- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
What are rights? Justified claims for dignity and well-being
Define a right as an entitlement or justified claim, distinguish rights from mere wants, and explain the two grounds on which rights are claimed: dignity and self-respect, and well-being.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a right and explain how it differs from something we merely want.
- Explain the two grounds on which rights are claimed, with examples.
- Explain why some activities harmful to well-being cannot be claimed as rights, and what makes a right universal.
We speak of rights all the time: the right to vote, to form parties, to contest elections. People also make newer claims, such as the right to information, to clean air or to safe drinking water. Rights are claimed in public life and in personal relationships, and not only for adults but, the textbook notes, for children, unborn foetuses and even animals. With the word used in so many ways, Chapter 5 of Political Theory asks three questions: what are rights, on what basis are they claimed, and why are they so important?
A right is a justified claim
A right is essentially an entitlement or a justified claim. It denotes what we are entitled to as citizens, as individuals and as human beings: something we consider due to us and which the rest of society must recognise as a legitimate claim to be upheld.
A right is an entitlement or justified claim: something due to us as citizens, individuals and human beings, which society recognises as legitimate and must uphold.
This does not mean that everything I find desirable is a right. I may want to wear my own clothes to school instead of the uniform, or stay out late at night; that does not give me a right to do so. There is a distinction between what I want and think I am entitled to, and what can be designated as a right. Rights are primarily claims that I, along with others, regard as necessary for a life of respect and dignity.
A want and a right
-
A want
- Something I personally desire
- e.g. wearing my own clothes instead of the uniform
- Need not be recognised by others
-
A right
- A justified claim others also regard as necessary
- e.g. the right to education
- Society must recognise and uphold it
Ground 1: dignity and self-respect
One ground for claiming rights is that they represent conditions we collectively see as sources of self-respect and dignity. The textbook's examples:
- Right to livelihood: gainful employment gives economic independence, central to dignity; having basic needs met frees us to pursue our talents and interests.
- Right to express ourselves freely: lets us be creative and original in writing, dance, music or any creative activity; it is also important for democratic government, since it allows free expression of beliefs and opinions.
Because rights like livelihood and freedom of expression matter for all human beings who live in society, they are described as universal in nature.
Ground 2: well-being
A second ground is that rights are necessary for our well-being: they help individuals develop their talents and skills. The right to education, for instance, develops our capacity to reason, gives useful skills and enables informed choices. In this sense education can be called a universal right.
The same reasoning sets a limit. If an activity is injurious to our health and well-being, it cannot be claimed as a right. Medical research shows that prohibited drugs harm health and affect our relations with others, so we cannot claim a right to take them or to smoke tobacco. Smoking may harm people nearby; drugs may change behaviour and make a person a danger to others. By the definition of rights, these cannot be claimed as rights.
Grounds on which rights are claimed
-
Dignity and self-respect
- Right to livelihood
- Freedom of expression
- Universal for all who live in society
-
Well-being
- Right to education
- Develops reason, skills, informed choice
- Excludes what harms health, e.g. drugs, smoking
Worked example 1: right or want?
Decide for each claim whether it can be called a right. (a) A made-up student, Dev, demands to skip all examinations. (b) A made-up worker, Leela, demands to be able to earn a living. Reasoning: (a) is a personal wish; it is not something others recognise as necessary for a dignified life, and examinations serve learning. (b) livelihood gives economic independence and dignity, a condition people collectively recognise. Answer: (b) is a right; (a) is a want.
Worked example 2: applying the well-being test
Someone argues, 'I have a right to smoke in a crowded bus because it is my body.' Apply the textbook's test: a right must serve well-being. Smoking injures the smoker's health and, in a crowded bus, the health of others nearby. Conclusion: it fails the well-being ground and harms others, so it cannot be claimed as a right.
Key takeaways: a right is an entitlement or justified claim that society must recognise and uphold; not every want is a right. Rights are claimed because they are conditions of dignity and self-respect (livelihood, free expression) and because they are needed for well-being (education). Rights that matter to all human beings in society are universal. Activities that injure health and well-being, such as drug use, cannot be claimed as rights.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, a right is essentially:
- anything a person desires
- a favour granted by a ruler
- an entitlement or a justified claim
- a duty owed to the state
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter defines a right as essentially an entitlement or a justified claim, something society must recognise as a legitimate claim.
-
2. Which example does the chapter use to show that not everything we want is a right?
- Wanting to wear clothes of one's choice to school instead of the prescribed uniform
- Wanting an education
- Wanting to vote
- Wanting a livelihood
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says I may want to wear my own clothes to school or stay out late, but this does not mean I have a right to do so.
-
3. The right to livelihood is linked in the chapter to dignity because:
- it makes people famous
- it removes all laws
- it is granted only to the rich
- gainful employment gives economic independence, central to a person's dignity
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says being gainfully employed gives a person economic independence and is thus central to his or her dignity.
-
4. Why, according to the chapter, cannot taking banned drugs be claimed as a right?
- Because drugs are expensive
- Because it is injurious to health and well-being and may make a person a danger to others
- Because only adults have rights
- Because the right to expression forbids it
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says activities injurious to health and well-being cannot be claimed as rights; drugs harm health and may change behaviour so as to endanger others.
-
5. Assertion (A): Education can be designated a universal right. Reason (R): Education helps develop our capacity to reason, gives useful skills and enables informed choices.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says that because education develops reason, skills and informed choice, contributing to well-being, it can be designated a universal right. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.