- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
How Parliament makes laws
Classify the types of bills, trace a bill from the idea and drafting stage through committees, voting, the other House and the President's assent, and explain the special procedure for money bills and joint sessions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish government bills from private member's bills, and money bills from non-money bills.
- Describe the stages of law-making in order, including the role of committees.
- Explain the procedure for money bills and how deadlocks are resolved by a joint session.
Making laws is the basic function of any legislature, and it follows a definite procedure, partly laid down in the Constitution and partly grown from conventions. Following a bill through the process shows that law-making is technical and even tedious, and also deeply political.
Types of bills
A bill is a draft of a proposed law. A bill proposed by a minister is a Government Bill; one proposed by a member who is not a minister is a Private Member's Bill. Bills may also be ordinary bills (money or non-money) or Constitution Amendment Bills.
Types of bills
-
By who introduces it
- Government Bill (a minister)
- Private Member's Bill (a non-minister)
-
By subject
- Ordinary Bill: money bill or non-money bill
- Constitution Amendment Bill
Before the bill reaches Parliament
Even before introduction there may be much debate. A party may press the government to bring a bill to fulfil election promises or improve its chances; interest groups, the media and citizens' forums may also push for a law. So law-making is a political process as well as a legal one. Preparing a bill involves practical questions: the resources needed to implement it, the support and opposition it may attract, and its likely effect on the ruling party's electoral prospects. In coalition governments, a bill must be acceptable to all partners. The Cabinet weighs all this before deciding to legislate. Once the Cabinet approves the policy, the concerned ministry drafts the bill; for example, a bill raising the marriageable age of girls would be prepared by the law ministry, with the ministry dealing with women and children also involved.
Stages inside Parliament
- Introduction. A bill may be introduced in either House by a member, usually the minister responsible. A money bill can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha (Article 109 provides that a money bill shall not be introduced in the Council of States).
- Committee stage. Much of the discussion happens in committees, whose recommendations are sent to the House. That is why committees are called miniature legislatures. The House may or may not accept the committee's report.
- Voting. The bill is discussed in detail and voted upon in the House.
- The other House. A non-money bill passed by one House goes to the other, where it passes through exactly the same procedure.
- Resolving disagreement. If the Houses disagree, an attempt is made to resolve it through a joint session of Parliament. In the few joint sessions held to break a deadlock, the decision has always gone in favour of the Lok Sabha, the chapter notes.
- President's assent. A bill passed by both Houses goes to the President, whose assent turns it into law (the President may return a non-money bill once for reconsideration, as studied in the Executive chapter).
Life of a non-money bill
- Idea and drafting Pressure from parties and groups; Cabinet approves; ministry drafts.
- Introduction In either House, usually by a minister.
- Committee Detailed study; report to the House.
- Discussion and vote Accepted or rejected in the first House.
- Other House Same procedure; joint session if they disagree.
- President's assent Bill becomes law.
Money bills
For a money bill, the Rajya Sabha can approve it or suggest changes but cannot reject it. If the Rajya Sabha takes no action within 14 days, the bill is deemed to have been passed. The Lok Sabha may accept or reject the Rajya Sabha's suggested amendments.
| Point | Non-money bill | Money bill |
|---|---|---|
| Where introduced | Either House | Lok Sabha only |
| Rajya Sabha's power | Full: can pass, amend or reject | Can only suggest changes; cannot reject |
| Time limit for Rajya Sabha | None specified in the chapter | 14 days; then deemed passed |
| If Houses disagree | Joint session may be called | Lok Sabha's view prevails; it may accept or reject suggestions |
Law-making: Cabinet decision and ministry draft, introduction, committee study, debate and vote, the same process in the other House (joint session if needed), then the President's assent. A money bill starts only in the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha must return it within 14 days with suggestions only.
Worked example 1: the 14-day rule
A made-up money bill passed by the Lok Sabha reaches the Rajya Sabha on 3 March. The Rajya Sabha neither approves it nor suggests changes. Working: 14 days after 3 March is 17 March (3 + 14 = 17). If the Rajya Sabha has taken no action by then, the bill is deemed passed by both Houses and goes to the President.
Worked example 2: putting the stages in order
Arrange these stages: (A) the bill is passed in the House where it was introduced; (B) the concerned minister proposes the need for a law; (C) the bill is sent to the President; (D) the bill is examined by a committee, which suggests changes; (E) the law ministry drafts the bill; (F) the other House passes the bill. Answer: B, E, D, A, F, C. Need and Cabinet approval come first, then drafting, then committee study and passage in the first House, then the other House, and finally the President's assent.
Worked example 3: a private member's bill
A made-up MP who is not a minister introduces a bill to set up libraries in every village. Reasoning: it is a private member's bill. The chapter notes that such bills have little chance of passing without government support, because the Cabinet decides the legislative agenda and the government usually commands the majority. It may still raise public debate on the issue.
Key takeaways: bills are government or private member's bills, and money, non-money or constitution amendment bills. Law-making begins with political pressure and Cabinet decisions, then drafting by the ministry, introduction, committee study, debate and voting, and the same in the other House, with a joint session to resolve deadlock, and ends with the President's assent. Money bills start only in the Lok Sabha; the Rajya Sabha can only suggest changes within 14 days.
Check your understanding
-
1. A bill introduced by a member of Parliament who is not a minister is called a:
- Government Bill
- Money Bill
- Private Member's Bill
- Constitution Amendment Bill
Show answer
Answer: C. A bill proposed by a non-minister is a private member's bill; one proposed by a minister is a government bill.
-
2. Why are parliamentary committees described as 'miniature legislatures'?
- Because they can pass laws without the House
- Because a large part of the discussion on bills takes place in them, and their recommendations go to the House
- Because they have only a few members
- Because they elect the Speaker
Show answer
Answer: B. Much of the detailed discussion on bills happens in committees, which then report to the House; this is why they are called miniature legislatures.
-
3. If the Rajya Sabha takes no action on a money bill within 14 days, what happens?
- The bill lapses
- A joint session is called
- The President decides
- The bill is deemed to have been passed
Show answer
Answer: D. The Rajya Sabha can approve or suggest changes but cannot reject a money bill; if it takes no action within 14 days, the bill is deemed passed.
-
4. Assertion (A): Law-making is not merely a legal procedure but also a political course of action. Reason (R): Parties, interest groups, the media and coalition partners all influence whether and how a bill is introduced.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the political pressures and calculations that shape bills before and during their passage make law-making a political as well as legal process.
-
5. According to the chapter, how have joint sessions held to resolve deadlocks between the Houses usually ended?
- The decision has always gone in favour of the Lok Sabha
- The decision has always gone in favour of the Rajya Sabha
- The President decided each case
- The Supreme Court settled each case
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter notes that in the few joint sessions called to resolve a deadlock, the decision has always gone in favour of the Lok Sabha, the larger House.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.