• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

The ideal of freedom: Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi

Explain what the struggle for freedom expresses, why social life needs some rules, and what the examples of Nelson Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi teach about the power of the ideal of freedom.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State what the struggle for freedom represents for individuals and for societies.
  • Explain why political theory tries to separate socially necessary constraints from other restrictions.
  • Describe what the textbook draws from the lives and books of Nelson Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi.

History is full of people and communities who were dominated, enslaved or exploited by stronger groups, and it is equally full of people who resisted. What is this freedom for which so many have been willing to suffer and even die? Chapter 2 of Political Theory opens with this question and then works towards a careful answer: what freedom means, why some limits on it are needed, and which limits can be justified.

What the struggle for freedom expresses

In essence, the textbook says, the struggle for freedom expresses people's desire to be in control of their own lives and destinies, and to have the chance to express themselves freely through their choices and activities. It is not only individuals who value this. Societies too value their independence and want to protect their culture and future.

Yet people have different interests and ambitions, so any form of social living needs some rules and regulation. Such rules may limit individual freedom, but the textbook notes that they can also free us from insecurity and give us the conditions in which we can develop ourselves. That is why much of the discussion of freedom in political theory tries to find principles for telling apart socially necessary constraints from other restrictions. A second debate concerns limits on freedom that come from a society's social and economic structures.

The main debates about freedom in this chapter

  • Meaning of freedom
    • Absence of constraints
    • Conditions to develop one's potential
  • Justified limits
    • Which constraints are socially necessary?
    • Who may impose them?
  • Structural limits
    • Social inequality, such as caste
    • Extreme economic inequality

Nelson Mandela: a long walk to freedom

Nelson Mandela's autobiography is titled Long Walk to Freedom. In it he describes his personal struggle against the apartheid regime in South Africa and the resistance of his people to the white regime's policies of segregation. The textbook lists some of the constraints imposed on black South Africans: being herded into townships, being denied easy movement around the country, and even being denied a free choice of whom to marry. Taken together, these formed a body of constraints that discriminated between citizens on the basis of race.

For Mandela and his colleagues, the long walk was the struggle to remove such unjust constraints, the obstacles to the freedom of all South Africans, the textbook stresses: not only black or coloured people but white people too. For this ideal Mandela spent twenty-seven years in jail, often in solitary confinement. The textbook asks us to imagine what this meant: giving up one's youth, friends, favourite sport (he loved boxing), clothes, music and festivals, and living alone in a cell without knowing when one would be released, only because one had campaigned for the freedom of one's people.

Aung San Suu Kyi: freedom from fear

The second example is Aung San Suu Kyi of Myanmar. According to the textbook, Gandhiji's ideas on non-violence inspired her while she was kept under house arrest, separated from her children and unable to visit her dying husband in England for fear that she would not be allowed back. She saw her own freedom as linked to the freedom of her people. Her book of essays is titled Freedom from Fear. Her central idea, in our words, is that real freedom means being free from fear, and that without it a person cannot live a dignified human life.

The textbook draws out what this implies for us: we should not be afraid of other people's opinions, of the attitude of those in authority, of how our community will react to what we want to do, of ridicule by our peers, or of speaking our minds. Yet we often show exactly such fears. A dignified life, on this view, requires overcoming them.

Two struggles for freedom (as the textbook presents them)

  • Nelson Mandela
    • Book: Long Walk to Freedom
    • Against apartheid in South Africa
    • Constraints based on race
    • 27 years in jail
  • Aung San Suu Kyi
    • Book: Freedom from Fear
    • Inspired by Gandhiji's non-violence
    • House arrest in Myanmar
    • Freedom from fear needed for dignity

From these two books, the textbook concludes, we can see the power of the ideal of freedom, the same ideal that stood at the centre of India's national struggle and of the struggles of the peoples of Asia and Africa against British, French and Portuguese colonialism.

The struggle for freedom expresses the wish of people and societies to control their own lives and destinies and to express themselves through their own choices.

— Key idea, in our own words

Worked example 1: identifying an unjust constraint

Which of these is the kind of constraint Mandela struggled against? (i) A rule that all drivers stop at red lights. (ii) A rule that people of one race may not live in certain areas. Reasoning: (i) applies to everyone equally and protects everyone's safety, so it frees us from insecurity. (ii) treats citizens differently because of race and blocks their movement and choices. Answer: (ii), a discriminatory constraint of the apartheid kind.

Worked example 2: applying freedom from fear

A made-up student, Tanvi, wants to join the school debating team but stays silent because she fears classmates will laugh at her accent. Applying Suu Kyi's idea: no law stops Tanvi, yet she is not fully free, because fear of peers' ridicule holds her back. The textbook lists fear of ridicule and of speaking one's mind among the fears to overcome. This shows freedom is not only about laws; it is also about the conditions in which people can express themselves.

Key takeaways: the struggle for freedom expresses the desire to control one's life and to express oneself; societies also value independence. Social life needs rules, so political theory seeks principles to separate necessary constraints from unjustified ones. Mandela's struggle against apartheid and Suu Kyi's idea of freedom from fear show the power of the ideal of freedom, which also inspired anti-colonial struggles in Asia and Africa.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Nelson Mandela's autobiography is titled:

    1. Freedom from Fear
    2. Hind Swaraj
    3. Long Walk to Freedom
    4. On Liberty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter names Mandela's autobiography Long Walk to Freedom. Freedom from Fear is Aung San Suu Kyi's book of essays, and On Liberty is by J. S. Mill.

  2. 2. According to the chapter, the constraints of the apartheid regime were unjust mainly because they:

    1. discriminated between citizens on the basis of race
    2. applied equally to all citizens
    3. were made by an elected parliament of all races
    4. concerned only traffic rules
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says the measures together formed a body of constraints that discriminated between citizens based on their race.

  3. 3. For Aung San Suu Kyi, as the chapter presents her view, real freedom is:

    1. the freedom to own property
    2. freedom from fear, without which one cannot live a dignified life
    3. the absence of all laws
    4. freedom to travel abroad
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Her book is titled Freedom from Fear, and the chapter presents her view that real freedom is freedom from fear, necessary for a dignified human life.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Rules and regulations are needed in any form of social living. Reason (R): Such rules can free us from insecurity and provide conditions in which we can develop ourselves.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. A is true, but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says diverse interests make rules necessary, and that such constraints may also free us from insecurity and allow self-development. R explains why rules, though limiting, are needed.

  5. 5. The textbook says Mandela struggled to remove obstacles to the freedom of:

    1. only black South Africans
    2. only the white rulers
    3. only people in jail
    4. all the people of South Africa, including white people
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter stresses that the struggle was for the freedom of all South Africans, not just black or coloured people but also white people.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery