• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Freedoms and their limits, rights of the accused, exploitation and religion

Explain preventive detention and the other freedoms with their restrictions, the three rights of the accused, the right against exploitation, and the right to freedom of religion with India's equal treatment of all religions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain preventive detention and why it is in tension with personal liberty.
  • State the restrictions on the freedoms and the three protections for an accused person.
  • Describe the right against exploitation and the right to freedom of religion, including its limits.

Freedoms are valuable precisely because they can be abused, both by citizens and by governments. This lesson looks at how the Constitution balances liberty with order, protects people accused of crimes, guards against exploitation and secures freedom of religion.

Preventive detention

Normally a person is arrested after he or she is reported to have committed an offence. Preventive detention is an exception: a person can be arrested simply out of an apprehension that he or she is likely to engage in unlawful activity, and held for some time without the usual procedure, if government thinks the person is a threat to law and order or to the peace and security of the nation. According to the chapter, such detention can be extended only for three months, after which the case goes before an advisory board for review.

It looks like an effective tool against anti-social elements, but the chapter notes it has often been misused, and many people think it needs greater safeguards. There is a clear tension between the right to life and personal liberty and preventive detention.

Other freedoms and their restrictions

Article 19 protects the freedoms of speech and expression, to assemble peacefully, to form associations or unions, to move freely throughout India, to reside and settle in any part of India, and to practise any profession or carry on any occupation, trade or business. None is absolute. Free speech is subject to restrictions such as public order, peace and morality; assembly must be peaceful and without arms, and government may declare an assembly of five or more persons unlawful in certain areas. The chapter warns that such powers can be misused to deny permission for genuine protest, though misuse becomes rare when people are aware and vigilant. Even in the Constituent Assembly some members were dissatisfied with these restrictions; Somnath Lahiri complained that many rights seemed framed from a police constable's point of view, each followed by a proviso that almost took it away.

Rights of the accused

No one is guilty until a court finds him or her guilty, and an accused person must have an adequate chance to defend himself or herself. To ensure a fair trial, the Constitution provides three rights:

  1. No person shall be punished for the same offence more than once.
  2. No law shall declare any action illegal from a back date (no retrospective criminal law).
  3. No person shall be compelled to give evidence against himself or herself.

Right to Freedom: what it includes

  • Six freedoms (Article 19)
    • Speech and expression
    • Assemble peacefully, without arms
    • Form associations
    • Move freely
    • Reside and settle
    • Any profession or trade
  • Life and personal liberty
    • Procedure established by law
    • Expanded by courts
  • Rights of the accused
    • No double punishment
    • No retrospective crime
    • No forced self-incrimination
  • Arrest and detention
    • Safeguards on arrest
    • Preventive detention with review
  • Right to education
    • For children

Right against exploitation

Millions of under-privileged people can be exploited by others. The Constitution prohibits begar (forced labour without payment) and traffic in human beings (buying and selling people and using them as slaves). Forced labour was imposed in the past by landlords, moneylenders and other wealthy persons; the chapter notes that some bonded labour continues, especially in brick kilns, and that it has been declared a punishable crime. The Constitution also forbids employing children below 14 years in dangerous jobs such as factories and mines. With child labour made illegal and education a fundamental right for children, this right has become more meaningful.

Right to freedom of religion

Historically, some rulers persecuted people who followed a religion other than the ruler's or forced them to convert, so freedom of religion is a hallmark of democracy. In India it includes:

  • Freedom of conscience: one may choose any religion or choose to follow none.
  • Freedom to profess, practise and propagate religion.
  • Freedom to manage religious affairs.
  • Freedom from being compelled to pay taxes for promoting any particular religion.
  • Freedom regarding attendance at religious instruction or worship in certain educational institutions.

This freedom has limits. Government may restrict religious practice to protect public order, morality and health, and may intervene to root out social evils; the chapter's examples are bans on sati, bigamy and human sacrifice. Such limits sometimes create tension, because a religious group may see any restriction as interference. The right to propagate includes persuading others to convert, but the Constitution does not allow forcible conversion; it gives the right to spread information about one's religion and so attract others.

Equality of all religions. In a country home to many religions, government must treat all equally and favour none. India has no official religion; no one has to belong to a particular religion to be Prime Minister, President, a judge or any public official. Institutions run by the State do not preach any religion or give religious education, and do not favour persons of any religion. These provisions sustain the principle of secularism.

Freedoms are guaranteed with reasonable restrictions; preventive detention is an exception reviewed after three months; an accused cannot be punished twice, punished under a backdated law, or forced to testify against himself; begar, trafficking and hazardous child labour are banned; religion is free subject to public order, morality and health.

Worked example 1: should this freedom be restricted?

Consider two made-up situations. (a) Citizens gather for a silent, unarmed peace march after riots in their city. (b) A caste panchayat meets to punish a young couple for marrying outside their caste. Analysis: (a) is a peaceful, unarmed assembly for a public purpose, so it is an exercise of the freedom to assemble; restricting it would need strong grounds of public order. (b) is not a protected freedom at all: it tries to punish people for using their own liberty, and the State should step in to protect the couple.

Worked example 2: which right of the accused?

In a made-up case, a new law passed in 2024 makes an act done in 2020 a crime, police pressure the accused to confess in court, and after acquittal he is tried again for the same act. Analysis: three separate rights are violated: protection against retrospective criminal law, against compelled self-incrimination, and against being punished twice for the same offence.

Worked example 3: religion and social reform

A made-up group claims that a ban on a harmful custom violates its freedom of religion. Reasoning: freedom of religion is subject to public order, morality and health, and the State may act against social evils, as with sati or human sacrifice. A restriction to end such a practice cannot be opposed as interference with religious freedom.

Key takeaways: preventive detention allows arrest on apprehension, limited to three months before advisory-board review, and stands in tension with personal liberty. The freedoms of Article 19 carry reasonable restrictions. An accused is protected against double punishment, retrospective criminal law and self-incrimination. Begar, trafficking and employment of children under 14 in hazardous work are prohibited. Freedom of religion is broad but limited by public order, morality and health; India has no official religion.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is preventive detention, as explained in the chapter?

    1. Arrest after a court has convicted a person
    2. Arrest of a person only out of apprehension that he or she may engage in unlawful activity
    3. Detention of witnesses in a trial
    4. Detention of foreign tourists without visas
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Preventive detention means arresting a person not for a committed offence but because government apprehends he or she may engage in unlawful activity threatening law and order or national security.

  2. 2. According to the chapter, after how long must a case of preventive detention be brought before an advisory board for review?

    1. 24 hours
    2. Three months
    3. One year
    4. Six years
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter states that preventive detention can be extended only for three months, after which the case is brought before an advisory board for review.

  3. 3. Which of the following is NOT one of the three rights of an accused person listed in the chapter?

    1. Not to be punished for the same offence more than once
    2. Not to be punished under a law that makes an act illegal from a back date
    3. Not to be compelled to give evidence against oneself
    4. To be released without trial after six months
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The three rights are protection against double punishment, against retrospective criminal laws and against self-incrimination. There is no right to automatic release without trial.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Government can ban practices such as sati or human sacrifice even though they are claimed as religious practices. Reason (R): Freedom of religion is subject to restrictions to protect public order, morality and health.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A. Because freedom of religion is not unlimited and can be restricted for public order, morality and health, the State can root out social evils without violating the right.

  5. 5. Read the case: In a made-up district, children aged ten are found working in a fireworks factory. Which Fundamental Right is being violated?

    1. Right to Freedom of Religion
    2. Cultural and Educational Rights
    3. Right against Exploitation
    4. Right to Constitutional Remedies
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The right against exploitation forbids employing children below 14 years in dangerous jobs such as factories and mines; a fireworks factory is hazardous work.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery