• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Universal franchise, asymmetric federalism, national identity and procedural achievements

Explain how universal franchise grew from the national movement, how the Constitution's federalism is asymmetric and multilingual, how it balances national and other identities, and its procedural achievements of deliberation and principled compromise.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Trace the idea of universal franchise from the 1895 Bill and the 1928 Nehru Report.
  • Explain asymmetric and multilingual federalism with the chapter's examples.
  • Explain how the Constitution balances national and group identities, and describe its two procedural achievements.

The chapter identifies two more substantive achievements, universal franchise and a distinctive federalism, then shows how the Constitution balances identities, and finally turns to how it was made: its procedural achievements.

Universal franchise

Committing to universal franchise was no small achievement at a time when many believed India's traditional hierarchies were frozen and nearly impossible to remove, and when stable western democracies had only recently extended the vote to women and the working class. Once the idea of a nation took root, the idea of democratic self-government followed: Indian nationalism always imagined a political order based on the will of every member of society.

  • The Constitution of India Bill (1895), the first non-official attempt at drafting a constitution for India, declared that every citizen, anyone born in India, had a right to take part in the country's affairs and be admitted to public office.
  • The Motilal Nehru Report (1928) reaffirmed this, saying every person of either sex who had reached twenty-one was entitled to vote for the House of Representatives or Parliament.

So from very early on, universal franchise was seen as the most important and legitimate instrument for expressing the nation's will. In the Assembly, Alladi Krishnaswami Ayyar spoke, in substance, of adopting adult franchise with abundant faith in the common man and in the success of democratic rule.

Asymmetric federalism

Although the Constitution created a strong centre, it also anticipated asymmetric federalism: important constitutional differences in the legal status and prerogatives of different units within the same federation. Unlike the symmetry of American federalism, Indian federalism was designed from the start to have special relationships with some units to meet their particular needs. The article on the north-east (Article 371) is an example, and under Article 371A the State of Nagaland received special status: the article validates pre-existing laws there and protects local identity through restrictions on immigration. Many other States also benefit from special provisions. The chapter's view is that such differential treatment is not bad in itself.

Though not originally envisaged, India has also become a multilingual federation: every major linguistic group is politically recognised and treated as equal. So India's democratic and linguistic federalism combines claims to unity with claims to cultural recognition, allowing multiple identities to complement one another.

National identity

The Constitution constantly reinforces a common national identity, which it does not see as incompatible with religious or linguistic identities; it tries to balance them. Yet under certain conditions it prefers the common identity. The debate on separate electorates shows this: they were rejected not because they recognised differences between communities, nor because of a simplistic idea of unity, but because they endangered a healthy national life. Instead of forced unity, the Constitution sought true fraternity, a goal dear to Dr Ambedkar. Sardar Patel described the aim as evolving 'one community', hoping that in the long run people would forget there was any majority or minority.

Five substantive achievements of the Constitution

  • Liberal individualism
    • Freedoms rooted in a long struggle
  • Social justice
    • Reservations without sacrificing liberty
  • Group rights
    • Respect for diversity; multiculturalism
  • Universal franchise
    • Faith in every citizen
  • Asymmetric, multilingual federalism
    • Special provisions for some States
    • Equal recognition of languages

Procedural achievements

  1. Faith in political deliberation. Many groups were not adequately represented in the Constituent Assembly, yet the Debates show the framers' wish to be as inclusive as possible. This open approach shows a willingness to modify preferences and to justify outcomes by reasons rather than self-interest, and to see creative value in difference and disagreement.
  2. A spirit of compromise and accommodation. Compromise is not always bad. If a value is traded away for mere self-interest, that is compromise in the bad sense. But if one value is partly traded for another, especially through free deliberation among equals, the result can hardly be objected to; securing a bit of everything important is not blameworthy. A commitment to decide the most important issues by consensus rather than majority vote is also morally commendable.

Substantive achievements: liberal individualism, social justice, group rights, universal franchise and asymmetric federalism, all balanced with a common national identity built on fraternity. Procedural achievements: deliberation by reasons, and principled compromise and consensus.

Worked example 1: good or bad compromise?

Two made-up cases. (a) A committee drops a provision protecting workers' safety because a member's business would lose money. (b) A committee balances freedom of speech against public order by allowing reasonable restrictions after open debate. Reasoning: (a) trades a value for self-interest, which is compromise in the bad sense. (b) partially trades one value for another through free deliberation, which the chapter says can hardly be objected to.

Worked example 2: is special status unfair?

A student argues that special provisions for Nagaland are unfair to other States. Reasoning from the chapter: Indian federalism was designed to be asymmetric, meeting the specific needs of some units, such as protecting local identity and pre-existing laws. The Constitution treats such differential treatment as legitimate, and many other States also benefit from special provisions. Equal treatment of unequal situations is not always fair.

Worked example 3: why reject separate electorates?

Was it because the framers wanted to erase all differences between communities? Reasoning: no. The Constitution recognises communities and their rights. Separate electorates were rejected because they endangered a healthy national life, dividing voters by religion. The goal was fraternity, a unity that respects differences, not forced uniformity.

Key takeaways: universal franchise grew from the national movement, from the 1895 Constitution of India Bill to the 1928 Nehru Report. Indian federalism is asymmetric, with special provisions such as Article 371A for Nagaland, and multilingual. The Constitution builds a common national identity through fraternity rather than forced unity, as the rejection of separate electorates shows. Its procedural achievements are deliberation by reasons and principled compromise and consensus.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which document was the first non-official attempt at drafting a constitution for India, declaring that anyone born in India had a right to take part in the country's affairs?

    1. The Objectives Resolution
    2. The Government of India Act, 1935
    3. The Motilal Nehru Report (1928)
    4. The Constitution of India Bill (1895)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter names the Constitution of India Bill of 1895 as the first non-official attempt at drafting a constitution; the Nehru Report of 1928 later reaffirmed universal franchise.

  2. 2. What does 'asymmetric federalism' mean in the chapter?

    1. All States have exactly the same powers and status
    2. Different units of the same federation have constitutionally different status and prerogatives to meet their specific needs
    3. States have no powers at all
    4. The centre is weaker than the States
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Asymmetric federalism means constitutionally embedded differences in the status of different units, such as special provisions for Nagaland under Article 371A.

  3. 3. Why, according to the chapter, were separate electorates rejected?

    1. Because they recognised that communities differ
    2. Because the British demanded it
    3. Because they endangered a healthy national life
    4. Because they were too expensive
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says separate electorates were rejected not because they fostered difference or threatened a simple notion of unity, but because they endangered a healthy national life.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): A compromise in which one value is partially traded for another through free deliberation among equals cannot easily be objected to. Reason (R): Compromise is bad only when something of value is traded off for mere self-interest.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since the chapter defines bad compromise as trading value for self-interest, a value-for-value trade-off arrived at through open deliberation is acceptable.

  5. 5. Which is a procedural achievement of the Constitution, according to the chapter?

    1. Faith in political deliberation, justifying outcomes by reasons rather than self-interest
    2. Asymmetric federalism
    3. Universal franchise
    4. Reservations for SC and ST
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The procedural achievements are faith in deliberation and a spirit of compromise and accommodation; the others are substantive achievements.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery