• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Legal rights and the state

Explain why legal and constitutional recognition of rights matters, how rights are directed towards the state, and how each right tells the state both what it must do and what it must not do.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the importance of a Bill of Rights and of Fundamental Rights in India.
  • Explain why legal recognition gives rights special status but is not the basis on which they are claimed.
  • Show, with examples, how rights place obligations on the state to act and constraints on what it may do.

Claims to human rights appeal to our moral sense. But whether they succeed depends on several factors, the most important being the support of governments and the law. That is why so much importance is placed on the legal recognition of rights.

Rights in the constitution

Many countries include a Bill of Rights in their constitutions. A constitution is the highest law of the land, so constitutional recognition gives certain rights primary importance. In India these are called Fundamental Rights; other laws and policies are supposed to respect them. The rights in a constitution are those considered of basic importance, sometimes supplemented by provisions reflecting a country's particular history and customs. In India, for example, there is a provision to ban untouchability, which addresses a traditional social practice.

Legal recognition is so important that several theorists define rights as claims recognised by the state. The textbook agrees that legal endorsement gives rights a special status, but it says this is not the basis on which rights are claimed. As the previous lesson showed, rights have been steadily expanded and reinterpreted to include excluded groups and to reflect our understanding of a life of dignity.

Rights are claims on the state

In most cases, rights are directed towards the state: through them people make demands upon it. When I assert my right to education, I call on the state to provide basic education. Society may also contribute: groups may open schools or fund scholarships so that children of all classes benefit. But the primary responsibility rests with the state, which must take the steps needed to fulfil the right.

Every right places obligations on the state: it says what the state must do (for example, protect life and provide education) and what it must not do (for example, arrest a person without giving reasons before a court).

— Key idea, in our own words

What rights require of the state

  • What the state must do
    • Right to education: provide basic education
    • Right to life: make laws protecting people from injury; punish those who harm them
    • If life means a good quality of life: policies for a clean environment and healthy conditions
  • What the state must not do
    • Right to liberty: not arrest people at will
    • Must give reasons before a judicial court to curtail liberty
    • Police must produce an arrest warrant

Take the right to life. It obliges the state to make laws protecting me from injury by others and to punish those who harm me. If a society understands the right to life as a right to a good quality of life, it expects the state to pursue policies that provide a clean environment and other conditions for healthy living.

Now the right to liberty. It means the state cannot simply arrest me at will. If it wants to imprison me it must defend that action and give reasons before a judicial court; that is why the police must produce an arrest warrant. Rights thus place constraints upon state actions.

The state exists for the individual

Rights ensure that the state's authority is exercised without violating the sanctity of individual life and liberty. The state may be the sovereign authority and its laws may be enforced with force, but, the textbook stresses, the sovereign state exists not for its own sake but for the sake of the individual. It is people who matter, and their well-being must be pursued by the government. Rulers are accountable and must remember that law exists for the good of the people.

From a right to state action (example: education)

  1. Claim A child asserts the right to education.
  2. Recognition The right is recognised in law.
  3. State obligation The state must provide schools and teachers.
  4. Society's contribution Groups may also open schools and give scholarships.
  5. Accountability If the state fails, citizens can hold rulers to account.

Worked example 1: must do or must not do?

Classify each as a duty to act or a restraint on the state. (a) The state builds a water treatment plant so a city has safe drinking water. (b) The state does not detain a made-up journalist, Farah, without producing her before a court with reasons. Answers: (a) a duty to act, following from the right to a good quality of life; (b) a restraint, following from the right to liberty.

Worked example 2: is legal recognition the basis of a right?

In a made-up country, a law does not yet recognise the right of children to be protected from hazardous work. Do the children have no right at all? Reasoning: some theorists define rights as claims recognised by the state, which would say 'no right yet'. But the textbook argues that legal endorsement gives special status yet is not the basis of the claim; the children's claim rests on dignity and well-being, and rights have repeatedly been extended through such claims. Conclusion: the children have a justified claim that the law should come to recognise.

Key takeaways: the success of rights claims depends greatly on legal recognition; a Bill of Rights, called Fundamental Rights in India, gives rights primary importance, and India's constitution also bans untouchability. Legal endorsement gives special status but is not the basis of rights. Rights are directed at the state: they oblige it to act (protect life, provide education) and restrain it (no arrest without reasons and a warrant). The sovereign state exists for the individual, and rulers are accountable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In India, the rights recognised in the Constitution as being of basic importance are called:

    1. Directive Principles
    2. Natural Rights
    3. Fundamental Rights
    4. Customary Rights
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says many countries have a Bill of Rights in their constitutions, and in India these are called Fundamental Rights.

  2. 2. Which constitutional provision does the chapter give as an example of a right reflecting India's particular history and customs?

    1. The ban on untouchability
    2. The right to own a car
    3. The right to free markets
    4. The right to a passport
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says India has a provision to ban untouchability, which draws attention to a traditional social practice in the country.

  3. 3. Why must the police produce an arrest warrant before taking a person away, according to the chapter?

    1. Because arrests are illegal
    2. Because the right to liberty means the state must give reasons for curtailing liberty before a court
    3. Because warrants are a tax
    4. Because the right to education requires it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the right to liberty means the state cannot arrest at will; it must give reasons before a judicial court, which is why a warrant is required.

  4. 4. Case: A made-up society comes to see the right to life as including a good quality of life. According to the chapter, what would it then expect of the state?

    1. Nothing beyond punishing murder
    2. To abolish all laws
    3. To leave health entirely to private charity
    4. To pursue policies providing a clean environment and other conditions for healthy living
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says that if a society understands the right to life as a right to a good quality of life, it expects the state to pursue policies for a clean environment and other conditions for a healthy life.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Several theorists define rights as claims recognised by the state. Reason (R): Legal recognition is the only basis on which rights can ever be claimed.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: the chapter says several theorists define rights this way. R is false: the chapter says legal endorsement gives special status but is not the basis on which rights are claimed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery