• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why constraints are needed and Mill's harm principle

Explain why society needs some constraints, state J. S. Mill's harm principle with its distinction between self-regarding and other-regarding actions, and explain 'reasonable restrictions'.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why no society can do without some constraints.
  • State the harm principle and distinguish self-regarding from other-regarding actions, and serious from minor harm.
  • Explain what 'reasonable restrictions' means and describe the main features of liberalism as the textbook presents it.

If freedom is so precious, why accept any limits at all? This lesson follows the textbook's argument that some constraints are unavoidable, and then examines one famous answer to the hard question of which constraints are justified: John Stuart Mill's harm principle.

Why we need constraints

Without any constraints, the textbook says, society would descend into chaos. People differ in ideas and opinions, have conflicting ambitions and compete for scarce resources. Disagreements can become open conflict over matters serious and trivial: road rage, parking spaces, housing or land, or whether a film should be screened, sometimes even leading to loss of life. So every society needs mechanisms to control violence and settle disputes.

As long as we respect each other's views and do not try to impose ours, we can live freely with minimum constraints. But even such a society needs one basic constraint: a willingness to respect differences of views, opinions and beliefs. When people feel that strong commitment to their beliefs requires opposing everyone who differs, we need legal and political restraints so that differences can be debated without one group coercively imposing its views. If someone tries to bully or harass us into conforming, we may need stronger legal support to protect our freedom.

This leaves the key questions: Which constraints are necessary and justifiable? What external authority may rightly say what can and cannot be done? Are there areas of life that should be left free of all external constraint?

The harm principle

To answer, the textbook turns to John Stuart Mill and his essay On Liberty. Mill's position, known in political theory as the harm principle, can be put in our own words: the only reason that justifies anyone, individually or collectively, interfering with a person's liberty of action against that person's will is self-protection, that is, to prevent harm to others.

Harm principle (J. S. Mill): power may rightly be used against a person's will only to prevent harm to others. Actions that affect only oneself should be left alone.

— Mill's idea, in our own words

Mill draws an important distinction:

Mill's distinction

  • Self-regarding actions
    • Consequences only for the person acting
    • No business of the state or any external authority
    • 'It is my business if it does not affect you'
  • Other-regarding actions
    • Consequences for others as well
    • May cause harm to others
    • Some case for external interference, e.g. by the state

But because freedom is at the core of human society and essential to a dignified life, Mill holds that it should be constrained only in special circumstances: the harm must be serious. For minor harm, Mill recommends only social disapproval, not the force of law. The textbook's example is loud music in an apartment building: it stops neighbours from talking, sleeping or enjoying their own music, but this is minor harm. Neighbours may show disapproval, perhaps by not greeting the person, but should not call the police. Legal force is for other-regarding actions that cause serious harm to definite individuals; otherwise society must bear some inconvenience to protect freedom.

Applying the harm principle (our summary)

  1. Does the action affect others? If it affects only the person acting, do not interfere.
  2. Does it harm them? Other-regarding actions that cause no harm should be tolerated.
  3. Is the harm serious? Minor harm: social disapproval only.
  4. Serious harm to definite individuals Legal constraint may be used, but in proportion.

People should tolerate different ways of life, views and interests as long as they cause no harm to others. Tolerance need not extend to views and actions that endanger people or stir up hatred against them: hate campaigns cause serious harm to others' freedom. Even then, the textbook warns, the constraint must not be so severe that it destroys freedom itself. It suggests, for instance, that life imprisonment would be excessive for someone who only conducts a hate campaign; some restriction on movement or on holding public meetings might be considered, especially if the person ignores warnings to stop.

Reasonable restrictions

In Indian constitutional discussion, justifiable constraints are called reasonable restrictions. They must be capable of being defended by reason, not excessive and not out of proportion to the action restricted, because otherwise they would damage the general condition of freedom in society. The textbook adds a warning: we must not develop a habit of imposing restrictions, since such a habit harms freedom.

Liberalism (as the textbook explains it)

  • In everyday speech 'liberal' parents are tolerant ones; as a political ideology, liberalism has been identified with tolerance, defending people's right to hold and express views even when liberals disagree with them. But liberalism is not only tolerance, and it is not the only modern ideology that supports tolerance.
  • Its most distinctive feature is its focus on the individual: family, society and community have value only if individuals value them. For example, liberals would say the decision whom to marry should be taken by the individual, not the family, caste or community.
  • Liberals tend to give priority to individual liberty over values like equality and tend to be suspicious of political authority.
  • Historically, liberalism favoured the free market and a minimal state; present-day liberalism, the textbook notes, accepts a role for the welfare state and measures to reduce social and economic inequalities.

Worked example 1: self-regarding or other-regarding?

Classify, using Mill's distinction: (a) a man (made up) decides to grow a beard; (b) a factory dumps waste into a river used by a village. Reasoning: (a) affects only the man himself, so it is self-regarding and no authority should interfere. (b) affects definite others and causes serious harm to their health and livelihood, so it is other-regarding and serious; legal constraint is justified under the harm principle.

Worked example 2: serious or minor, and what response?

A neighbour (made up) bursts loud crackers at midnight once a year at a festival. Is legal punishment justified on Mill's principle? Step 1: it is other-regarding (others are disturbed). Step 2: the harm is inconvenience, like the textbook's loud-music example, so it is minor. Step 3: the response should be social disapproval, not the police. Note: if the action endangered people's safety, the harm might become serious; then a proportionate legal restriction could be reasonable.

Key takeaways: constraints are needed to control violence, settle disputes and ensure that differences are debated rather than imposed. Mill's harm principle allows interference only to prevent harm to others: self-regarding actions are free from interference; other-regarding actions causing serious harm may be legally constrained, while minor harm calls only for social disapproval. Indian constitutional language speaks of reasonable restrictions: defensible by reason and proportionate.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Mill's harm principle is set out in his essay:

    1. The Republic
    2. Hind Swaraj
    3. Freedom from Fear
    4. On Liberty
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says J. S. Mill stated the harm principle in his essay On Liberty.

  2. 2. According to Mill, an action whose consequences affect only the person doing it is:

    1. a self-regarding action, in which no external authority should interfere
    2. an other-regarding action that the state must punish
    3. always a serious harm
    4. a reasonable restriction
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Mill calls actions with consequences only for the actor self-regarding, and says the state or any external authority has no business to interfere with them.

  3. 3. Case: Residents of a building complain that a neighbour plays loud music late at night. Following Mill as the chapter explains him, the right response is:

    1. life imprisonment
    2. immediate police action
    3. social disapproval, since the harm is minor
    4. no response, since music is always self-regarding
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter uses exactly this example: playing loud music causes minor harm and should bring social disapproval from the residents, not the police.

  4. 4. In Indian constitutional discussions, justifiable constraints on freedom are called:

    1. absolute bans
    2. reasonable restrictions
    3. self-regarding actions
    4. positive liberties
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the term used is reasonable restrictions: they must be defensible by reason, not excessive and not out of proportion to the action restricted.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Liberals would say the decision whom to marry should be taken by the individual rather than the family or community. Reason (R): Modern liberalism focuses on the individual and treats entities like family and community as valuable only if individuals value them.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both statements are in the chapter's box on liberalism, and R explains A: because liberalism focuses on the individual, it gives the individual the decision about marriage.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Negative and positive liberty

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery