- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Normal modes of strings and air columns, and beats
Find the natural frequencies (harmonics) of a string fixed at both ends and of air columns closed at one end or open at both, explain resonance, and calculate beat frequencies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Derive ν = nv/2L for a string fixed at both ends and name the fundamental and harmonics.
- Derive the natural frequencies of a pipe closed at one end (odd harmonics only) and of a pipe open at both ends.
- Explain resonance with a natural frequency.
- Derive and use ν(beat) = ν₁ − ν₂, including tuning problems.
A sitar string, a flute and a tabla each produce particular notes and no others. The reason is that their boundaries allow only certain standing waves. The most important feature of standing waves is that boundary conditions restrict the possible wavelengths and frequencies: a system has a set of natural frequencies, its normal modes.
String fixed at both ends
- Both ends, x = 0 and x = L, must be nodes. Nodes occur where kx = nπ, i.e. x = nλ/2.
- So L must be a whole number of half-wavelengths: L = nλ/2, n = 1, 2, 3, ….
- Allowed wavelengths: λₙ = 2L/n.
- Natural frequencies: νₙ = v/λₙ = nv/(2L), where v = √(T/μ) is the wave speed on the string.
String fixed at both ends: νₙ = n v/(2L), n = 1, 2, 3, … All harmonics are present. n = 1 is the fundamental (first harmonic).
The lowest frequency, v/(2L), is the fundamental mode or first harmonic; n = 2 is the second harmonic, and so on. A real string usually vibrates in a mixture of modes; where it is plucked or bowed decides which modes are strongest, which gives each instrument its character.
Air columns
In a pipe, a closed end is a displacement node (the air cannot move, though the pressure change there is largest), and an open end is a displacement antinode. Closed at one end: with the node at x = 0 and an antinode at x = L, L = (n + ½)λ/2, so λ = 2L/(n + ½) and ν = (2n + 1)v/(4L), n = 0, 1, 2, …. The fundamental is v/(4L) and only odd harmonics (3, 5, 7 … times the fundamental) occur. A glass tube partly filled with water is an example. Open at both ends: both ends are antinodes, which gives ν = nv/(2L), all harmonics, with fundamental v/(2L), twice that of a closed pipe of the same length.
| System | Fundamental | Harmonics present |
|---|---|---|
| String fixed at both ends | v/(2L) | All: 1, 2, 3, … |
| Pipe open at both ends | v/(2L) | All: 1, 2, 3, … |
| Pipe closed at one end | v/(4L) | Odd only: 1, 3, 5, … |
Strings and air columns can also be driven by an outside periodic source. If its frequency is close to one of the natural frequencies, the system vibrates strongly: resonance. A stretched drum skin (as in a tabla) has its own normal modes, fixed by the condition that its clamped rim cannot vibrate; finding them is harder because the waves are two-dimensional, but the physics is the same.
Worked example 1: a string and two pipes
(a) A string 0.80 m long fixed at both ends carries waves at 320 m s⁻¹. ν₁ = v/(2L) = 320/1.6 = 200 Hz; harmonics 400, 600, 800 Hz …. A 600 Hz source would excite its third harmonic. (b) A pipe 25 cm long closed at one end, with v = 340 m s⁻¹: ν₁ = v/(4L) = 340/1.0 = 340 Hz; next modes 1020 Hz and 1700 Hz. (c) The same pipe open at both ends: ν₁ = 340/0.50 = 680 Hz, then 1360 Hz, 2040 Hz ….
Beats
When two sounds of slightly different frequencies are heard together, we hear a tone at about their average frequency whose loudness rises and falls regularly. These are beats. Take s₁ = a cos ω₁t and s₂ = a cos ω₂t at one place. Using cos A + cos B = 2 cos[(A − B)/2] cos[(A + B)/2]: s = [2a cos ωb t] cos ωa t, with ωb = (ω₁ − ω₂)/2 and ωa = (ω₁ + ω₂)/2. If the frequencies are close, ωa ≫ ωb: the sound oscillates at the average frequency, but its amplitude 2a cos ωb t varies slowly. The loudness is greatest whenever cos ωb t = ±1, which happens twice per cycle of cos ωb t, so the number of loud moments per second is 2ωb/2π:
Beat frequency ν(beat) = ν₁ − ν₂ (the difference of the two frequencies).
Musicians tune two instruments by adjusting one until the beats slow down and disappear.
Using beats to find an unknown frequency
- Count the beats ν(unknown) = ν(known) ± beat frequency: two possibilities.
- Change the unknown slightly Loading a fork with wax lowers its frequency; tightening a string raises it.
- Watch the beat rate Did the difference grow or shrink?
- Choose the consistent value Only one of the two possibilities fits the change.
Worked example 2: a tuning problem
Fork A (512 Hz) and fork B give 4 beats per second, so B is 508 Hz or 516 Hz. When B is loaded with a little wax, which lowers its frequency, the beats increase to 6 per second. If B were 516 Hz, lowering it would bring it closer to 512 Hz and reduce the beats. The beats increased, so B must be 508 Hz (it became about 506 Hz, 6 Hz below A).
Key takeaways
- String fixed at both ends and pipe open at both ends: νₙ = nv/(2L), all harmonics.
- Pipe closed at one end: ν = (2n + 1)v/(4L), odd harmonics only; fundamental v/(4L).
- A driving frequency near a natural frequency produces resonance.
- Beats: ν(beat) = ν₁ − ν₂; use a small known change to decide which side the unknown lies.
Check your understanding
-
1. A string 0.50 m long, fixed at both ends, carries waves at 200 m s⁻¹. What is its fundamental frequency?
- 100 Hz
- 400 Hz
- 200 Hz
- 50 Hz
Show answer
Answer: C. ν₁ = v/(2L) = 200/(2 × 0.50) = 200 Hz.
-
2. Which harmonics can be produced by an air column closed at one end?
- All harmonics
- Only odd harmonics
- Only even harmonics
- Only the fundamental
Show answer
Answer: B. The closed end is a node and the open end an antinode, so L = (n + ½)λ/2 and ν = (2n + 1)v/(4L): only odd multiples of the fundamental.
-
3. A pipe 17 cm long is closed at one end. Taking the speed of sound as 340 m s⁻¹, its fundamental frequency is
- 1000 Hz
- 250 Hz
- 2000 Hz
- 500 Hz
Show answer
Answer: D. ν₁ = v/(4L) = 340/(4 × 0.17) = 340/0.68 = 500 Hz.
-
4. Two tuning forks of 256 Hz and 260 Hz are sounded together. How many beats are heard per second?
- 4
- 258
- 516
- 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Beat frequency = ν₁ − ν₂ = 260 − 256 = 4 per second. 258 Hz is the average frequency of the tone heard.
-
5. Assertion (A): A pipe open at both ends has twice the fundamental frequency of a pipe of the same length closed at one end. Reason (R): The fundamental of an open pipe is v/(2L), while that of a pipe closed at one end is v/(4L).
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. An open pipe fits half a wavelength in its length (λ = 2L) while a closed pipe fits a quarter (λ = 4L). So v/(2L) is twice v/(4L), and R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.