• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Freedom of expression, bans and responsibility

Explain why freedom of expression is treated as part of the minimum area of non-interference, state Mill's four reasons for it, discuss the debate on bans and censorship, and link freedom with responsibility.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State J. S. Mill's four reasons for freedom of expression, even for ideas that seem false.
  • Explain the textbook's argument about the long-term harm of a habit of banning, and the questions it raises about censorship.
  • Distinguish constraints backed by organised authority from restrictions we accept willingly, and link freedom with responsibility.

One freedom that is widely considered part of the minimum area of non-interference is freedom of expression. It is also one of the most contested: demands to ban books, plays, films and even research articles arise again and again. The textbook treats this as a test case for everything in the chapter so far.

Mill's four reasons

John Stuart Mill, a nineteenth-century British political thinker and activist, offered a passionate defence of freedom of expression, including freedom of thought and discussion, in On Liberty. He gave four reasons why even ideas that seem false or misleading today should be freely expressed. In our own words:

  1. No idea is completely false. What seems false contains an element of truth; banning it loses that element.
  2. Truth emerges from conflict. Truth does not appear by itself; it comes out of the clash of opposing views. Ideas that seem wrong today may have helped produce the ideas we now think right.
  3. Conflict of ideas has continuing value. Truth always risks becoming an unthinking cliché; only by exposing it to opposing views can we be sure it is trustworthy.
  4. We cannot be sure what is true. Ideas once considered false by a whole society, and suppressed, have later turned out to be true. A society that suppresses all ideas unacceptable today risks losing valuable knowledge.

Mill's case for freedom of expression

  • Partial truth
    • No idea is wholly false
  • Truth through conflict
    • Opposing views produce truth
  • Guard against cliche
    • Truth must keep being tested
  • Fallibility
    • Suppressed ideas have proved true later

The textbook also recalls a famous saying attributed to Voltaire, which in substance says: I may disapprove of what you say, but I will defend your right to say it. It asks how deeply we are committed to this. Freedom of expression is a fundamental value, and society must be willing to bear some inconvenience to protect it from those who want to restrict it.

The debate on bans

The textbook gives examples of works that faced protests: a film on the plight of widows in Varanasi by film-maker Deepa Mehta, which could not be made there after protests and was later made elsewhere; and books, a film and a play (it names Ramayana Retold by Aubrey Menon, The Satanic Verses by Salman Rushdie, The Last Temptation of Christ and Me Nathuram Boltey) that were banned after protests from some sections of society. We note these only as the textbook's illustrations of the debate, not to take any side.

The textbook's argument is that banning is an easy short-term solution because it meets an immediate demand, but it is very harmful for the long-term prospects of freedom, because once a society starts banning it develops a habit of banning. Yet it also asks: does this mean we should never ban? Film censorship, which bans part of a film rather than the whole, is similar. So the real question is: when should one ban, and when not? Any constraint must be supported by proper procedures and important moral arguments.

Another case for discussion: in England, people employed in the Royal household are bound by contract not to write about its inner affairs, even after leaving. Is this an unjustifiable constraint on expression? The textbook's guidance helps here.

Coerced and accepted constraints

Two kinds of restriction

  • Backed by organised authority
    • Social, religious or cultural authority, or the might of the state
    • Restrict freedom in ways hard to fight against
  • Accepted willingly
    • Taken on to pursue our own goals or ambitions
    • Freedom not limited in the same way
    • If not coerced, freedom is not curtailed

Freedom and responsibility

The chapter ends by drawing the threads together. We began with freedom as the absence of external constraints; we now see that freedom embodies our capacity to make choices. Making choices means accepting responsibility for our actions and their consequences. That is why, the textbook says, most advocates of liberty hold that children must be in the care of parents. Our capacity to choose well, to weigh options with reason and shoulder responsibility, has to be built through education and the cultivation of judgement, just as it needs to be protected by limiting the authority of the state and society.

Freedom is the capacity to make choices, and choices bring responsibility. That capacity must be developed through education and judgement, and protected by limiting the authority of state and society.

— Key idea, in our own words

Worked example 1: applying Mill's reasons

In a made-up school debate, a student argues an unpopular view that homework should be abolished. Another says the view is 'obviously false' and the student should not be allowed to speak. Using Mill: (1) the view may hold some truth, for example about rest and play; (2) arguing against it may sharpen the case for well-designed homework; (3) defending homework against challenge stops it being an unthinking habit; (4) we cannot be sure the majority view is right. Conclusion: on Mill's reasons, the student should be heard.

Worked example 2: coerced or accepted?

A made-up athlete, Arjun, signs a contract with a club agreeing not to post about team selection on social media during the season. Reasoning: the restriction was accepted voluntarily to pursue his own goal of playing for the club, and he was not coerced. By the textbook's reasoning, his freedom is not curtailed in the way it would be by a state ban backed by force. Whether such a clause is fair in every case remains open to debate, as the Royal household example shows.

Key takeaways: freedom of expression is widely seen as part of the minimum area of non-interference. Mill gave four reasons to allow even seemingly false ideas: partial truth, truth through conflict, testing against cliche, and our fallibility. Banning meets short-term demands but builds a harmful habit; the hard question is when, if ever, a ban is justified, and it must rest on proper procedure and moral argument. Freedom is the capacity to choose, which brings responsibility and must be built through education.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of the following is one of Mill's four reasons for freedom of expression?

    1. Truth emerges only through the conflict of opposing views
    2. Only true ideas deserve to be heard
    3. Governments always know what is true
    4. False ideas contain no truth at all
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Mill argued that truth does not emerge by itself but through the conflict of opposing views. He also said no idea is completely false, so the remaining options contradict him.

  2. 2. According to the chapter, why is banning harmful in the long run?

    1. It is expensive
    2. It always fails to meet the immediate demand
    3. Once one begins to ban, one develops a habit of banning
    4. It increases the number of books
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says banning is an easy short-term solution but harmful for freedom in the long term, because it leads to a habit of banning.

  3. 3. Case: A person agrees, by a contract they freely signed, not to disclose a former employer's internal affairs. According to the textbook's reasoning, this is:

    1. always a serious violation of freedom
    2. a restriction backed by the might of the state
    3. a ban on a book
    4. a restriction accepted without coercion, which does not curtail freedom in the same way
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says that if we willingly accept restrictions to pursue our goals and are not coerced, we cannot claim our freedom has been curtailed, unlike constraints backed by organised authority or the state.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Most advocates of liberty hold that children must be placed in the care of parents. Reason (R): Making choices involves accepting responsibility, and the capacity to choose well has to be built through education and the cultivation of judgement.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter links the two: because choices bring responsibility and the capacity to choose well must be developed, advocates of liberty place children in their parents' care. R explains A.

  5. 5. Mill's point that truth risks becoming an 'unthinking cliche' means that:

    1. true ideas should be banned
    2. clichés are always false
    3. even true ideas must be exposed to opposing views to remain trustworthy
    4. debate is never useful once truth is known
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Mill's third reason is that the conflict of ideas has continuing value: only by exposing a truth to opposing views can we be sure it is trustworthy and not a mere cliché.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Freedom

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery