• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Introducing nationalism: a powerful and two-sided force

Explain why nationalism is hard to define yet important to study, how it has both united and divided people, and the phases it passed through, from unification in nineteenth-century Europe to the break-up of empires and later separatist demands.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why nationalism needs to be studied even though it is hard to define precisely.
  • Describe the contrasting effects of nationalism in history.
  • Trace its main phases: unification, the break-up of empires, anti-colonial struggles and later separatist demands.

Ask people what nationalism means and you will hear about patriotism, national flags and sacrifice for the country. The Republic Day parade in Delhi is a striking symbol of Indian nationalism, showing the power, strength and diversity many associate with the Indian nation. Chapter 7 of Political Theory does not mainly ask why nationalism arose or what functions it serves; it asks us to think carefully about nationalism and assess its claims and aspirations, recognising both its strengths and its limitations and the need to link it with democracy.

Hard to define, important to study

Look deeper, the textbook says, and it is difficult to arrive at a precise and widely accepted definition of nationalism. That is no reason to give up: nationalism must be studied because it plays such an important role in world affairs. Over the last two centuries or more it has emerged as one of the most compelling political creeds, helping to shape history.

The two faces of nationalism (as the textbook describes)

  • Constructive effects
    • Inspired intense loyalties
    • United people
    • Helped liberate them from oppressive rule
  • Destructive effects
    • Inspired deep hatreds
    • Divided people
    • Caused conflict, bitterness and wars

Nationalism has been a factor in the break-up of empires and states, and nationalist struggles have helped draw and redraw the boundaries of states and empires. Today much of the world is divided into nation-states, but the reordering of boundaries has not ended, and separatist struggles within existing states are common.

Phases of nationalism

Phases of nationalism (as the textbook traces them)

  1. 19th-century Europe: unification Small kingdoms united into larger nation-states; present-day Germany and Italy formed this way; new states also founded in Latin America.
  2. Consolidation of identity Local dialects and loyalties merged into state loyalties and common languages; a new political identity based on the nation-state.
  3. Early 20th century: break-up of empires Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires in Europe.
  4. Anti-colonial struggles Break-up of British, French, Dutch and Portuguese empires in Asia and Africa; India's freedom struggle was a nationalist struggle.
  5. Since 1960: demands within states Groups or regions in apparently stable nation-states make nationalist demands, sometimes for separate statehood.

The textbook notes that a similar process of consolidation took place in India over the last century or more. It also observes that the freedom struggles of India and other former colonies were nationalist struggles, inspired by the wish to build nation-states independent of foreign control.

In recent decades, the textbook says, separatist movements have developed among groups such as the Quebecois in Canada, the Basques in northern Spain, the Kurds in Turkey and Iraq and the Tamils in Sri Lanka, and the language of nationalism is used by some groups in India too. Nationalism can also try to unite several states, as the hope of a pan-Arab union shows, while separatist movements try to divide existing states. We mention these only as the textbook's illustrations of how varied nationalist demands are.

The questions this chapter asks

  1. What is a nation? Why do people form nations, and what do nations aspire to?
  2. Why are people ready to sacrifice, even die, for their nation?
  3. Why and how are claims to nationhood linked to claims to statehood?
  4. Do nations have a right to statehood, or national self-determination? Or can nationalist claims be met without separate statehood?

Nationalism is one of the most compelling political creeds of the last two centuries: it has united and liberated people, and it has also divided them and caused conflict. That is why it must be studied critically.

— Key idea, in our own words

Worked example 1: unification or break-up?

Classify each development described in the textbook. (a) Small kingdoms join to form present-day Italy. (b) The Austro-Hungarian Empire breaks apart in the early twentieth century. (c) India becomes independent of British rule. Answers: (a) unification and consolidation (nineteenth-century Europe); (b) break-up of an empire; (c) anti-colonial nationalism, which also broke up a colonial empire. This shows nationalism can both join and split political units.

Worked example 2: is nationalism still relevant?

A cartoon in the textbook shows one person saying that globalisation has made nations irrelevant, and another replying that nationalism is still alive, pointing to how people follow the national cricket team or how people living abroad still watch Indian films. Weighing it: the chapter itself says nationalism remains a powerful force, that boundaries are still being redrawn, and that separatist demands are common, which supports the second speaker. Globalisation has not ended nationalist feeling.

Key takeaways: nationalism is hard to define precisely but must be studied because it has shaped history for two centuries. It has united and liberated people and also divided them and caused wars. It unified states such as Germany and Italy in the nineteenth century, broke up the Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires and colonial empires, inspired India's freedom struggle, and since 1960 has fuelled demands within existing states. The chapter asks what a nation is and whether nations have a right to statehood.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, which present-day states were formed through unification and consolidation in nineteenth-century Europe?

    1. Germany and Italy
    2. Canada and Spain
    3. India and Sri Lanka
    4. Turkey and Iraq
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says the present-day German and Italian states were formed through a process of unification and consolidation of smaller kingdoms in nineteenth-century Europe.

  2. 2. The chapter says that in the early twentieth century nationalism contributed to the break-up of which empires in Europe?

    1. The Mughal and Maratha empires
    2. The Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires
    3. The Roman and Greek empires
    4. The Chinese and Japanese empires
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says nationalism accompanied and contributed to the break-up of large empires such as the Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires in early twentieth-century Europe.

  3. 3. Why does the chapter say nationalism should be studied even though it is hard to define?

    1. Because it is a new idea
    2. Because it has a single, agreed definition
    3. Because it plays an important role in world affairs
    4. Because it affects only Europe
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says the difficulty of definition is no reason to abandon the effort, because nationalism plays such an important role in world affairs.

  4. 4. India's struggle for freedom from colonial rule is described in the chapter as:

    1. a separatist movement within Britain
    2. a movement for unification of Europe
    3. unrelated to nationalism
    4. a nationalist struggle aimed at an independent nation-state
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says the struggles for freedom by India and other former colonies were nationalist struggles inspired by the desire to establish nation-states independent of foreign control.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Nationalism has both united and divided people. Reason (R): It has helped liberate people from oppressive rule and has also been a cause of conflict, bitterness and wars.

    1. A is true, but R is false
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is false, but R is true
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter describes nationalism's two-sided record: it has united and liberated people and also caused conflict and wars. R explains why it can be said to both unite and divide.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery