Revision notes

Chapter 5 Legislature: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Why we need a Parliament, two Houses and the Rajya Sabha

Two principles for a second chamber

  • Symmetrical representation
    • Every unit gets equal seats
    • Size and population ignored
    • Example: US Senate
  • Population-based representation
    • More populous units get more seats
    • Smaller units get fewer seats
    • Example: India's Rajya Sabha (Fourth Schedule)
The Rajya Sabha at a glance
FeatureRajya Sabha
RepresentsThe States of India
How electedIndirectly, by elected members of State Legislative Assemblies
Seats per StateAccording to population, fixed by the Fourth Schedule
Term of a memberSix years; may be re-elected
RenewalOne-third of members retire every two years
DissolutionNever fully dissolved: the permanent House
Nominated membersTwelve, nominated by the President for literature, science, art and social service

A bicameral legislature gives wider representation and a second look at every decision. The Rajya Sabha represents the States, is elected by MLAs, gives more seats to more populous States, and is a permanent House with one-third of members retiring every two years.

Key takeaways: the legislature is the centre of democratic politics and the most representative organ; it can choose and dismiss the government. Two Houses provide wider representation and reconsideration. The Rajya Sabha represents the States, is indirectly elected by MLAs, allots seats by population under the Fourth Schedule (unlike the US Senate), has six-year terms with one-third retiring every two years, is never dissolved, and includes twelve nominated members.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The Lok Sabha and the functions and powers of Parliament

Functions of Parliament described in the chapter
FunctionWhat it involves
LegislativeEnacting laws. In practice the bureaucracy drafts bills under ministers, the Cabinet decides their substance and timing, and private members' bills rarely pass without government support
Control of the executiveMaking sure the executive does not overstep its authority and stays responsible to the people; perhaps the most vital function
FinancialApproving taxes and granting money through the budget; the government must account for what it spends and raises
RepresentationVoicing the divergent views of regional, social, economic and religious groups
DebatingThe highest forum of debate; members may speak freely on any matter
ConstituentDiscussing and enacting constitutional amendments, which need a special majority in both Houses
ElectoralElecting the President and the Vice President
JudicialConsidering proposals to remove the President, Vice President and judges of the High Courts and Supreme Court

Powers of the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha

  • Lok Sabha
    • Makes laws on the Union and Concurrent Lists; introduces and enacts money and non-money bills
    • Approves taxation, budgets and annual financial statements
    • Controls the executive, including by a no-confidence motion
    • Amends the Constitution; approves emergency proclamations
    • Elects President and Vice President; removes judges
  • Rajya Sabha
    • Considers and approves non-money bills; only suggests amendments to money bills
    • Approves constitutional amendments
    • Controls the executive through questions, motions and resolutions, but cannot remove it
    • Takes part in election and removal of President, Vice President and judges; alone can initiate removal of the Vice President
    • Can empower Parliament to legislate on a State List matter

The Lok Sabha, directly elected, controls the purse and can remove the government. The Rajya Sabha, indirectly elected, cannot initiate, reject or amend money bills or remove the government, but its consent is needed to let Parliament legislate on a State List matter. Otherwise the two Houses are co-equal.

Key takeaways: the Lok Sabha is directly elected from single-member territorial constituencies for at most five years and can be dissolved early. Parliament's functions are legislative, control of the executive, financial, representation, debating, constituent, electoral and judicial. The Lok Sabha alone deals with money bills and confidence in the government; the Rajya Sabha's special power protects the States' sphere; on most other matters the two Houses are co-equal.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

How Parliament makes laws

Types of bills

  • By who introduces it
    • Government Bill (a minister)
    • Private Member's Bill (a non-minister)
  • By subject
    • Ordinary Bill: money bill or non-money bill
    • Constitution Amendment Bill

Life of a non-money bill

  1. Idea and drafting Pressure from parties and groups; Cabinet approves; ministry drafts.
  2. Introduction In either House, usually by a minister.
  3. Committee Detailed study; report to the House.
  4. Discussion and vote Accepted or rejected in the first House.
  5. Other House Same procedure; joint session if they disagree.
  6. President's assent Bill becomes law.
Non-money and money bills compared
PointNon-money billMoney bill
Where introducedEither HouseLok Sabha only
Rajya Sabha's powerFull: can pass, amend or rejectCan only suggest changes; cannot reject
Time limit for Rajya SabhaNone specified in the chapter14 days; then deemed passed
If Houses disagreeJoint session may be calledLok Sabha's view prevails; it may accept or reject suggestions

Law-making: Cabinet decision and ministry draft, introduction, committee study, debate and vote, the same process in the other House (joint session if needed), then the President's assent. A money bill starts only in the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha must return it within 14 days with suggestions only.

Key takeaways: bills are government or private member's bills, and money, non-money or constitution amendment bills. Law-making begins with political pressure and Cabinet decisions, then drafting by the ministry, introduction, committee study, debate and voting, and the same in the other House, with a joint session to resolve deadlock, and ends with the President's assent. Money bills start only in the Lok Sabha; the Rajya Sabha can only suggest changes within 14 days.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

How Parliament controls the executive

Instruments of parliamentary control

  • Deliberation and discussion
    • Question Hour
    • Zero Hour
    • Half-an-hour discussion
    • Adjournment motion
  • Approval of laws
    • Bargaining within party, coalition and with opposition
  • Financial control
    • Budget approval
    • CAG and Public Accounts Committee reports
  • No-confidence motion
    • Most powerful weapon
    • Real when majority support is uncertain

Parliament controls the executive through deliberation (especially Question Hour), approval of laws, financial control through the budget and audit reports, and the no-confidence motion, all resting on members' freedom of speech in the House (parliamentary privilege).

Key takeaways: without vigilance, a majority government could become a cabinet dictatorship. Parliamentary privilege protects members' freedom of speech. Parliament controls the executive through deliberation (Question Hour, Zero Hour and other devices), approval of laws, financial control through the budget and audit, and the no-confidence motion, which has real force when coalitions are fragile. Control weakens when sittings shrink and quorum and boycotts disrupt the House.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Parliamentary committees, regulating the House and the anti-defection law

Standing committees and joint parliamentary committees

  • Departmentally related standing committees
    • System developed since 1983
    • Supervise a department's work, budget and expenditure
    • Examine bills relating to the department
    • Continuing bodies
  • Joint Parliamentary Committees
    • Set up for a particular bill or to investigate financial irregularities
    • Members from both Houses
    • Hold a position of eminence
The anti-defection law
AspectAnti-defection law as described in the chapter
Introduced by52nd Amendment Act, 1985; later modified by the 91st Amendment
Who decidesThe presiding officer of the House
What counts as defectionAbsence against party direction, voting against party instructions, or voluntarily leaving the party
PenaltyLoss of membership of the House and disqualification from political office such as minister
Effect in practiceHas not curbed defections; has increased the power of party leaders and presiding officers

Committees do Parliament's detailed work and Parliament rarely rejects their suggestions. The presiding officer regulates the House and decides defection cases. Defection: absence or voting against the party's direction, or voluntarily leaving the party; penalty: loss of seat and disqualification from political office.

Key takeaways: committees, including departmentally related standing committees (since 1983) and joint parliamentary committees, reduce Parliament's burden and their suggestions are rarely rejected. The presiding officer is the final authority on regulating the House, on breaches of privilege and on defection. The anti-defection law (52nd Amendment, 1985, modified by the 91st) penalises defectors with loss of seat and of eligibility for political office, but has strengthened party leaders more than it has stopped defections. The legislature remains the most representative organ of government.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery