- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Indian secularism and principled distance
Compare the western idea of secularism as mutual exclusion with the Indian Constitution's secularism, explain its two departures (rights of religious groups and the state's power to intervene), define principled distance, and state three achievements of the Constitution.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the western conception of secularism as mutual exclusion and its purpose.
- Explain the two ways the Indian Constitution departs from it and why.
- Define principled distance and list three achievements of the Constitution described in the chapter.
Secular states are widely seen as treating religion as a purely private matter, refusing it any public or official recognition. Since the Indian Constitution recognises religious communities, is it not secular? The chapter's answer: it does not follow. Although the word 'secular' was not mentioned at first, the Indian Constitution has always been secular, but in its own way.
The western conception: mutual exclusion
The mainstream western conception means mutual exclusion of state and religion: each stays out of the other's internal affairs. The state does not intervene in religion, and religion does not dictate state policy. In other words, strict separation.
The purpose is to protect individual freedom. If the state supports organised religions, it makes them even more powerful. When religious organisations start dictating how individuals should pray or relate to God, individuals might turn to the state for protection, but a state that has joined hands with those organisations would not help. So the state must not help religious organisations. But it also must not tell them how to manage their affairs, since that too can thwart religious freedom. In short, states should neither help nor hinder religions, keeping them at arm's length.
The Indian alternative
Conditions in India were different, so the framers worked out an alternative conception, departing from the western model in two ways, for two reasons:
- Rights of religious groups. Inter-community equality was as necessary as equality between individuals, because a person's freedom and self-respect depend on the status of her community. If one community dominates another, its members are less free; if relations are equal, members live with dignity. So the Constitution gives all religious communities rights such as the right to establish and maintain educational institutions. Freedom of religion in India means the freedom of both individuals and communities.
- The state's power of intervention. Separation could not mean mutual exclusion, because religiously sanctioned customs such as untouchability denied people the most basic dignity. Such customs were so deeply rooted that only active state intervention could dissolve them. Intervention need not be negative: the state can also help communities, for example by giving aid to their educational institutions. So the state may help or hinder religious communities, depending on which promotes freedom and equality.
Principled distance
In India, separation between religion and state means not mutual exclusion but principled distance: the state keeps a distance from all religions so that it can intervene or abstain, depending on which would better promote liberty, equality and social justice.
Two conceptions of secularism
-
Western: mutual exclusion
- State and religion strictly separated
- State neither helps nor hinders religion
- Freedom of the individual is the focus
- Religion a private matter
-
Indian: principled distance
- State distant from all religions
- May intervene, e.g. against untouchability
- May help, e.g. aid to community schools
- Freedom of individuals and communities
Three achievements so far
The chapter sums up three core features, which can also be seen as achievements:
- The Constitution reinforces and reinvents liberal individualism, an achievement because it is done in a society where community values are often indifferent or hostile to individual autonomy.
- It upholds social justice without compromising individual liberties. Its commitment to caste-based affirmative action shows how far ahead India was: the chapter notes that affirmative action programmes in the US began after the 1964 Civil Rights Act, almost two decades after India entrenched them constitutionally.
- Against a background of inter-communal strife, it commits to group rights, the right to express cultural particularity, showing that the framers were ready to face the challenges of what decades later came to be called multiculturalism.
| Question | Western secularism | Indian secularism |
|---|---|---|
| Does the state recognise religious communities? | No; religion is private | Yes; communities have rights, e.g. to run educational institutions |
| Can the state intervene in religion? | No | Yes, to promote freedom and equality, e.g. abolishing untouchability |
| Can the state help religious bodies? | No | Yes, e.g. aid to their educational institutions, without favouring any |
| Guiding idea | Mutual exclusion | Principled distance |
Principled distance: the Indian state stays distant from all religions so that it can intervene, as against untouchability, or help, as with aid to community schools, whichever better promotes liberty, equality and social justice.
Worked example 1: which principles does India adopt?
Which of these are principles of secularism in the Indian Constitution? (a) The state has nothing to do with religion. (b) The state has close relations with a religion. (c) The state may discriminate among religions. (d) The state recognises rights of religious groups. (e) The state has limited powers to intervene in religious affairs. Answer: (d) and (e). (a) is strict mutual exclusion, which India rejects; (b) and (c) violate secularism, since the state must keep its distance from all religions and favour none.
Worked example 2: is this intervention justified?
A made-up law forbids a temple from refusing entry to people of any caste. A group claims the State is interfering in religion. Reasoning: under principled distance, the State may intervene when a religiously sanctioned custom denies basic dignity, as untouchability does. The intervention promotes equality and freedom, so it is consistent with Indian secularism, even though a strict mutual-exclusion model would forbid it.
Worked example 3: aid without favour
A made-up State gives grants to schools run by Hindu, Muslim, Christian and Sikh trusts on the same terms. Reasoning: helping religious communities' educational institutions is allowed in India, provided the State does not favour any one religion. Equal terms keep the State at a principled distance while supporting community rights.
Key takeaways: western secularism means mutual exclusion: the state neither helps nor hinders religion, to protect individual freedom. Indian secularism departs from this by recognising the rights of religious communities and by allowing the state to intervene, against practices like untouchability, or to help, through aid to community institutions. Its guiding idea is principled distance. Three achievements follow: reinvented liberal individualism, social justice without sacrificing liberty, and early commitment to group rights.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does the western conception of secularism, as described in the chapter, mean?
- The state managing all religious bodies
- The state supporting the majority religion
- Mutual exclusion of state and religion, so that the state neither helps nor hinders religions
- Religion dictating state policy
Show answer
Answer: C. The mainstream western conception is mutual exclusion: state and religion keep out of each other's affairs, and the state neither helps nor hinders religions.
-
2. Why did India need a state with the power to intervene in religious matters?
- To appoint priests
- Because religiously sanctioned customs such as untouchability denied basic dignity and needed active state intervention to end them
- To collect religious taxes
- To prefer one religion
Show answer
Answer: B. Deeply rooted customs like untouchability could not dissolve without state intervention, so separation in India could not mean mutual exclusion.
-
3. What is 'principled distance'?
- The state keeping equal physical distance from places of worship
- The state refusing all contact with religion
- The state staying distant from all religions so that it can intervene or abstain, whichever better promotes liberty, equality and social justice
- The state favouring the oldest religion
Show answer
Answer: C. Principled distance allows the state to intervene or abstain depending on which better promotes liberty, equality and social justice, while favouring no religion.
-
4. Assertion (A): Freedom of religion in India includes the freedom of communities, not only of individuals. Reason (R): The chapter argues that a person's freedom and self-respect depend on the status of her community.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because individual dignity depends on the status of one's community, the Constitution gives rights to religious communities as well as individuals.
-
5. According to the chapter, affirmative action programmes in the United States began after:
- the 1947 Independence Act
- the 1964 Civil Rights Act
- the 1928 Motilal Nehru Report
- the 1895 Constitution of India Bill
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter notes that US affirmative action began after the 1964 Civil Rights Act, almost two decades after India entrenched it constitutionally.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.