- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Why rights matter: the bill of rights and Fundamental Rights
Explain why a democracy lists rights in its constitution, what a bill of rights does, how Fundamental Rights differ from ordinary legal rights, and name the six groups of Fundamental Rights in Part III.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain, with the textbook's two cases, why rights must exist in practice and not only on paper.
- Define a bill of rights and say from whom it protects the individual.
- Distinguish Fundamental Rights from ordinary legal rights and list the six groups in Part III.
The previous chapter showed that one function of a constitution is to limit government. In India, the most important limits are the Fundamental Rights listed in Part III of the Constitution, which also states the limits on these rights. The chapter notes that over the decades the scope of these rights has changed and, in some respects, expanded.
Two cases that show why rights matter
The chapter opens with two real situations. In 1982, during construction for the Asian Games in Delhi, contractors hired very poor workers from many parts of the country and paid them less than the minimum wage fixed by the government. A team of social scientists petitioned the Supreme Court, arguing that paying less than the minimum wage amounted to begar (forced labour), which violates the Fundamental Right against exploitation. The court agreed and directed the government to make sure the workers received the prescribed wages.
In the second case, a young man from a village in Assam was arrested on a charge of causing grievous injuries, found mentally unfit to stand trial and sent to a mental hospital as an undertrial. Doctors later reported that he was fit for trial, but nobody acted. He remained in 'judicial custody' for 54 years, his case never heard, until a team of the National Human Rights Commission intervened and he was released in 2005. The Constitution's right to life and liberty includes a fair and speedy trial; his case shows what happens when a right exists on paper but not in practice. In the first case, by contrast, the violation was challenged in court and the constitutional guarantee delivered justice.
What a bill of rights is
A democracy must ensure that individuals have certain rights and that government will always recognise them. So most democracies list citizens' rights in the constitution itself. Such a list of rights, mentioned and protected by the constitution, is called a bill of rights. It prohibits government from acting against these rights and ensures a remedy if they are violated.
From whom does it protect the individual? From two directions. Another person or a private organisation may threaten your rights, and then you need the government's protection, so government must be bound to protect rights. But the organs of government themselves, the legislature, executive, bureaucracy or even the judiciary, may also violate rights while functioning, so government must be restrained too.
A bill of rights is a list of rights stated and protected by the constitution; it stops government from violating them and guarantees a remedy when they are violated.
Rights in India's freedom struggle and in South Africa
Leaders of the freedom movement demanded that the British respect the rights of the people; the Motilal Nehru committee demanded a bill of rights as early as 1928. So when the Constitution was being prepared, there were no two opinions on including and protecting rights. The Constitution listed the rights to be specially protected and called them 'fundamental rights'.
For comparison, the chapter describes the South African Constitution, inaugurated in December 1996 after the end of the Apartheid government, when the country still feared civil war. It calls its Bill of Rights a cornerstone of democracy, forbids discrimination on a long list of grounds, grants perhaps the most extensive range of rights, and has a special constitutional court to enforce them. Among its rights are dignity, privacy, fair labour practices, a healthy environment, adequate housing, health care, food, water and social security, children's rights, education, rights of cultural, religious and linguistic communities, and the right to information.
Fundamental Rights and ordinary rights
The word fundamental means these rights are so important that the Constitution lists them separately and makes special provision to protect them, ensuring that government itself does not violate them.
| Point of difference | Ordinary legal rights | Fundamental Rights |
|---|---|---|
| Source of protection | Ordinary law | The Constitution itself |
| How they can be changed | By the legislature through ordinary law-making | Only by amending the Constitution |
| Protection against government | Can be altered by government through law | No organ of government may act to violate them; courts can strike down such acts |
The judiciary has the power and responsibility to protect Fundamental Rights: executive and legislative actions can be declared illegal if they violate these rights or restrict them unreasonably. Yet Fundamental Rights are not absolute or unlimited: government can place reasonable restrictions on their exercise.
Fundamental Rights in Part III
-
Right to Equality
- Equality before law
- No discrimination
- Equal opportunity in public employment
- Untouchability and titles abolished
-
Right to Freedom
- Six freedoms incl. speech
- Life and personal liberty
- Education
- Rights on arrest and conviction
-
Right against Exploitation
- No trafficking or forced labour
- No child labour in hazardous jobs
-
Right to Freedom of Religion
- Conscience and practice
- Managing religious affairs
-
Cultural and Educational Rights
- Minorities' language and culture
- Minority educational institutions
-
Right to Constitutional Remedies
- Move the courts for writs and orders
Worked example 1: is it a Fundamental Right?
A made-up State law gives tenants the right to receive a rent receipt. A citizen also has freedom of speech under the Constitution. Reasoning: the rent-receipt right comes from ordinary law, so the legislature can change it by ordinary law. Freedom of speech is guaranteed by the Constitution, so it can be changed only by a constitutional amendment, and courts can strike down government action that unreasonably restricts it.
Worked example 2: who is the threat?
(a) A private factory owner locks workers inside and refuses to pay them. (b) A police station arrests a person and refuses to say why. Analysis: in (a) the threat comes from a private party, so the individual needs government to protect the right. In (b) the threat comes from an organ of government itself, so the bill of rights must restrain government. A bill of rights is needed for both.
Key takeaways: rights matter only if they work in practice, as the Asian Games workers' and the long-detained undertrial's cases show. A bill of rights lists rights in the constitution, restrains government and guarantees remedies. India demanded one as early as the Motilal Nehru committee of 1928. Fundamental Rights are guaranteed by the Constitution, can be changed only by amendment and are protected by the courts, but are subject to reasonable restrictions. Part III has six groups of rights.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the 1982 Asian Games case described in the chapter, why did the Supreme Court hold that the workers' Fundamental Rights were violated?
- Because they were denied the right to vote
- Because paying less than the minimum wage amounted to forced labour (begar)
- Because they were not allowed to practise their religion
- Because they were arrested without a warrant
Show answer
Answer: B. The petitioners argued that employing people for less than the prescribed minimum wage is begar or forced labour, which violates the right against exploitation. The court accepted this and directed that the workers be paid the prescribed wages.
-
2. Which committee demanded a bill of rights for India as far back as 1928?
- The Motilal Nehru committee
- The Cabinet Mission
- The Drafting Committee
- The Simon Commission
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter states that the Motilal Nehru committee had demanded a bill of rights in 1928, which is why there were no two opinions on including rights in the Constitution.
-
3. How can a Fundamental Right be changed?
- By an order of the President
- By an ordinary law passed by a State legislature
- Only by amending the Constitution
- By a decision of the Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. Ordinary legal rights can be changed by the ordinary law-making process, but a Fundamental Right can be changed only by amending the Constitution itself.
-
4. Assertion (A): Fundamental Rights in India are absolute and cannot be restricted in any way. Reason (R): The judiciary can declare executive and legislative actions illegal if they violate Fundamental Rights.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: D. The assertion is false: the chapter says Fundamental Rights are not absolute; government can impose reasonable restrictions. The reason is true: courts can strike down actions that violate these rights or restrict them unreasonably.
-
5. According to the chapter, a bill of rights protects the individual from:
- only other individuals
- only the government
- only foreign countries
- both other persons or private organisations and the organs of government
Show answer
Answer: D. Rights can be threatened by another person or a private organisation (so government must protect them) and by the legislature, executive, bureaucracy or even the judiciary (so government must be restrained).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.