- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Parliamentary committees, regulating the House and the anti-defection law
Explain the role of standing committees and joint parliamentary committees, how the presiding officer regulates the House, what counts as defection under the anti-defection law, and the chapter's assessment of Parliament.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why Parliament needs committees and distinguish standing committees from joint parliamentary committees.
- Describe how the presiding officer regulates the business and discipline of the House.
- Define defection under the anti-defection law and assess its effects.
Parliament meets only during sessions and has very limited time, yet law-making needs in-depth study, and other tasks such as examining ministries' demands for grants, scrutinising departmental spending and investigating corruption need close attention. Committees do much of this work.
Parliamentary committees
Standing committees. Since 1983, India has developed a system of parliamentary standing committees; according to the textbook, there are over twenty departmentally related committees. They supervise the work of various departments, their budget, their expenditure and the bills relating to them that come before the House.
Joint Parliamentary Committees (JPCs) have held a position of eminence. They can be set up to discuss a particular bill or to investigate financial irregularities, and their members are drawn from both Houses.
The committee system has reduced the burden on Parliament. Many important bills are referred to committees, and Parliament has usually approved their work with few alterations. Legally, no bill becomes law and no budget is sanctioned without Parliament's approval, but Parliament rarely rejects committee suggestions.
Standing committees and joint parliamentary committees
-
Departmentally related standing committees
- System developed since 1983
- Supervise a department's work, budget and expenditure
- Examine bills relating to the department
- Continuing bodies
-
Joint Parliamentary Committees
- Set up for a particular bill or to investigate financial irregularities
- Members from both Houses
- Hold a position of eminence
How Parliament regulates itself
Parliament performs its functions through debate, and debate must be meaningful and orderly so that business runs smoothly and the House keeps its dignity. The Constitution itself makes provisions for the smooth conduct of business, and the presiding officer (the Speaker of the Lok Sabha, the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha) is the final authority in regulating the business of the legislature. In the Constituent Assembly, N.V. Gadgil argued, in substance, that the legislature is restricted only in matters of procedure, not in the substance of its sovereignty. This is a paraphrase.
The anti-defection law
Most legislators are elected on a party's ticket. What if they leave the party after being elected? For many years after independence this was unresolved. Finally the parties agreed that a legislator elected on one party's ticket must be restricted from defecting to another. The 52nd Amendment Act (1985), known as the anti-defection amendment, did this; it was later modified by the 91st Amendment. The presiding officer takes the final decision in all such cases. If defection is proved, the member loses membership of the House and is also disqualified from holding any political office such as ministership.
What counts as defection? According to the chapter, it is defection if a member:
- remains absent from the House when asked by the party leadership to be present; or
- votes against the instructions of the party; or
- voluntarily gives up membership of the party.
The chapter's assessment: the anti-defection amendment has not been able to curb defections, but it has given additional powers to the party leadership and the presiding officers over members.
| Aspect | Anti-defection law as described in the chapter |
|---|---|
| Introduced by | 52nd Amendment Act, 1985; later modified by the 91st Amendment |
| Who decides | The presiding officer of the House |
| What counts as defection | Absence against party direction, voting against party instructions, or voluntarily leaving the party |
| Penalty | Loss of membership of the House and disqualification from political office such as minister |
| Effect in practice | Has not curbed defections; has increased the power of party leaders and presiding officers |
Conclusion of the chapter
Parliament is a rainbow of the country's regions, languages, castes and religions. Members often fight bitterly, and it may seem they waste time and money, but the same members can effectively control the executive and voice the interests of many sections. Because of its composition, the legislature is the most representative organ, and in a parliamentary democracy it holds a high position of power and responsibility. Herein lies the democratic potential of Parliament.
Committees do Parliament's detailed work and Parliament rarely rejects their suggestions. The presiding officer regulates the House and decides defection cases. Defection: absence or voting against the party's direction, or voluntarily leaving the party; penalty: loss of seat and disqualification from political office.
Worked example 1: is this defection?
Decide in each made-up case. (a) Member P, elected on Party X's ticket, votes against Party X's instruction on a bill. (b) Member Q speaks critically of her party's policy in a debate but votes as instructed. (c) Member R resigns from Party Y and joins Party Z. (d) Member S stays away from a crucial vote after the party directs all members to be present. Answers: (a) defection; (b) not defection, since criticism in debate is not one of the three grounds; (c) defection, by voluntarily giving up membership; (d) defection, by absence against the party's direction. The presiding officer decides each case.
Worked example 2: committee or House?
A made-up bill on data protection is long and technical. Reasoning: the House has limited time in a session, so the bill is referred to the departmentally related standing committee, which studies it clause by clause, hears views and recommends changes. The House then debates and votes. Legally the House decides, but in practice it rarely rejects the committee's recommendations.
Worked example 3: has the law worked?
Evaluate: 'The anti-defection law has strengthened individual legislators.' Evaluation using the chapter: this is incorrect. The chapter says the law has not curbed defections, and it has given more power to party leaders and presiding officers over members, because members who vote against party instructions risk losing their seats. So the law has, if anything, reduced individual legislators' independence.
Key takeaways: committees, including departmentally related standing committees (since 1983) and joint parliamentary committees, reduce Parliament's burden and their suggestions are rarely rejected. The presiding officer is the final authority on regulating the House, on breaches of privilege and on defection. The anti-defection law (52nd Amendment, 1985, modified by the 91st) penalises defectors with loss of seat and of eligibility for political office, but has strengthened party leaders more than it has stopped defections. The legislature remains the most representative organ of government.
Check your understanding
-
1. Since when has India developed a system of departmentally related parliamentary standing committees, according to the chapter?
- 1950
- 1983
- 1971
- 2003
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter states that since 1983 India has developed a system of parliamentary standing committees that supervise departments, their budgets, expenditure and related bills.
-
2. Which of the following is the purpose for which Joint Parliamentary Committees can be set up?
- Electing the Speaker
- Appointing judges
- Discussing a particular bill or investigating financial irregularities
- Conducting Lok Sabha elections
Show answer
Answer: C. JPCs can be set up to discuss a particular bill or to investigate financial irregularities, and their members come from both Houses.
-
3. Who takes the final decision on whether a member has defected?
- The Prime Minister
- The Election Commission
- The President
- The presiding officer of the House
Show answer
Answer: D. Under the anti-defection law, the presiding officer of the House takes the final decision in all defection cases.
-
4. Assertion (A): The anti-defection law has increased the power of party leaders over legislators. Reason (R): A legislator who votes against the party's instructions can lose membership of the House.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since voting against party instructions can cost a member the seat, party leaders gain leverage over members; the chapter notes this effect.
-
5. Which of the following would count as defection under the law described in the chapter?
- Criticising one's own party in a newspaper article
- Voluntarily giving up membership of one's party
- Asking questions to ministers of one's own party
- Being absent with the party's permission
Show answer
Answer: B. Defection includes voluntarily leaving the party, voting against party instructions, or remaining absent when the party directs members to be present. Criticism or questions are not defection.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.