- Foundation
- About 25 min
- 5 practice questions
Organic reaction mechanism: bond fission, reactive intermediates, reagents and electron displacement effects
Describe heterolytic and homolytic fission, carbocations, carbanions and free radicals, nucleophiles and electrophiles, curved arrows, the inductive, resonance, electromeric and hyperconjugation effects, and the four types of organic reaction.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the substrate and the reagent and explain what a reaction mechanism describes.
- Compare heterolytic and homolytic fission and the carbocations, carbanions and free radicals they give.
- Classify reagents as nucleophiles or electrophiles and use curved arrows.
- Explain the inductive, resonance (mesomeric), electromeric and hyperconjugation effects and use them to compare stability and acidity.
- Recognise substitution, addition, elimination and rearrangement reactions.
Knowing how a reaction happens lets a chemist predict products and plan syntheses. In an organic reaction the organic molecule, the substrate, meets an attacking reagent; bonds break and form, often through a short-lived intermediate, to give products and by-products. The substrate is the reactant that supplies carbon to the new bond. In CH₂=CH₂ + Br₂ → BrCH₂–CH₂Br, ethene is the substrate and bromine the reagent. A step-by-step account of electron movement, energy changes and rates is the reaction mechanism.
General course of an organic reaction
- Substrate + attacking reagent The organic molecule meets the reagent at its reactive site.
- Bond fission A covalent bond to carbon breaks heterolytically or homolytically.
- Intermediate A carbocation, carbanion or free radical, short-lived and reactive.
- Product(s) + by-products New bonds form to give the final substances.
Two ways to break a covalent bond
In heterolytic cleavage the shared pair stays with one fragment. CH₃–Br gives CH₃⁺ and Br⁻: the carbon is left with only six electrons and a positive charge, a carbocation. Carbocations are primary, secondary or tertiary as one, two or three carbons are joined to the positive carbon, for example CH₃CH₂⁺ (ethyl, 1°), (CH₃)₂CH⁺ (isopropyl, 2°) and (CH₃)₃C⁺ (tert-butyl, 3°). The positive carbon is sp² hybridised and planar, with an empty p orbital perpendicular to the plane. If instead the carbon keeps the pair (a group leaves without its electrons), a carbanion forms; its carbon is usually sp³ with a lone pair and a distorted tetrahedral (pyramidal) shape. Reactions going through heterolysis are called ionic, heteropolar or polar reactions.
In homolytic cleavage each atom takes one electron of the pair, shown by half-headed 'fish-hook' arrows, giving neutral free radicals with an unpaired electron. Free radical stability increases from methyl to primary, secondary and tertiary. Such reactions are free radical, homopolar or non-polar reactions. All three intermediates are unstable and highly reactive.
The three reactive intermediates
-
Carbocation
- Formed by heterolysis
- Positive charge on carbon
- Six valence electrons (sextet)
- sp², trigonal planar, empty p orbital
- Stability 3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃⁺
-
Carbanion
- Formed by heterolysis
- Negative charge on carbon
- Eight electrons including a lone pair
- Usually sp³, pyramidal
-
Free radical
- Formed by homolysis
- Neutral
- Seven electrons, one unpaired
- Stability 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl
Nucleophiles and electrophiles
A nucleophile (Nu:, 'nucleus seeking') brings an electron pair to an electron-poor site: anions such as OH⁻, CN⁻, RO⁻ and carbanions, and neutral molecules with lone pairs such as H₂O, NH₃ and amines. An electrophile (E⁺, 'electron seeking') accepts an electron pair from an electron-rich site: carbocations, molecules with an incomplete octet such as BF₃ and AlCl₃, ions such as NO₂⁺, and the δ+ carbon of a carbonyl group or of a C–X bond in an alkyl halide. A curved arrow shows a pair of electrons moving; it starts at the pair (a lone pair or a bond) and ends where the pair goes.
Worked example 1: nucleophile or electrophile?
CN⁻ has a negative charge and a lone pair: nucleophile. H₂O has two lone pairs on O: nucleophile. NH₃ has a lone pair on N: nucleophile. AlCl₃ has only six electrons round Al: electrophile. CH₃⁺ has a carbon with a sextet: electrophile. Br⁺ is electron-deficient: electrophile. In CH₃CHO the carbonyl carbon is δ+ because O pulls the π electrons, so it is the electrophilic centre a nucleophile attacks.
Electron displacement effects
Electrons in a molecule can be displaced permanently by an atom or group in it (inductive effect, resonance effect, hyperconjugation) or temporarily when a reagent approaches (electromeric effect).
Inductive effect. In CH₃CH₂Cl the C–Cl bond is polar: C1 is δ+ and Cl is δ−. C1 then draws some electron density from the C1–C2 bond, so C2 becomes slightly positive (δδ+). This polarisation of one σ bond by a neighbouring polar σ bond is the inductive effect. It fades quickly with distance and is negligible beyond about three bonds. Relative to hydrogen, halogens, –NO₂, –CN, –COOH, –COOR and –OAr are electron-withdrawing (–I); alkyl groups such as –CH₃ and –C₂H₅ are electron-donating (+I).
Worked example 2: inductive effect and acid strength
Arrange 2-chlorobutanoic acid, 3-chlorobutanoic acid, 4-chlorobutanoic acid and butanoic acid by acid strength. When an acid loses H⁺, the negative charge on the carboxylate ion is stabilised if an electron-withdrawing group pulls charge away. Chlorine's –I effect is strongest when it is closest to –COO⁻ and weakens with each extra bond. Order: 2-chloro > 3-chloro > 4-chloro > butanoic acid. On the same reasoning, FCH₂COOH is stronger than ClCH₂COOH because fluorine is more electronegative.
Resonance. Some molecules cannot be shown by one Lewis structure. Benzene drawn with alternating single and double bonds should have two bond lengths, but all its C–C bonds measure 139 pm, between C–C (154 pm) and C=C (134 pm). The real molecule is a resonance hybrid of two equivalent structures. Canonical (contributing) structures are imaginary; the hybrid is lower in energy than any of them, and the difference from the most stable canonical structure is the resonance energy, largest when there are several equivalent contributors. In the methanoate (formate) ion, HCOO⁻, the negative charge is shared equally by both oxygens, so the two C–O bonds are identical. Rules: canonical structures keep the same positions of nuclei and the same number of unpaired electrons; a structure is more important if it has more covalent bonds, full octets, less separation of opposite charges, negative charge on the more electronegative atom and more dispersed charge.
Resonance (mesomeric) effect. In a conjugated system (alternating single and multiple bonds, or a lone pair next to a π bond, as in buta-1,3-diene, aniline and nitrobenzene) electrons are delocalised and polarity is passed along the chain. In the +R effect electrons move away from the group into the system: –halogen, –OH, –OR, –OCOR, –NH₂, –NHR, –NR₂, –NHCOR. In aniline this raises the electron density at the ortho and para positions. In the –R effect electrons move towards the group: –COOH, –CHO, >C=O, –CN, –NO₂; in nitrobenzene the ortho and para positions become electron-poor.
Electromeric effect (E). A temporary, complete shift of a π-electron pair of a multiple bond to one of its atoms, only while an attacking reagent is present, and undone when it leaves. In the +E effect the pair moves to the atom the reagent attaches to (H⁺ adding to an alkene). In the –E effect it moves to the atom the reagent does not attach to (CN⁻ adding to the carbon of C=O while the pair moves onto oxygen). When the inductive and electromeric effects oppose each other, the electromeric effect wins.
Hyperconjugation. σ electrons of a C–H bond on a carbon next to an unsaturated system or an empty p orbital spread into it. In CH₃CH₂⁺, a C–H bond of the methyl group lines up with the empty p orbital and shares its electron density, dispersing the positive charge. It is a permanent effect, also called no-bond resonance, and it also occurs in alkenes such as propene and in alkylarenes. More alkyl groups mean more such C–H bonds and more stabilisation.
Carbocation stability: (CH₃)₃C⁺ > (CH₃)₂CH⁺ > CH₃CH₂⁺ > CH₃⁺, with 9, 6, 3 and 0 C–H bonds available for hyperconjugation. In CH₃⁺ the empty p orbital is perpendicular to the plane of the C–H bonds, so no such overlap is possible.
Worked example 3: counting hyperconjugating C–H bonds
Compare (CH₃)₂C⁺CH₂CH₃ (a tertiary cation) with (CH₃)₂CH⁺. Count C–H bonds on carbons directly attached to the positive carbon. First cation: two CH₃ groups give 6 and the CH₂ gives 2, so 8. Second: two CH₃ groups give 6. The tertiary cation has more hyperconjugation and three electron-donating (+I) alkyl groups instead of two, so it is the more stable.
Types of organic reactions
| Type | What happens | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Substitution | One atom or group is replaced by another | CH₃Cl + OH⁻ → CH₃OH + Cl⁻ |
| Addition | Two molecules join across a multiple bond | CH₂=CH₂ + HBr → CH₃CH₂Br |
| Elimination | Atoms are removed from neighbouring carbons, forming a multiple bond | CH₃CH₂Br + KOH (alcoholic) → CH₂=CH₂ + KBr + H₂O |
| Rearrangement | Atoms or groups shift within a molecule, giving an isomer | The carbon skeleton or the position of a group changes |
Key takeaways
- Heterolysis gives carbocations (sp², planar) or carbanions (sp³, pyramidal); homolysis gives free radicals.
- Nucleophiles donate an electron pair; electrophiles accept one.
- Inductive effect: σ-bond polarisation, fades after about three bonds; resonance: π or lone-pair delocalisation in conjugated systems.
- Electromeric effect is temporary and needs a reagent; hyperconjugation is permanent and explains 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl.
- Reaction types: substitution, addition, elimination, rearrangement.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the hybridisation and shape of the positively charged carbon in a carbocation?
- sp³, tetrahedral
- sp², trigonal planar
- sp, linear
- sp³, pyramidal
Show answer
Answer: B. The positive carbon uses three sp² orbitals for its three σ bonds, which lie in a plane at 120°, and keeps an empty p orbital. Pyramidal sp³ describes a carbanion.
-
2. Which species is an electrophile?
- NH₃
- CN⁻
- H₂O
- BF₃
Show answer
Answer: D. Boron in BF₃ has only six valence electrons and accepts an electron pair, so BF₃ is an electrophile. NH₃, CN⁻ and H₂O each carry a lone pair to donate: nucleophiles.
-
3. Assertion (A): (CH₃)₃C⁺ is more stable than CH₃CH₂⁺. Reason (R): (CH₃)₃C⁺ has nine C–H bonds that can take part in hyperconjugation, while CH₃CH₂⁺ has three.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. More hyperconjugating C–H bonds spread the positive charge more, so R correctly explains A (the +I effect of the extra methyl groups helps in the same direction).
-
4. Which group shows a –R (electron-withdrawing resonance) effect when attached to a benzene ring?
- –CHO
- –OCH₃
- –NH₂
- –OH
Show answer
Answer: A. –CHO has a C=O π bond conjugated with the ring and pulls π electrons towards oxygen: –R. –OH, –NH₂ and –OCH₃ donate a lone pair into the ring: +R.
-
5. How many C–H bonds can take part in hyperconjugation with the empty p orbital of the isopropyl cation, (CH₃)₂CH⁺?
- 2
- 7
- 6
- 9
Show answer
Answer: C. Only C–H bonds on carbons attached to the positive carbon count. Two CH₃ groups give 2 × 3 = 6. The H on the positive carbon itself lies in the nodal plane of the p orbital and does not count; 9 belongs to the tert-butyl cation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.