• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why we need a Parliament, two Houses and the Rajya Sabha

Explain why the legislature is central to democracy, why large and diverse countries prefer two Houses, and how the Rajya Sabha represents the States, including its term, permanent nature and nominated members.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why a legislature is more than a law-making body and why it remains powerful even with a strong cabinet.
  • Give two advantages of a bicameral legislature.
  • Compare symmetrical and population-based representation and describe the composition and term of the Rajya Sabha.

Legislatures are elected by the people and work on their behalf. Law-making is only one of their functions: the legislature is the centre of the democratic political process, full of debates, walkouts, protests, agreement and cooperation, all of which serve vital purposes. A genuine democracy is inconceivable without a representative, efficient and effective legislature, which also helps people hold their representatives accountable.

Has Parliament declined?

In most democracies, legislatures are losing their central place to the executive. In India too, the Cabinet initiates policies, sets the agenda and carries it through, leading some critics to say Parliament has declined. But even a very strong cabinet must keep its majority in the legislature, and even a strong leader must face Parliament and answer to its satisfaction. Parliament is one of the most democratic and open forums of debate; because of its composition it is the most representative organ of government; and above all it has the power to choose and dismiss the government. Herein lies its democratic potential.

Why two Houses?

'Parliament' means the national legislature; State legislatures are the legislatures of the States. India's Parliament has two Houses, the Council of States (Rajya Sabha) and the House of the People (Lok Sabha); a legislature with two Houses is bicameral. The Constitution lets each State choose a unicameral or bicameral legislature; according to the textbook, six States have a bicameral legislature.

Large and diverse countries usually prefer two Houses for two reasons:

  1. Wider representation: a second House can represent all sections of society and all geographical regions.
  2. Reconsideration: every decision of one House goes to the other, so every bill and policy is discussed twice. This double check means that even a hasty decision in one House can be reconsidered in the other.

In the Constituent Assembly, Purnima Banerji argued, in substance, that an upper House could act as a revising body whose views would count, and where people unsuited to the rough and tumble of active politics could advise the lower House.

The Rajya Sabha: representing the States

The two Houses rest on different bases of representation. The Rajya Sabha represents the States. It is indirectly elected: residents of a State elect the members of the State Legislative Assembly, and those elected MLAs elect the State's members of the Rajya Sabha.

A second chamber can follow either of two principles. Symmetrical representation gives every part of the country equal seats regardless of size or population; the USA does this in its Senate, so a small state has the same representation as a large one. The other principle gives seats according to population. India chose the second: the number of members from each State is fixed by the Fourth Schedule of the Constitution, and more populous States get more seats. The textbook's illustration contrasts a very populous State, which sends many members, with a small State that has one seat; equal representation would have given them the same number, a discrepancy the framers wanted to avoid.

Two principles for a second chamber

  • Symmetrical representation
    • Every unit gets equal seats
    • Size and population ignored
    • Example: US Senate
  • Population-based representation
    • More populous units get more seats
    • Smaller units get fewer seats
    • Example: India's Rajya Sabha (Fourth Schedule)

Term, permanence and nominated members

Rajya Sabha members are elected for six years and can be re-elected. Members do not all finish their terms together: every two years, one-third of the members complete their term, and elections are held only for those seats. So the Rajya Sabha is never fully dissolved and is called the permanent House of Parliament. The advantage: even when the Lok Sabha is dissolved and elections are pending, the Rajya Sabha can meet to conduct urgent business. Besides elected members, the Rajya Sabha has twelve members nominated by the President from among persons who have made their mark in literature, science, art and social service.

Case box: bicameralism in Germany

According to the textbook, Germany's Federal Assembly (Bundestag) is elected for four years by a system combining direct and proportional representation, while the Federal Council (Bundesrat) represents the federal states. Its members, generally state ministers, are appointed by the state governments, not elected, and the members from one state must vote as a bloc on the state government's instructions. Bills on matters where the states have concurrent powers must be passed by it, and it can veto such legislation.

The Rajya Sabha at a glance
FeatureRajya Sabha
RepresentsThe States of India
How electedIndirectly, by elected members of State Legislative Assemblies
Seats per StateAccording to population, fixed by the Fourth Schedule
Term of a memberSix years; may be re-elected
RenewalOne-third of members retire every two years
DissolutionNever fully dissolved: the permanent House
Nominated membersTwelve, nominated by the President for literature, science, art and social service

A bicameral legislature gives wider representation and a second look at every decision. The Rajya Sabha represents the States, is elected by MLAs, gives more seats to more populous States, and is a permanent House with one-third of members retiring every two years.

Worked example 1: the rolling retirement

Suppose a made-up permanent House has 240 elected members, each with a six-year term, and one-third retire every two years. Working: members retiring at each biennial election = 240 ÷ 3 = 80. Over six years there are three such elections: 3 × 80 = 240, so every seat is renewed once in six years, while two-thirds of the House (160 members) are always continuing members. This is why the House never dissolves.

Worked example 2: equal or proportional?

A made-up federation has State X with 9 crore people and State Y with 30 lakh people, and its upper House has 30 seats to divide between them. Reasoning: under symmetrical representation each would get 15 seats, so a person in Y would have about 30 times the weight of a person in X (9 crore ÷ 30 lakh = 30). Under population-based representation, X would get far more seats than Y. India chose the population-based approach for the Rajya Sabha to avoid such a discrepancy.

Key takeaways: the legislature is the centre of democratic politics and the most representative organ; it can choose and dismiss the government. Two Houses provide wider representation and reconsideration. The Rajya Sabha represents the States, is indirectly elected by MLAs, allots seats by population under the Fourth Schedule (unlike the US Senate), has six-year terms with one-third retiring every two years, is never dissolved, and includes twelve nominated members.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is a bicameral legislature?

    1. A legislature elected every two years
    2. A legislature with two Houses
    3. A legislature with two Speakers
    4. A legislature shared by two States
    Show answer

    Answer: B. When a legislature has two Houses, such as the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha, it is called bicameral.

  2. 2. Who elects the members of the Rajya Sabha from a State?

    1. All voters of the State directly
    2. The elected members of the State Legislative Assembly
    3. The Governor
    4. The members of the Lok Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Rajya Sabha is indirectly elected: residents elect MLAs, and the elected MLAs elect the State's Rajya Sabha members.

  3. 3. Why is the Rajya Sabha called the permanent House of Parliament?

    1. Its members serve for life
    2. It meets throughout the year
    3. It is never fully dissolved, since one-third of its members retire every two years
    4. It cannot be addressed by the President
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Because only one-third of members complete their terms every two years, the Rajya Sabha is never dissolved as a whole, unlike the Lok Sabha.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The Rajya Sabha does not give equal representation to every State. Reason (R): The number of members from each State is fixed by the Fourth Schedule according to population, unlike the equal representation of states in the US Senate.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: India chose population-based representation for the Rajya Sabha, so more populous States have more seats.

  5. 5. From which fields does the President nominate twelve members to the Rajya Sabha?

    1. Business, banking and trade
    2. Defence, police and administration
    3. Sports, cinema and journalism only
    4. Literature, science, art and social service
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter states that the twelve nominated members are chosen from among persons who have made their mark in literature, science, art and social service.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery