Cl (8): chlorine is the eighth, and it is a reactive non-metal like fluorine. Beyond calcium, however, heavier metals such as iron did not fall into neat families of eight, so the pattern collapsed.
Mendeleev, Lothar Meyer and the periodic law (1869)
Working independently, the Russian chemist Dmitri Mendeleev (1834–1907) and the German chemist Lothar Meyer (1830–1895) proposed in 1869 that when elements are arranged by increasing atomic weight, similar properties recur at regular intervals. Lothar Meyer plotted physical properties such as atomic volume, melting point and boiling point against atomic weight and obtained a repeating pattern. Unlike Newlands, he noticed that the length of the repeating unit changes. Mendeleev, however, was the first to publish the law and is generally credited with the periodic table.
Mendeleev's periodic law: the properties of the elements are a periodic function of their atomic weights.
Mendeleev placed elements in horizontal rows and vertical columns in order of increasing atomic weight, so that elements with similar properties fell in the same vertical column, or group. His method was broader than Lothar Meyer's: he compared a wide range of physical and chemical properties and paid special attention to the formulas of compounds, such as oxides and chlorides. Two bold decisions made his table famous.
- He trusted properties over atomic weights. Iodine has a slightly lower atomic weight than tellurium, yet Mendeleev placed iodine with fluorine, chlorine and bromine, and tellurium with the oxygen family, because their properties demanded it. He suspected that some atomic weights had been measured wrongly.
- He left gaps for undiscovered elements. He left a gap below aluminium and one below silicon, named the missing elements eka-aluminium and eka-silicon, and predicted their properties. They were later discovered as gallium and germanium.
| Property | Eka-aluminium (predicted) | Gallium (found) | Eka-silicon (predicted) | Germanium (found) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atomic weight | about 68 | about 70 | about 72 | about 72.6 |
| Oxide formula | E₂O₃ | Ga₂O₃ | EO₂ | GeO₂ |
| Chloride formula | ECl₃ | GaCl₃ | ECl₄ | GeCl₄ |
| Melting point | Low | Low (about 303 K) | High | High |
Worked example 3: estimating a missing atomic weight from neighbours
A useful way to estimate a missing element's atomic weight, in the spirit of Mendeleev, is to average its four neighbours in the table. Eka-silicon sits below silicon (28.1), above tin (118.7), and between gallium (69.7) and arsenic (74.9). Step 1: add them: 28.1 + 118.7 + 69.7 + 74.9 = 291.4. Step 2: divide by 4: 291.4 ÷ 4 = 72.85. Germanium's atomic weight turned out to be about 72.6, within 0.4% of this estimate. Successful numbers like these convinced chemists that the periodic table reflected something real about the elements.
From triads to the periodic law
- Döbereiner, 1829 Triads: the middle element's atomic weight is about the average of the other two.
- De Chancourtois, 1862 Elements by atomic weight wound around a cylinder.
- Newlands, 1865 Law of octaves: every eighth element resembles the first; works up to calcium.
- Mendeleev and Lothar Meyer, 1869 Periodic law based on atomic weights; gaps left and new elements predicted.
Key takeaways
- Classification organises known facts about elements and helps predict new ones.
- Döbereiner's triads and Newlands' octaves each worked for only a limited set of elements.
- Mendeleev's periodic law states that properties are a periodic function of atomic weight.
- Mendeleev placed similar elements together even when that broke the atomic-weight order (tellurium and iodine), and left gaps for undiscovered elements.
- The discovery of gallium and germanium with the predicted properties made his table widely accepted.
Check your understanding
-
1. What pattern did Döbereiner notice in each of his triads?
- The three elements had consecutive atomic numbers
- The middle element's atomic weight was roughly the average of the other two
- Every eighth element resembled the first
- The three elements had the same atomic weight
Show answer
Answer: B. In a Döbereiner triad, such as lithium, sodium and potassium, the middle element's atomic weight is close to the mean of the other two, and its properties are in between. Atomic numbers were unknown in 1829, and the 'eighth element' idea belongs to Newlands.
-
2. Calcium (40.1), strontium and barium (137.3) form a Döbereiner triad. What atomic weight does the triad rule predict for strontium?
- 97.2
- 48.6
- 88.7
- 177.4
Show answer
Answer: C. Average the outer two: (40.1 + 137.3) ÷ 2 = 177.4 ÷ 2 = 88.7. The measured atomic weight of strontium is about 87.6, close to this prediction.
-
3. Newlands' law of octaves was found to hold well only for elements up to:
- iron
- uranium
- oxygen
- calcium
Show answer
Answer: D. Newlands' pattern of similar properties every eighth element worked for the lighter elements but broke down after calcium, where heavier metals did not fit into families of eight.
-
4. Why did Mendeleev place iodine after tellurium even though iodine has the lower atomic weight?
- Iodine's properties closely resemble those of fluorine, chlorine and bromine
- Iodine has the higher atomic number, which Mendeleev used
- Tellurium was undiscovered in 1869
- He arranged elements in alphabetical order within a group
Show answer
Answer: A. Mendeleev's priority was to keep elements with similar properties in the same group. Iodine behaves like the halogens, so he put it in their group and placed tellurium with the oxygen family. Atomic numbers were not known in his time.
-
5. Assertion (A): Mendeleev left some places empty in his periodic table. Reason (R): He believed that some elements had not yet been discovered.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both statements are true. Mendeleev left gaps (for example below aluminium and silicon) precisely because he expected undiscovered elements to fill them, so R correctly explains A. Gallium and germanium later filled two of these gaps.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.