• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Rights and responsibilities

Explain the four responsibilities that rights place on each of us: protecting the common good, respecting others' rights, balancing conflicting rights, and staying vigilant about limits placed on rights, including in the name of national security.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how rights oblige us to protect the common good, including for future generations.
  • Explain why my rights are limited by the principle of equal rights for all, and how conflicting rights are balanced.
  • Explain why citizens must be vigilant about restrictions on rights, and the safeguards the textbook mentions.

Rights are not only claims on the state; they also place obligations on each of us. The textbook identifies four such responsibilities. Understanding them prevents the common mistake of treating rights as permission to do anything one likes.

1. Defend the common good

Rights compel us to think beyond personal needs and to defend things that are good for all of us. Protecting the ozone layer, minimising air and water pollution, maintaining green cover by planting trees and preventing deforestation, and maintaining ecological balance are essential for everyone. They represent the common good, which we must protect for ourselves and for future generations, who are entitled to inherit a safe and clean world.

2. Respect the rights of others

If I claim the right to express my views, I must grant the same right to others. If I do not want others to interfere with my choice of dress or music, I must not interfere with theirs. I cannot use free speech to incite a crowd to harm my neighbour. In exercising my rights, I cannot deprive others of theirs. My rights are limited by the principle of equal and same rights for all.

3. Balance rights when they conflict

Rights can conflict. The textbook's example: my freedom of expression lets me take photographs, but photographing a person bathing in his own house without consent and posting the pictures online would violate his right to privacy. Rights must be balanced against each other.

4. Be vigilant about limits on rights

Citizens must watch the limitations placed on their rights. The textbook mentions debate about governments restricting civil liberties on grounds of national security. Security may be defended as necessary for citizens' rights and well-being, but at what point do security restrictions themselves threaten rights? Should a country facing terrorist bombings curtail liberty, arrest on mere suspicion, intercept mail or tap phones, or use torture to extract confessions?

In such situations, the textbook says, the question to ask is whether the person poses an imminent threat to society. Even arrested persons should have legal counsel and the chance to present their case before a magistrate or court. We must be very cautious about giving governments powers that could curtail civil liberties, because such powers can be misused: governments can become authoritarian and undermine the very purpose for which they exist, the well-being of citizens. So, although rights can never be absolute, we must be vigilant in protecting our rights and others', since they form the basis of a democratic society.

Responsibilities that come with rights

  • Common good
    • Ozone layer, clean air and water
    • Green cover, ecological balance
    • For future generations too
  • Respect others' rights
    • Same rights for all
    • No incitement through free speech
  • Balance conflicts
    • Expression versus privacy
  • Vigilance
    • Watch security restrictions
    • Imminent threat test
    • Legal counsel and a court hearing

Rights are never absolute: my rights are limited by the equal rights of others, must be balanced when they conflict, and must be guarded vigilantly so that limits imposed on them do not destroy them.

— Key idea, in our own words

The textbook closes the chapter by reproducing the Preamble of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the UN General Assembly on 10 December 1948, which, among other things, recognises the inherent dignity and equal, inalienable rights of all members of the human family as the foundation of freedom, justice and peace, and calls for these rights to be protected by the rule of law.

Worked example 1: where my rights end

A made-up resident, Kunal, plays drums on his terrace and says, 'It is my right to enjoy music.' His neighbour, Mrs Das, says, 'It is my right to enjoy my music too, and I cannot hear it.' Applying the second responsibility: Kunal's right is limited by the equal right of Mrs Das. If he wants freedom to choose his music, he must not prevent others from enjoying theirs. A balance, such as set hours for drumming, respects both.

Worked example 2: applying the imminent-threat test

In a made-up country, police propose to detain anyone who posts criticism of the government online, citing security. Step 1: ask whether each person poses an imminent threat to society. Criticism alone does not. Step 2: even a genuinely suspected person must get legal counsel and a hearing before a magistrate. Step 3: such sweeping power could be misused and make the government authoritarian. Conclusion: by the textbook's reasoning, the proposal fails; vigilance requires citizens to question it.

Key takeaways: rights bring responsibilities. We must defend the common good, such as a clean environment, including for future generations; respect others' rights, since mine are limited by equal rights for all; balance rights that conflict, such as expression and privacy; and stay vigilant about restrictions, asking whether a person poses an imminent threat and insisting on legal counsel and a court hearing. Rights are never absolute but are the basis of democracy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Protecting the ozone layer and maintaining green cover are described in the chapter as part of:

    1. the common good, which we must protect for ourselves and future generations
    2. cultural rights only
    3. the right to property
    4. national security
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says such things are essential for all of us and represent the common good, to be protected for ourselves and for future generations.

  2. 2. According to the chapter, my rights are limited by:

    1. the wishes of the majority
    2. my income
    3. the principle of equal and same rights for all
    4. the number of my friends
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says that in exercising my rights I cannot deprive others of theirs; my rights are limited by the principle of equal and same rights for all.

  3. 3. The chapter's example of photographing a person bathing in his house without consent and posting the pictures online illustrates:

    1. the right to education
    2. the need to balance freedom of expression with the right to privacy
    3. an economic right
    4. a natural right to property
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter uses this example to show that rights can conflict: freedom of expression allows taking pictures, but doing this would violate the right to privacy.

  4. 4. When restrictions are proposed on grounds of security, the chapter says the question to ask is:

    1. whether the person is wealthy
    2. whether the person belongs to a majority group
    3. whether the restriction is popular
    4. whether the person concerned poses an imminent threat to society
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says the question to ask is whether the person concerned poses an imminent threat to society, and that even arrested persons should have legal counsel and a court hearing.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Citizens must be cautious about giving governments powers to curtail civil liberties. Reason (R): Such powers can be misused, and governments can become authoritarian and undermine the well-being they exist to serve.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. A is false, but R is true
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is true, but R is false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says we must be extremely cautious about such powers because they can be misused and governments can become authoritarian. R explains A.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Rights

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery