- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Criticisms and limitations of the Constitution
Evaluate the three criticisms that the Constitution is unwieldy, unrepresentative and alien, distinguish the voice and opinion components of representation, state the three limitations the chapter identifies, and explain its conclusion about the Preamble and a shared vision.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Evaluate the criticisms that the Constitution is unwieldy and unrepresentative, using the distinction between voice and opinion.
- Evaluate the criticism that it is alien, using the ideas of innovative borrowing and alternative modernity.
- State the three limitations the chapter identifies and its conclusion.
No constitution is beyond criticism. The chapter examines three criticisms of the Indian Constitution, then admits three limitations, and finally explains why its philosophy remains intact.
Criticism 1: it is unwieldy
This criticism assumes that a country's entire constitution must be found in one compact document. But that is not true even of countries like the US, which have a compact constitution. A country's constitution includes a compact document and other written documents with constitutional status, and important constitutional practices exist outside the main text. India has put many such details into one document, which makes it large. Many countries, for example, do not include an election commission or a civil service commission in their constitutional document; India does.
Criticism 2: it is unrepresentative
When the Constituent Assembly was formed, adult franchise did not yet exist, and most members came from the advanced sections of society. Does that make the Constitution unrepresentative? The chapter distinguishes two components of representation:
Two components of representation
-
Voice
- People recognised in their own voice, not the masters' language
- Members chosen by restricted franchise
- On this count, unrepresentative
-
Opinion
- Range of views and interests expressed
- Debates covered a vast range of issues and social concerns
- On this count, not altogether lacking
On voice, the Constitution is indeed unrepresentative, because members were chosen by a restricted franchise, not universal suffrage. On opinion, it is not altogether lacking: the claim that almost every shade of opinion was represented may be a little exaggerated but has something to it, since members raised matters based on the interests of many social sections. The chapter also points out that statues of Dr Ambedkar holding a copy of the Constitution, found in many town squares, express a feeling among Dalits that the Constitution reflects many of their aspirations.
Criticism 3: it is alien
Some claim the Constitution is entirely alien, borrowed article by article from the West and out of tune with Indian culture; such voices were heard even in the Constituent Assembly, where one member lamented, in substance, that the Assembly had produced the music of an English band instead of the veena or sitar. The chapter accepts that the Constitution is modern and partly western, but argues it was innovative borrowing, not blind borrowing, and is not entirely alien for two reasons:
- Many Indians have adopted modern ways of thinking and made them their own; for some, westernisation became a protest against injustice in their own tradition. Rammohan Roy began this trend and Dalits continue it; as early as 1841, Dalits in northern India were noticed using the new legal system to bring suits against their landlords, adopting modern law to pursue dignity and justice.
- When western modernity interacted with local cultures, a hybrid culture emerged by creative adaptation, an alternative modernity found neither in the West nor in indigenous tradition. In drafting the Constitution, efforts were made to amalgamate western and traditional Indian values: a process of selective adaptation, not borrowing.
Limitations
The chapter admits that, given the conditions in which it was made, the Constitution is not perfect. It names three limitations:
- It has a centralised idea of national unity.
- It appears to have glossed over some important issues of gender justice, particularly within the family.
- It is not clear why, in a poor developing country, certain basic socio-economic rights were placed among the Directive Principles rather than made part of the Fundamental Rights.
These limitations can be explained or even overcome, but the chapter's point is that they are not serious enough to jeopardise the philosophy of the Constitution.
| Criticism or limitation | The chapter's response or comment |
|---|---|
| Unwieldy | Constitutions include more than one compact document; India put many matters, such as the election commission, into the text |
| Unrepresentative | True for voice (restricted franchise), not altogether for opinion (wide range of views) |
| Alien | Innovative borrowing and selective adaptation; Indians made modern ideas their own |
| Centralised unity; gender justice in the family; socio-economic rights only as Directive Principles | Real limitations, but not serious enough to jeopardise the Constitution's philosophy |
Conclusion: the Preamble and a shared vision
The core features give the Constitution its stature as a living document. Its institutional arrangements rest on a commonly agreed vision that emerged in the freedom struggle and was given legal form in the Constituent Assembly. Many say the best summary of this philosophy is the Preamble, which makes a humble claim: the Constitution was not given by great men but prepared and adopted by 'We, the people of India'. Despite bitter disputes between courts and governments, the centre and the States, and political parties, citizens and politicians still share the vision of living and prospering together on the basis of equality, liberty and fraternity. Making the Constitution in 1950 was a great achievement; keeping its philosophical vision alive may be ours.
Criticisms that the Constitution is unwieldy, unrepresentative or alien are only partly true; its real limitations (centralised unity, gender justice in the family, socio-economic rights left to the Directive Principles) do not undo its philosophy, best summed up in a Preamble that speaks for 'We, the people of India'.
Worked example 1: voice or opinion?
Evaluate: 'Because the Constituent Assembly was not elected by universal suffrage, the Constitution cannot represent the people.' Analysis using the chapter: on the voice component, the claim has force, since the franchise was restricted. On the opinion component, it is too strong, since the Debates show a vast range of views and concerns of many social sections. The chapter's balanced conclusion: partly unrepresentative in voice, but not altogether lacking in opinion.
Worked example 2: borrowed or adapted?
A made-up student says: 'We fought the British and then adopted their parliamentary system, so our Constitution is borrowed.' Response using the chapter: the freedom struggle opposed colonialism, not every idea associated with Britain. The framers adapted institutions to Indian needs and combined them with Indian commitments such as social justice and group rights. That is innovative borrowing and selective adaptation, an alternative modernity rather than imitation.
Worked example 3: identify the limitation
Which limitation does each made-up observation point to? (a) A law that gives daughters unequal shares in family property went unchallenged for years. (b) A right to adequate livelihood exists but cannot be enforced in court. (c) The centre holds wide powers over the States. Answers: (a) neglect of gender justice within the family; (b) socio-economic rights placed in the Directive Principles; (c) a centralised idea of national unity.
Key takeaways: the Constitution is large because it includes matters others leave out, so the charge of unwieldiness is weak. It is unrepresentative in voice but not altogether in opinion. It is modern and partly western but the product of innovative borrowing and selective adaptation. Its limitations are a centralised idea of unity, neglect of gender justice within the family and the placing of socio-economic rights among the Directive Principles. Its philosophy, summed up in the Preamble's 'We, the people of India', remains a shared vision of equality, liberty and fraternity.
Check your understanding
-
1. How does the chapter respond to the criticism that the Indian Constitution is unwieldy?
- It agrees that the Constitution should be shortened
- It says the US Constitution is longer
- It says the Constitution is very short
- It argues that constitutions everywhere include more than one compact document, and India simply put many such matters into its text
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says the criticism wrongly assumes a constitution must be one compact document; India included many matters, such as the election commission, in its text, which made it large.
-
2. On which component of representation does the chapter say the Constitution is indeed unrepresentative?
- Voice
- Opinion
- Both voice and opinion equally
- Neither
Show answer
Answer: A. Because members were chosen by restricted franchise, the Constitution is unrepresentative in voice; on opinion it is not altogether lacking.
-
3. What does the chapter mean by calling the Constitution's borrowing 'innovative'?
- It copied other constitutions word for word
- It rejected all foreign ideas
- It selectively adapted and amalgamated western and Indian values, producing something new
- It borrowed only from Britain
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter calls it innovative borrowing and selective adaptation: amalgamating western and traditional Indian values into an alternative modernity.
-
4. Assertion (A): The chapter considers the limitations of the Constitution not serious enough to jeopardise its philosophy. Reason (R): The Constitution is a perfect and flawless document.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: C. The assertion is true according to the chapter. The reason is false: the chapter expressly says the Constitution is not perfect and names three limitations.
-
5. Which of the following is NOT one of the three limitations of the Constitution identified in the chapter?
- A centralised idea of national unity
- The absence of universal adult franchise
- Placing some basic socio-economic rights among the Directive Principles
- Glossing over gender justice within the family
Show answer
Answer: B. The Constitution adopted universal adult franchise, which the chapter counts as an achievement; the other three are the limitations it names.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.