- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Where rights come from: natural rights, human rights and Kant
Explain the theory of natural rights, why the term human rights is now preferred, the idea of intrinsic human value and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Kant's moral conception of rights, and how the list of rights has expanded.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the theory of natural rights and the three natural rights it identified.
- Explain why the term human rights is now used more, the idea behind it, and the role of the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
- Explain Kant's distinction between price and dignity and his two arguments for the moral conception of rights.
If rights are justified claims, who or what justifies them? Do we have rights because a ruler grants them, because we are born with them, or because people agree on them? This lesson follows the textbook's account of how thinking about the source of rights has changed.
Natural rights
In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, political theorists argued that rights are given to us by nature or God. The rights of men were derived from natural law, so they were not conferred by a ruler or society; we are born with them. Such rights are inalienable: no one can take them away. These theorists identified three natural rights: life, liberty and property, from which all other rights were said to derive.
The idea that we are born with rights is powerful: it implies that no state or organisation may take away what the law of nature has given. It has been widely used to oppose arbitrary power by states and governments and to safeguard individual freedom.
From natural rights to human rights
Today the term human rights is used more than natural rights. The textbook explains why: the idea of a natural law, a set of norms laid down by nature or God, appears unacceptable to many today. Rights are increasingly seen as guarantees that human beings themselves seek or arrive at in order to lead a minimally good life.
Natural rights and human rights
-
Natural rights
- 17th-18th century theorists
- Given by nature or God through natural law
- Inalienable: life, liberty, property
- Used to oppose arbitrary state power
-
Human rights
- Term more used today
- Guarantees people themselves arrive at
- Due to all simply as human beings
- Basis of the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights
The assumption behind human rights is that all persons are entitled to certain things simply because they are human beings. Each person is unique and equally valuable; all are equal and no one is born to serve others. Each possesses intrinsic value, so all must have equal opportunities to be free and realise their full potential. This idea of a free and equal self is increasingly used to challenge inequalities based on race, caste, religion and gender. The UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the General Assembly on 10 December 1948, builds on this understanding and tries to recognise claims that the world community collectively sees as important for a life of dignity and self-respect.
Human rights rest on the idea that every person, simply by being human, is unique and equally valuable, with intrinsic worth; so all are entitled to equal opportunities to be free and to realise their potential.
Kant on human dignity
The textbook presents the eighteenth-century German philosopher Immanuel Kant. His idea, in our own words: everything has either a price or a dignity. What has a price can be replaced by something equivalent; what is above all price and has no equivalent has dignity. Human beings, unlike objects, possess dignity and are valuable in themselves. A person may be uneducated, poor or powerless, even dishonest; yet he remains a human being and deserves some minimum dignity. For Kant, treating people with dignity means treating them morally, and this became a rallying point against social hierarchies and for human rights.
Kant's view is called the moral conception of rights, resting on two arguments:
- We should treat others as we would like to be treated ourselves.
- We should not treat other people as means to our ends, as we treat a pen, a car or a horse; we should respect people not because they are useful to us but because they are human beings.
Rights expand through struggle and new challenges
Oppressed people around the world have used the idea of universal human rights to challenge laws that segregate them or deny them equal rights. Through the struggles of excluded groups, the interpretation of existing rights has sometimes changed: slavery, for instance, has been abolished, though other struggles have had only limited success, and some communities still struggle to have humanity defined in a way that includes them.
The list of human rights has also expanded as societies face new threats. Concern for the natural environment has produced demands for rights to clean air and water and to sustainable development. Awareness of what women, children and the sick face in war or natural crises has produced demands for a right to livelihood and rights of children. Such claims express moral outrage at violations of dignity and call for rights to be extended to all.
How thinking about the source of rights developed
- Natural law Rights given by nature or God; life, liberty, property.
- Human rights Rights due to every human being, with intrinsic value.
- Universal Declaration (1948) World community recognises claims needed for dignity.
- Expanding list Struggles and new challenges add rights like clean air and children's rights.
Worked example 1: price or dignity?
Using Kant's distinction, classify: (a) a bicycle; (b) a made-up farm labourer, Raju. Reasoning: a bicycle can be replaced by another of equal value, so it has a price. Raju cannot be replaced by an 'equivalent'; he is valuable in himself, so he has dignity. Implication: an employer who treats Raju only as a tool for profit, ignoring his well-being, treats him as a means, which Kant's moral conception forbids.
Worked example 2: identifying the theory
Which theory does each made-up statement reflect? (a) 'No king can take away my liberty, because God gave it to me at birth.' (b) 'Every person, rich or poor, is owed basic dignity because they are human, whatever their usefulness to others.' (c) 'Because pollution now threatens health, people are claiming a right to clean air.' Answers: (a) natural rights; (b) Kant's moral conception and human rights; (c) the expansion of human rights in response to new challenges.
Key takeaways: 17th-18th century theorists held that natural law gives us inalienable rights to life, liberty and property, a powerful check on arbitrary power. Today the term human rights is preferred: rights are due to every person as a uniquely and equally valuable human being, the basis of the UN Universal Declaration of 1948. Kant held that humans have dignity, not price, and must not be treated merely as means. Struggles and new challenges keep expanding the list of rights.
Check your understanding
-
1. The three natural rights identified by seventeenth and eighteenth century theorists were:
- vote, education and work
- life, liberty and property
- speech, religion and assembly
- food, shelter and clothing
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says these theorists identified three natural rights of man: life, liberty and property, from which all others were derived.
-
2. Why, according to the chapter, is the term human rights now used more than natural rights?
- Because natural rights were found in no book
- Because rights are now granted only by kings
- Because the idea of a natural law laid down by nature or God appears unacceptable today
- Because human rights apply only to citizens
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says the idea of a natural law or norms laid down by nature or God appears unacceptable today, so rights are seen as guarantees human beings themselves arrive at.
-
3. For Kant, what is the difference between something with a price and something with dignity?
- What has a price can be replaced by an equivalent; what has dignity has no equivalent
- Things with dignity are always expensive
- There is no difference
- Dignity belongs only to the educated
Show answer
Answer: A. Kant's idea, quoted in the chapter, is that what has a price can be replaced by an equivalent, while what is above all price and has no equivalent has dignity, as human beings do.
-
4. Which of the following is one of the two arguments behind Kant's moral conception of rights?
- Treat people according to their usefulness
- Only the powerful deserve respect
- Rights come from the state alone
- Do not treat other people as means to our ends
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says Kant's moral conception rests on treating others as we would like to be treated, and not treating people as means to our ends like a pen, car or horse.
-
5. Assertion (A): The list of human rights has expanded over the years. Reason (R): Societies face new threats and challenges, such as damage to the environment, which generate demands for new rights like clean air and water.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says the list of human rights has expanded as societies face new threats and challenges, giving environmental concern as an example. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.