Revision notes

Chapter 10 The Philosophy of the Constitution: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What the philosophy of a constitution means

What a constitution does, in the chapter's account

  • Limits power
    • Rules of the game check the state
    • Prevents tyranny
  • Transforms society
    • Peaceful, democratic change
    • Breaks traditional hierarchies
  • Expresses self-determination
    • A colonised people frames its own rules
    • A 'nation on the move'
  • Empowers the deprived
    • Gives vulnerable people power to achieve collective good

The Constitution rests on a moral vision. A political philosophy approach studies its concepts, the coherent ideals behind them and their justification in the Constituent Assembly Debates, which stay relevant because India's values have not changed drastically and because forgotten reasons matter when practices are challenged.

Key takeaways: many laws express values, so the Constitution has a moral vision. A political philosophy approach studies its concepts, the vision they form and their justification in the Constituent Assembly Debates, and can arbitrate between rival interpretations. Constitutions limit state power, enable peaceful transformation, express self-determination and, as Nehru saw, can empower the deprived. The Debates remain relevant because India's values have not changed drastically and because forgotten reasons are needed when practices are challenged.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Core features: individual freedom, social justice and respect for diversity

Classical liberalism and the Constitution's liberalism

  • Classical western liberalism
    • Individual rights come first
    • Social justice and community values are secondary
    • Communities usually not recognised in law
  • Liberalism of the Indian Constitution
    • Individual rights protected
    • Linked to social justice, e.g. reservations for SC and ST
    • Respects communities and recognises group rights
Three core features
Core featureRoots or reason in the chapterConstitutional expression
Individual freedomRammohan Roy's defence of a free press; opposition to the Rowlatt Act; Congress resolutions on rightsFreedom of expression, freedom from arbitrary arrest, freedom of conscience
Social justiceEquality alone could not undo age-old injusticeReserved seats in legislatures and reserved public jobs for SC and ST
Respect for diversityMany communities; none should dominateCommunity rights, e.g. religious communities' educational institutions, with aid

The Constitution's liberalism protects individual freedom, a commitment rooted in more than a century of struggle, but unlike classical liberalism it is joined to social justice and to respect for communities, so that no community dominates others.

Key takeaways: the Constitution's philosophy is liberal, democratic, egalitarian, secular and federal, committed to freedom, equality, social justice and national unity by peaceful means. Its commitment to individual freedom grew from a long history, from Rammohan Roy's defence of the press to opposition to the Rowlatt Act. Its liberalism is joined to social justice, as reservations show, and to respect for diversity through community rights that prevent any community dominating others.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Indian secularism and principled distance

Two conceptions of secularism

  • Western: mutual exclusion
    • State and religion strictly separated
    • State neither helps nor hinders religion
    • Freedom of the individual is the focus
    • Religion a private matter
  • Indian: principled distance
    • State distant from all religions
    • May intervene, e.g. against untouchability
    • May help, e.g. aid to community schools
    • Freedom of individuals and communities
Secularism compared
QuestionWestern secularismIndian secularism
Does the state recognise religious communities?No; religion is privateYes; communities have rights, e.g. to run educational institutions
Can the state intervene in religion?NoYes, to promote freedom and equality, e.g. abolishing untouchability
Can the state help religious bodies?NoYes, e.g. aid to their educational institutions, without favouring any
Guiding ideaMutual exclusionPrincipled distance

Principled distance: the Indian state stays distant from all religions so that it can intervene, as against untouchability, or help, as with aid to community schools, whichever better promotes liberty, equality and social justice.

Key takeaways: western secularism means mutual exclusion: the state neither helps nor hinders religion, to protect individual freedom. Indian secularism departs from this by recognising the rights of religious communities and by allowing the state to intervene, against practices like untouchability, or to help, through aid to community institutions. Its guiding idea is principled distance. Three achievements follow: reinvented liberal individualism, social justice without sacrificing liberty, and early commitment to group rights.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Universal franchise, asymmetric federalism, national identity and procedural achievements

Five substantive achievements of the Constitution

  • Liberal individualism
    • Freedoms rooted in a long struggle
  • Social justice
    • Reservations without sacrificing liberty
  • Group rights
    • Respect for diversity; multiculturalism
  • Universal franchise
    • Faith in every citizen
  • Asymmetric, multilingual federalism
    • Special provisions for some States
    • Equal recognition of languages

Substantive achievements: liberal individualism, social justice, group rights, universal franchise and asymmetric federalism, all balanced with a common national identity built on fraternity. Procedural achievements: deliberation by reasons, and principled compromise and consensus.

Key takeaways: universal franchise grew from the national movement, from the 1895 Constitution of India Bill to the 1928 Nehru Report. Indian federalism is asymmetric, with special provisions such as Article 371A for Nagaland, and multilingual. The Constitution builds a common national identity through fraternity rather than forced unity, as the rejection of separate electorates shows. Its procedural achievements are deliberation by reasons and principled compromise and consensus.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Criticisms and limitations of the Constitution

Two components of representation

  • Voice
    • People recognised in their own voice, not the masters' language
    • Members chosen by restricted franchise
    • On this count, unrepresentative
  • Opinion
    • Range of views and interests expressed
    • Debates covered a vast range of issues and social concerns
    • On this count, not altogether lacking
Criticisms and limitations
Criticism or limitationThe chapter's response or comment
UnwieldyConstitutions include more than one compact document; India put many matters, such as the election commission, into the text
UnrepresentativeTrue for voice (restricted franchise), not altogether for opinion (wide range of views)
AlienInnovative borrowing and selective adaptation; Indians made modern ideas their own
Centralised unity; gender justice in the family; socio-economic rights only as Directive PrinciplesReal limitations, but not serious enough to jeopardise the Constitution's philosophy

Criticisms that the Constitution is unwieldy, unrepresentative or alien are only partly true; its real limitations (centralised unity, gender justice in the family, socio-economic rights left to the Directive Principles) do not undo its philosophy, best summed up in a Preamble that speaks for 'We, the people of India'.

Key takeaways: the Constitution is large because it includes matters others leave out, so the charge of unwieldiness is weak. It is unrepresentative in voice but not altogether in opinion. It is modern and partly western but the product of innovative borrowing and selective adaptation. Its limitations are a centralised idea of unity, neglect of gender justice within the family and the placing of socio-economic rights among the Directive Principles. Its philosophy, summed up in the Preamble's 'We, the people of India', remains a shared vision of equality, liberty and fraternity.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery