• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

What is freedom? Two dimensions, Swaraj and sources of constraints

Define freedom as both the absence of external constraints and the presence of conditions for self-development, explain Swaraj, and identify the sources of constraints on freedom.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the two dimensions of freedom and what a free society would look like.
  • Explain the meaning of Swaraj and how Tilak and Gandhi used it.
  • Identify the sources of constraints on freedom, including domination and social and economic inequality.

Having seen the power of the ideal, we can now ask what freedom actually is. The textbook gives a simple first answer and then shows why it is incomplete.

Two dimensions of freedom

The simple answer is that freedom is the absence of constraints. A person is free, on this definition, when not subject to external controls or coercion, and able to make independent decisions and act autonomously. But this is only one dimension. Freedom is also about expanding the ability of people to express themselves and develop their potential: the condition in which people can develop their creativity and capabilities, in sports, science, art, music or exploration.

The two dimensions of freedom

  • Absence of external constraints
    • No coercion or external control
    • Able to decide independently
    • Later called negative liberty
  • Conditions for self-development
    • Opportunity to express oneself
    • Developing creativity and capabilities
    • Later called positive liberty

Both dimensions matter. The textbook describes a free society as one that enables all its members to develop their potential with the minimum of social constraints. Freedom is valuable because it lets us make choices and exercise our judgement, using our powers of reason.

Freedom is both the absence of unjustified external constraints and the presence of conditions in which people can develop their talents. A free society lets all its members develop their potential with the least possible social constraint.

— Key definition, in our own words

No one living in society can enjoy a total absence of restrictions. So we must decide which social constraints are justified and which should be removed. To do this, the textbook says, we must examine the relationship between the individual and society (or group, community or state): which features of society allow individuals to choose, decide and act, which do not, and which should go. We also need to ask whether the same principles apply to relations between individuals, groups and nations.

Swaraj: an Indian concept of freedom

The textbook presents Swaraj as a concept in Indian political thought similar to freedom. The word joins Swa (self) and Raj (rule), so it can mean both rule of the self and rule over the self. During the freedom struggle, Swaraj meant freedom as a constitutional and political demand, and as a value at the social-collective level. It became a rallying cry, inspiring Tilak's famous declaration that Swaraj was his birthright and he would have it.

Mahatma Gandhi emphasised Swaraj as rule over the self in Hind Swaraj (written in 1909), where he connected Swaraj with learning to rule ourselves. On the textbook's account, Swaraj is not only freedom but a liberation that recovers a person's self-respect, self-responsibility and capacity for self-realisation from dehumanising institutions. Understanding the real self and its relation to community and society is central to attaining it. Gandhiji believed the development that follows would free both individual and collective potential, guided by justice.

Two senses of Swaraj
SenseMeaningAssociated in the chapter with
Rule of the self (self-rule)Freedom as a constitutional and political demand; a collective valueThe national movement; Tilak's declaration
Rule over the self (self-control)Learning to govern oneself; recovering self-respect and self-responsibilityGandhi's Hind Swaraj (1909)

Where constraints come from

  1. Domination and external controls: imposed by force, or by a government through laws that express the rulers' power and may be backed by force. The textbook's examples are colonial rule and apartheid. Some government may be inevitable, but in a democracy people keep some control over their rulers, which is why democratic government is seen as an important means of protecting freedom.
  2. Social inequality: for example, the kind implicit in the caste system.
  3. Extreme economic inequality in a society.

The textbook quotes Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's presidential address to a students' conference at Lahore on 19 October 1929. In our own words, Bose called for all-round freedom: for the individual and society, rich and poor, men and women, all individuals and classes. Such freedom, he said, meant not only release from political bondage but also equal distribution of wealth, the end of caste barriers and social injustices, and the destruction of communalism and religious intolerance. The textbook uses this to show the need to remove social and economic constraints too.

Sources of constraints on freedom

  • Domination and external control
    • Force
    • Laws expressing rulers' power
    • Colonialism, apartheid
  • Social inequality
    • Caste system
  • Economic inequality
    • Extreme gaps in wealth

Worked example 1: which dimension is missing?

A made-up village has no law stopping anyone from becoming a doctor, but it has no school beyond Class 5. Are its children free to become doctors? Reasoning: the first dimension is satisfied, since there is no external constraint. The second is not: the conditions for developing their capabilities are absent. Conclusion: the children are free in the narrow sense only. The textbook's definition of a free society requires both dimensions.

Worked example 2: classifying sources of constraint

Classify: (a) a foreign ruler bans public meetings; (b) a person is refused entry to a temple because of caste; (c) a family cannot afford books for their child. Answers: (a) domination and external control through law and force; (b) social inequality; (c) economic inequality. Bose's idea of all-round freedom would require removing all three.

Key takeaways: freedom has two dimensions, the absence of external constraints and the presence of conditions for self-development; a free society combines both with minimum social constraint. Swaraj means both rule of the self and rule over the self; Tilak used it as a political demand and Gandhi stressed self-rule in Hind Swaraj (1909). Constraints come from domination and external control, social inequality and economic inequality; democracy helps protect freedom.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The word Swaraj is made of Swa and Raj, meaning:

    1. self and rule
    2. people and land
    3. freedom and duty
    4. law and order
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter explains that Swa means self and Raj means rule, so Swaraj means both rule of the self and rule over the self.

  2. 2. According to the textbook, a free society is one that:

    1. has no laws at all
    2. lets the strongest do as they please
    3. enables all its members to develop their potential with the minimum of social constraints
    4. is ruled by a single wise person
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter defines a free society as one which enables all its members to develop their potential with the minimum of social constraints.

  3. 3. Why is democratic government considered an important means of protecting freedom?

    1. Because it has no government
    2. Because members of the state retain some control over their rulers
    3. Because it removes all constraints
    4. Because it never makes laws
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says some government may be inevitable, but in a democracy members of a state can retain some control over their rulers, which protects their freedom.

  4. 4. Read: 'Freedom must mean release from political bondage and also equal distribution of wealth, abolition of caste barriers and the end of religious intolerance.' This idea of all-round freedom is attributed in the chapter to:

    1. Nelson Mandela
    2. J. S. Mill
    3. Aung San Suu Kyi
    4. Subhas Chandra Bose
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter quotes Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's 1929 address at Lahore calling for all-round freedom, including economic and social freedom.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Absence of constraints is a complete definition of freedom. Reason (R): Freedom is also about expanding people's ability to express themselves and develop their potential.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. A is false, but R is true
    3. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    4. A is true, but R is false
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says absence of constraints is only one dimension of freedom, so A is false. R is true: freedom also involves conditions for developing creativity and capabilities.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery