- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
What the philosophy of a constitution means
Explain why laws are connected with moral values, describe the political philosophy approach to the Constitution, show how constitutions can be means of democratic transformation, and explain why we still read the Constituent Assembly Debates.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the link between laws and moral values with examples.
- Describe the three elements of a political philosophy approach to the Constitution.
- Explain how a constitution can limit power, empower the deprived and express self-determination, and why the Constituent Assembly Debates remain relevant.
Why did the leaders of the national movement bind themselves and future generations to a constitution after winning independence? What kind of constitution did they give us, and does it have a moral content? Answering these questions means studying the philosophy of the Constitution.
Laws and values
Some people believe a constitution is only a set of laws, and that laws are one thing while values and morality are another, so the Constitution can be approached only legally, not philosophically. The chapter disagrees. Not every law has moral content, but many laws are closely tied to deeply held values. A law forbidding discrimination on grounds of language or religion exists because we value equality. So there is a connection between laws and moral values, and the Constitution should be seen as a document based on a moral vision.
A political philosophy approach
Taking a political philosophy approach to the Constitution involves three things:
- Understanding its conceptual structure: asking what terms such as 'rights', 'citizenship', 'minority' or 'democracy' can mean.
- Working out a coherent vision of society and polity from an interpretation of its key concepts, so that we grasp the ideals embedded in it.
- Reading the Constitution together with the Constituent Assembly Debates, to understand and refine the justification for its values, since a value is not fully treated philosophically without the reasons behind it.
This approach helps us find the moral content of the Constitution, evaluate its claims, and arbitrate between differing interpretations of core values. Ideals are debated, and sometimes manipulated for short-term partisan interest, in legislatures, party forums, the press, schools and universities, and different institutions may interpret the same ideal differently. Because the Constitution's expression of an ideal has great authority, it can serve as the arbiter in such conflicts.
Case box: Japan's 'peace constitution'
The chapter notes that Japan's Constitution of 1947 is popularly called the 'peace constitution'. Its preamble expresses a desire for peace for all time, and Article 9 renounces war as a sovereign right and the threat or use of force to settle international disputes, and says land, sea and air forces will never be maintained for that aim. The example shows how the context in which a constitution is made shapes the thinking of its makers.
Constitution as a means of democratic transformation
One widely agreed reason for having constitutions is to restrict power. Modern states are extremely powerful, with a monopoly over force; if their institutions fall into the wrong hands, they can be turned against the very people they were created to protect. Constitutions set the rules of the game so that this tendency is continuously checked and states do not become tyrannical. Constitutions also provide peaceful, democratic means of social transformation, and for a formerly colonised people they are the first real exercise of political self-determination.
Nehru understood both points. He argued that the demand for a Constituent Assembly was a demand for full self-determination, since only an Assembly of elected Indian representatives had the right to frame India's constitution without outside interference. He also described the Assembly not as a gathering of able lawyers but as a 'nation on the move', throwing away the shell of its past and fashioning a new garment of its own making. The Constitution was designed to break the shackles of traditional social hierarchies and usher in freedom, equality and justice. This changes the theory of constitutional democracy: constitutions exist not only to limit those in power but to empower those traditionally deprived of it.
What a constitution does, in the chapter's account
-
Limits power
- Rules of the game check the state
- Prevents tyranny
-
Transforms society
- Peaceful, democratic change
- Breaks traditional hierarchies
-
Expresses self-determination
- A colonised people frames its own rules
- A 'nation on the move'
-
Empowers the deprived
- Gives vulnerable people power to achieve collective good
Why go back to the Constituent Assembly?
Why should students of politics, not just legal historians, study the framers' intentions? The chapter gives two reasons. First, unlike the United States, whose constitution was written in the late eighteenth century, India's world has not changed so drastically since the framers: in values and ideals we have not separated ourselves from the Constituent Assembly, so the history of our Constitution is still a history of the present. Second, we may have forgotten the reasons behind many legal and political practices because we take them for granted. That is harmless when things go well, but when practices are challenged or threatened, neglecting their underlying principles can be harmful. So we must keep revisiting the political philosophy of the Constitution.
The Constitution rests on a moral vision. A political philosophy approach studies its concepts, the coherent ideals behind them and their justification in the Constituent Assembly Debates, which stay relevant because India's values have not changed drastically and because forgotten reasons matter when practices are challenged.
Worked example 1: is the law connected to a value?
Identify the value, if any. (a) Daughters and sons share equally in family property. (b) Different sales tax slabs apply to different goods. (c) No religious instruction in government schools. (d) No begar or forced labour. Answers: (a) equality, especially gender equality; (b) mainly an administrative choice, though it may reflect fairness in taxing luxuries more than necessities; (c) secularism, the State not favouring any religion; (d) freedom and dignity, the right against exploitation.
Worked example 2: relevant or not?
Three made-up opinions on reading the Constituent Assembly Debates. P: 'People are too busy to read legal debates.' Q: 'Conditions today are different, so using the framers' ideas brings the past into the present.' R: 'Our ways of understanding have not changed totally; the Debates give reasons why practices matter, and forgetting them is dangerous when practices are challenged.' Analysis: R argues the Debates are relevant, matching the chapter; Q argues they are not; P concerns accessibility, not relevance.
Key takeaways: many laws express values, so the Constitution has a moral vision. A political philosophy approach studies its concepts, the vision they form and their justification in the Constituent Assembly Debates, and can arbitrate between rival interpretations. Constitutions limit state power, enable peaceful transformation, express self-determination and, as Nehru saw, can empower the deprived. The Debates remain relevant because India's values have not changed drastically and because forgotten reasons are needed when practices are challenged.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why does the chapter reject the view that laws have nothing to do with values?
- Because all laws are religious
- Because many laws, such as a ban on discrimination by religion or language, exist because we value principles like equality
- Because values are always written into every law
- Because the courts make all laws
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says not all laws have moral content, but many are closely tied to values: a law against discrimination exists because we value equality.
-
2. Which of the following is NOT one of the three elements of a political philosophy approach to the Constitution?
- Understanding its conceptual structure
- Working out a coherent vision from its key concepts
- Reading it with the Constituent Assembly Debates to understand the justification of its values
- Counting the number of its articles and schedules
Show answer
Answer: D. The three elements are conceptual structure, a coherent vision, and justification through the Constituent Assembly Debates. Counting articles is not part of it.
-
3. What does the Japanese 'peace constitution' example illustrate, according to the chapter?
- That all constitutions are identical
- That Japan has no constitution
- That the context of making a constitution shapes the thinking of its makers
- That peace is impossible
Show answer
Answer: C. Japan's 1947 constitution, renouncing war in Article 9, shows how the context in which a constitution is made dominates the thinking of its makers.
-
4. Assertion (A): For a formerly colonised people, a constitution is the first real exercise of political self-determination. Reason (R): Nehru argued that only a Constituent Assembly of elected Indian representatives had the right to frame India's constitution without external interference.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: framing their own constitution through their own representatives, free of outside interference, is how a colonised people first exercises self-determination.
-
5. Why, according to the chapter, does India's Constitution remain 'a history of the present'?
- Because it was written very recently
- Because, in terms of values and ideals, we have not separated ourselves from the world of the Constituent Assembly
- Because it has never been amended
- Because it copies the US Constitution
Show answer
Answer: B. Unlike the US, where the eighteenth-century framers' world is very distant, India's values and ideals have not changed drastically since the Constituent Assembly.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.