- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Directive Principles, Fundamental Duties and their relationship with rights
Explain the non-justiciable Directive Principles and what they contain, the Fundamental Duties added in 1976, and how the conflict between rights and Directive Principles over property led to the Kesavananda Bharati case.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why the Directive Principles were made non-justiciable and list their three kinds of content.
- State what the 42nd amendment did about Fundamental Duties and why duties do not limit rights.
- Trace the conflict over the right to property from 1950 to the 44th amendment and the basic structure idea.
The framers knew that independent India would face many challenges, above all bringing equality and well-being to all citizens. They wanted to give future governments a direction without binding them to particular policies. Their solution was the Directive Principles of State Policy.
Non-justiciable guidelines
The Directive Principles are guidelines included in the Constitution but not legally enforceable. If a government does not implement one, we cannot go to court to make it do so. That is what non-justiciable means: parts of the Constitution that cannot be enforced by the judiciary. The framers believed the moral force behind these guidelines would make governments take them seriously, and that people would hold governments responsible for implementing them.
What the Directive Principles contain
| Kind | Examples given in the chapter |
|---|---|
| Goals | Welfare of the people; social, economic and political justice; raising the standard of living; equitable distribution of resources; promotion of international peace |
| Non-justiciable rights | Adequate livelihood; equal pay for equal work for men and women; right against economic exploitation; right to work; early childhood care and education for children below six years |
| Policies | Uniform civil code; prohibition of consumption of alcoholic liquor; promotion of cottage industries; prevention of slaughter of useful cattle; promotion of village panchayats |
Governments have tried from time to time to give effect to some Directive Principles. The chapter's examples include zamindari abolition laws, nationalisation of banks, factory laws, minimum wages, promotion of cottage and small industries, reservation for the uplift of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, the right to education, panchayati raj institutions across the country, a partial right to work through an employment guarantee programme, and mid-day meals.
Fundamental Duties
In 1976, the 42nd amendment inserted a list of Fundamental Duties of citizens; according to the textbook, ten duties were listed. Among them: to abide by the Constitution, defend the country, promote harmony among all citizens and protect the environment. The Constitution says nothing about enforcing these duties. Importantly, it does not make enjoyment of rights conditional on fulfilling duties, so the duties have not changed the status of Fundamental Rights.
Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles: complementary
Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles
-
Fundamental Rights
- Restrain government from doing certain things
- Mainly protect individuals
- Justiciable: enforceable in court
- Part III
-
Directive Principles
- Urge government to do certain things
- Aim at the well-being of the whole society
- Non-justiciable: not enforceable in court
- Rely on moral force and people's pressure
The two can be seen as complementary. But when government tries to implement a Directive Principle, it may conflict with a citizen's Fundamental Right.
The conflict over the right to property
Originally, the Constitution included a Fundamental Right to property, described in the textbook as the right to acquire, possess and maintain property, while making it clear that government could take property for public welfare. When governments passed laws to abolish zamindari, these were challenged as violating the right to property. Keeping in mind that social needs are greater than individual interests, government amended the Constitution to give effect to the Directive Principles. A long legal battle followed. Government argued that rights could be abridged to implement Directive Principles, an argument that assumed rights were a hindrance to welfare; the court held that Fundamental Rights were so important that they could not be limited even for that purpose.
From property conflict to the basic structure
- 1950 Right to property is a Fundamental Right; laws soon limit it.
- Zamindari abolition Challenged as violating the right to property; Constitution amended to implement Directive Principles.
- Long legal battle Government says rights can be abridged for Directive Principles; court disagrees.
- 1973 Supreme Court: right to property is not part of the basic structure; Parliament may abridge it by amendment.
- Kesavananda Bharati Certain basic features of the Constitution cannot be changed by Parliament.
- 1978 44th amendment removes property from Fundamental Rights; it becomes a legal right under Article 300A.
This produced a second debate, about amending the Constitution. Government said Parliament could amend any part; the court said Parliament could not make amendments violating Fundamental Rights. The Supreme Court settled this in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973): there are certain basic features of the Constitution that Parliament cannot change. In the same period the court held that the right to property was not part of this basic structure, so Parliament could abridge it. In 1978, the 44th amendment removed the right to property from the list of Fundamental Rights and made it a simple legal right under Article 300A. Chapter 9 returns to the basic structure.
Conclusion of the chapter
The chapter traces the idea that rights include both freedom and equality back to the social reformer Jotirao Phule (1827-1890) of Maharashtra. The national movement sharpened it into constitutional rights, and since 1950 the judiciary has been an important protector of rights, widening their scope through interpretation. Rights limit government and ensure democratic governance.
Directive Principles are non-justiciable guidelines listing goals, rights and policies; Fundamental Rights restrain government, Directive Principles urge it to act. Fundamental Duties (42nd amendment, 1976) do not make rights conditional. The 44th amendment (1978) made property a legal right under Article 300A.
Worked example 1: right or directive?
Classify: (a) equal pay for equal work for men and women; (b) freedom of speech; (c) promotion of village panchayats; (d) abolition of untouchability. Working: (a) a non-justiciable right in the Directive Principles; (b) a Fundamental Right under the Right to Freedom; (c) a policy in the Directive Principles; (d) a Fundamental Right under the Right to Equality. Only (b) and (d) can be directly enforced in court.
Worked example 2: what changed for property in 1978?
Before 1978, a person whose property was taken could move the Supreme Court directly under the right to constitutional remedies, because property was a Fundamental Right. Reasoning: after the 44th amendment, property is a legal right under Article 300A. It is still protected by law, but it is no longer among the Fundamental Rights, so the special remedy reserved for Fundamental Rights no longer applies to it in the same way, and its scope can be shaped by ordinary law.
Worked example 3: the activist's claim
An activist says the poor do not need Fundamental Rights, only legally binding Directive Principles. Evaluation: Directive Principles such as the right to work and livelihood speak directly to poverty. But Fundamental Rights protected the Asian Games workers against forced labour, and courts have read shelter and livelihood into the right to life. The chapter treats the two as complementary: rights protect individuals now, directives guide policy for society's well-being. A balanced answer keeps both.
Key takeaways: the Directive Principles are non-justiciable guidelines of goals, rights and policies, backed by moral force and public pressure. Fundamental Duties, added in 1976, are not enforceable and do not condition rights. Rights and directives are complementary but have clashed, especially over property; the Kesavananda Bharati case set out basic features Parliament cannot change, and the 44th amendment of 1978 made property a legal right under Article 300A.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does it mean to say that the Directive Principles are 'non-justiciable'?
- They apply only to judges
- They cannot be enforced by the courts
- They can be changed only by the President
- They are enforced by the Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. Non-justiciable means the courts cannot be asked to order government to implement them. Their force comes from moral pressure and from people holding governments responsible.
-
2. Which of the following is listed in the chapter as a POLICY among the Directive Principles?
- Uniform civil code
- Freedom of speech
- Abolition of untouchability
- Right to constitutional remedies
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter lists uniform civil code, prohibition of alcoholic liquor, cottage industries, prevention of slaughter of useful cattle and village panchayats as policies. The other options are Fundamental Rights.
-
3. Which amendment, passed in 1976, inserted Fundamental Duties into the Constitution?
- The 44th amendment
- The 1st amendment
- The 42nd amendment
- The 73rd amendment
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter states that the 42nd amendment of 1976 inserted a list of Fundamental Duties. The 44th amendment (1978) concerned the right to property.
-
4. Assertion (A): The inclusion of Fundamental Duties has not changed the status of Fundamental Rights. Reason (R): The Constitution does not make the enjoyment of rights dependent on the fulfilment of duties.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because rights are not conditional on duties, adding duties did not alter the status of the rights.
-
5. After the 44th amendment of 1978, the right to property became:
- a Fundamental Right under Article 21
- a Directive Principle
- a Fundamental Duty
- a legal right under Article 300A
Show answer
Answer: D. The 44th amendment removed the right to property from the Fundamental Rights and converted it into a simple legal right under Article 300A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.