- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Cultural and educational rights, constitutional remedies and the NHRC
Explain the rights of religious and linguistic minorities, the right to constitutional remedies and the five writs, and the role of national commissions and the National Human Rights Commission in protecting rights.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain who counts as a minority and what cultural and educational rights they have.
- Explain why the right to constitutional remedies is called the heart and soul of the Constitution.
- Match each of the five writs to its purpose and describe the role and limits of the NHRC.
A long list of rights would mean little in a diverse society if minorities had to give up their culture, or if there were no way to enforce rights when they are violated. This lesson covers the rights that protect diversity and the machinery that makes all rights real.
Cultural and educational rights
India is not a monolithic society. In any diverse society some groups are smaller than others. Must a minority adopt the culture of the majority? The Constitution answers no: it treats diversity as a strength, and one Fundamental Right is the right of minorities to maintain their culture. Minority status is not based only on religion; linguistic and cultural minorities are included. The chapter defines minorities as groups that share a language or religion and are outnumbered by some other section, either in a particular part of the country or in the country as a whole.
- Minorities with a distinct language, script or culture have the right to conserve and develop them.
- All minorities, religious or linguistic, can set up their own educational institutions to preserve and develop their culture.
- When granting aid, government will not discriminate against an institution because it is managed by a minority community.
A cartoon voice in the chapter notes that the same person can be a minority in one sense and a majority in another, by locality, town, language or religion. Minority status depends on the context.
Right to constitutional remedies
Writing down rights is not enough; there must be a way to realise and defend them. The right to constitutional remedies (Article 32) does this. Dr B.R. Ambedkar called it the 'heart and soul' of the Constitution, because it gives every citizen the right to approach a High Court or the Supreme Court to get Fundamental Rights restored when they are violated. The courts can issue orders and directions to government, including special orders called writs.
| Writ | Meaning in plain words | When it is used |
|---|---|---|
| Habeas corpus | Produce the person before the court | The court orders an arrested person to be presented before it, and can free the person if the arrest is unlawful |
| Mandamus | A command to do one's duty | An office holder is not doing a legal duty and thereby infringes someone's right |
| Prohibition | A stop order to a lower court | A higher court (High Court or Supreme Court) finds a lower court acting beyond its jurisdiction |
| Quo warranto | By what authority? | A person is holding an office he or she is not entitled to; the court restrains him or her from acting |
| Certiorari | Send the case up | The court orders a lower court or authority to transfer a pending matter to a higher court or authority |
How a violated right is restored
- Right violated A Fundamental Right is infringed by an authority.
- Approach the court The citizen moves the High Court or the Supreme Court.
- Court examines The court checks whether the right was violated.
- Writ or order issued For example habeas corpus, mandamus or quo warranto.
- Right restored Government must comply with the court's order.
Other institutions that protect rights
Apart from the courts, later years saw other mechanisms, such as national commissions for minorities, for women and for Scheduled Castes, which protect the rights of these groups. Independent organisations such as the People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) and the People's Union for Democratic Rights (PUDR) act as watchdogs against rights violations. Against this background, government set up the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) in 1993, by law, to protect fundamental and other rights.
According to the textbook, the NHRC is composed of a former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, a former Supreme Court judge, a former Chief Justice of a High Court, and two other members with knowledge and practical experience of human rights. Its functions include inquiring, on its own initiative or on a victim's petition, into complaints of human rights violations; visiting jails to study the conditions of inmates; and undertaking and promoting research on human rights. It receives thousands of complaints a year, about matters such as custodial deaths, disappearances, police excesses, failure to act and indignity to women. Its key limitation: it has no power of prosecution. It can only make recommendations to government, or recommend that courts start proceedings, based on its inquiry.
Right to constitutional remedies: any citizen can move the High Court or the Supreme Court to restore a violated Fundamental Right; the courts may issue writs such as habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto and certiorari. Ambedkar called it the heart and soul of the Constitution.
Worked example 1: choose the writ
Name the writ in each made-up case. (a) A person is detained and his family cannot find out where he is held or why. (b) A municipal officer refuses, without any legal reason, to issue a licence the law requires him to issue. (c) A person continues to act as chairperson of a public body though he is not qualified to hold the post. (d) A district court starts hearing a matter outside its legal powers. Working: (a) habeas corpus; (b) mandamus; (c) quo warranto; (d) prohibition.
Worked example 2: is the school's policy valid?
A made-up society of Telugu speakers runs a Telugu-medium school in another State. A rule is proposed that minority-run schools will receive no government aid. Reasoning: linguistic minorities have the right to establish educational institutions, and government must not discriminate against an institution in granting aid because it is managed by a minority. So the proposed rule would violate cultural and educational rights. Note also that the right is to establish institutions, not to keep children of other groups out of them.
Worked example 3: what can the NHRC do?
The NHRC inquires into a complaint and finds that a person died in custody because of police excess. Reasoning: the Commission cannot itself prosecute the police officers. It can recommend action to government or recommend that the courts start proceedings. Its power lies in investigation, publicity and recommendation.
Key takeaways: religious and linguistic minorities have the right to conserve their language, script and culture and to establish their own educational institutions without discrimination in aid. The right to constitutional remedies lets citizens approach the High Courts and the Supreme Court, which may issue five kinds of writs. Commissions and the NHRC, set up in 1993, add protection, but the NHRC can only recommend, not prosecute.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which right did Dr B.R. Ambedkar call the 'heart and soul' of the Constitution?
- Right to Equality
- Right to Freedom of Religion
- Right to Constitutional Remedies
- Right against Exploitation
Show answer
Answer: C. Ambedkar described the right to constitutional remedies as the heart and soul of the Constitution because it lets citizens approach the courts to restore any violated Fundamental Right.
-
2. Which writ does a court issue when a person is holding an office he or she is not entitled to hold?
- Quo warranto
- Habeas corpus
- Certiorari
- Mandamus
Show answer
Answer: A. Quo warranto ('by what authority') is issued when a person holds an office without being entitled to it; the court restrains him or her from acting in that office.
-
3. Which statement about the minority rights in the chapter is correct?
- Only religious minorities are protected
- Minorities may set up their own educational institutions, and aid will not be denied because a minority manages them
- Minority institutions may admit only children of their own community
- Government schools must teach every minority's religion
Show answer
Answer: B. Both religious and linguistic minorities may establish educational institutions, and government will not discriminate against them in granting aid. The right does not require excluding others or teaching religion in government schools.
-
4. Assertion (A): The National Human Rights Commission cannot itself punish those who violate human rights. Reason (R): The Commission has no power of prosecution and can only make recommendations to government or to the courts.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since the NHRC lacks the power of prosecution, it can only recommend action, so it cannot itself punish violators.
-
5. Read the case: A higher court finds that a lower court has taken up a case beyond its jurisdiction and orders it to stop. Which writ is this?
- Mandamus
- Habeas corpus
- Quo warranto
- Prohibition
Show answer
Answer: D. Prohibition is issued by a higher court (High Court or Supreme Court) when a lower court has considered a case going beyond its jurisdiction.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.