- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
How Parliament controls the executive
Explain parliamentary privilege and the four instruments of parliamentary control: deliberation and discussion, approval of laws, financial control and the no-confidence motion, and the factors that weaken parliamentary control.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain parliamentary privilege and the danger of cabinet dictatorship.
- Describe Question Hour, Zero Hour and other tools of deliberation, and the approval, financial and no-confidence instruments.
- Identify conditions that make parliamentary control effective or weak.
In a parliamentary democracy, the executive comes from the party or coalition with a Lok Sabha majority. With a disciplined majority behind it, the executive could exercise unlimited and arbitrary power, and parliamentary democracy could slip into cabinet dictatorship, where the Cabinet leads and the House merely follows. Only an active and vigilant Parliament can keep regular and effective check on the executive.
Parliamentary privilege
Basic to all parliamentary control is the freedom of legislators to work effectively and fearlessly as the people's representatives. For instance, no action can be taken against a member for whatever he or she says in the legislature. This is parliamentary privilege. The presiding officer has the final say in deciding matters of breach of privilege. The purpose of privileges is to enable members to represent the people and to control the executive effectively.
Instruments of parliamentary control
The legislature ensures executive accountability at every stage: policy-making, implementation, and after implementation. It uses four kinds of devices.
1. Deliberation and discussion
While making laws, members debate the executive's policy direction and how policies are implemented. Control is also exercised in general discussions through several instruments:
- Question Hour, held every day during sessions, when ministers must answer searching questions. The chapter calls it perhaps the most effective method of keeping vigil on the executive; attendance is highest then, and questions often seek information on matters such as price rise, availability of food grains, atrocities on weaker sections, riots and black-marketing.
- Zero Hour, when members may raise any matter they think important, though ministers are not bound to reply.
- Half-an-hour discussions on matters of public importance.
- Adjournment motions and similar devices.
Debates during Question Hour can be heated: members raise their voices, walk to the well of the House or walk out in protest. This wastes legislative time, but the chapter notes that many such actions are political techniques to win concessions and force executive accountability.
2. Approval and ratification of laws
A bill becomes law only with Parliament's approval. A government with a disciplined majority usually gets it, but approval cannot be taken for granted: it comes through intense bargaining within the ruling party or coalition, and even between government and opposition. When a government has a majority in the Lok Sabha but not in the Rajya Sabha, it must make substantial concessions to get bills through both Houses, and some bills have failed or been rejected by the Rajya Sabha.
3. Financial control
Preparing and presenting the budget for the legislature's approval is a constitutional obligation of the government, which gives the legislature control over the purse strings. The legislature may refuse to grant money, though this seldom happens because governments usually have majority support. Before granting money, the Lok Sabha can discuss why the government needs it, and it can inquire into misuse of funds on the basis of reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General and the Public Accounts Committee. Financial control is not only about honest accounts: because the budget reflects policies, controlling finance means controlling policy.
4. No-confidence motion
The most powerful weapon for ensuring executive accountability is the no-confidence motion. As long as the government keeps the support of its party or coalition majority, the House's power to dismiss it is more fictional than real. But after 1989, several governments were forced to resign because they lost the confidence of the House, each time because they failed to keep the support of coalition partners.
Instruments of parliamentary control
-
Deliberation and discussion
- Question Hour
- Zero Hour
- Half-an-hour discussion
- Adjournment motion
-
Approval of laws
- Bargaining within party, coalition and with opposition
-
Financial control
- Budget approval
- CAG and Public Accounts Committee reports
-
No-confidence motion
- Most powerful weapon
- Real when majority support is uncertain
When does control work?
Effective control needs adequate time for the House, members who are interested and participate, and willingness to compromise between government and opposition. The chapter notes a gradual decline over recent decades in the number of sessions of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies and in time spent on debate, and problems such as absence of quorum and opposition boycotts, which deprive the House of its power to control the executive through discussion.
Parliament controls the executive through deliberation (especially Question Hour), approval of laws, financial control through the budget and audit reports, and the no-confidence motion, all resting on members' freedom of speech in the House (parliamentary privilege).
Worked example 1: name the device
Identify the instrument. (a) An MP asks the agriculture minister how much grain is in government stores, and the minister must reply. (b) An MP raises sudden floods in her district without notice; the minister need not reply. (c) The Lok Sabha examines an audit report showing misuse of funds by a department. (d) A coalition partner withdraws support and the government loses a vote in the Lok Sabha. Answers: (a) Question Hour; (b) Zero Hour; (c) financial control using CAG and Public Accounts Committee reports; (d) no-confidence motion.
Worked example 2: is the no-confidence power real?
In made-up Parliament A, one disciplined party holds 60 per cent of seats. In made-up Parliament B, a government survives on the support of five parties. Reasoning: in A, the House's power to remove the government is largely fictional, because the majority will stand together. In B, if one partner leaves, the government can fall, so the no-confidence motion is a real threat. This matches the chapter's observation about governments after 1989.
Worked example 3: walkouts
Opposition members walk out during Question Hour after a minister gives an evasive answer. Evaluation: the walkout costs legislative time and prevents further questioning. But the chapter notes that such protests can be political techniques to draw attention and win concessions, forcing accountability. Too frequent use, however, weakens the House's power to control the executive through discussion.
Key takeaways: without vigilance, a majority government could become a cabinet dictatorship. Parliamentary privilege protects members' freedom of speech. Parliament controls the executive through deliberation (Question Hour, Zero Hour and other devices), approval of laws, financial control through the budget and audit, and the no-confidence motion, which has real force when coalitions are fragile. Control weakens when sittings shrink and quorum and boycotts disrupt the House.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is parliamentary privilege, as explained in the chapter?
- A member's right to a government house
- Immunity from action for whatever a member says in the legislature
- A member's right to skip sessions
- The Speaker's right to vote twice
Show answer
Answer: B. Parliamentary privilege means no action can be taken against a member for what he or she says in the legislature; the presiding officer decides breach-of-privilege matters.
-
2. Which device does the chapter describe as perhaps the most effective method of keeping vigil on the executive?
- Zero Hour
- Joint session
- Question Hour
- Walkout
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter calls Question Hour, held every day during sessions, perhaps the most effective method, since ministers must answer searching questions and attendance is highest then.
-
3. During Zero Hour:
- ministers must answer every question in writing
- the budget is voted upon
- members may raise any matter, but ministers are not bound to reply
- the President addresses Parliament
Show answer
Answer: C. In Zero Hour members are free to raise any matter they think important, though ministers are not bound to reply.
-
4. Assertion (A): The power of the Lok Sabha to dismiss a government is fictional rather than real when the government has a disciplined majority. Reason (R): As long as the government keeps the support of its party or coalition majority, a no-confidence motion will not pass.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: a secure majority will defeat any no-confidence motion, so the power is real only when majority support is uncertain, as in several coalitions after 1989.
-
5. Which of the following is mentioned in the chapter as weakening Parliament's control over the executive?
- More sessions and longer debates
- Willingness of government and opposition to compromise
- Active participation by members
- Absence of quorum and boycotts of sessions
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter lists a decline in sessions and debate time, absence of quorum and opposition boycotts as factors that deprive the House of control through discussion; the others strengthen control.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.