• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

What is a nation? An imagined community of belief, history and territory

Explain how a nation differs from a family or a tribe, why no single feature defines all nations, and the first three assumptions on which nations rest: shared beliefs, a sense of history and attachment to a territory.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish a nation from a family and from tribes, clans and other kinship groups.
  • Explain why the textbook calls a nation an 'imagined' community.
  • Explain shared beliefs, a continuing historical identity and attachment to territory as features of nations.

A nation is not just any collection of people, yet it is very different from the other groups we belong to. You will never meet most of your fellow nationals, and you share no family ties with them, yet the nation feels real and valuable to its members. How is that possible? This lesson begins the textbook's answer.

A nation is not a family or a clan

Three kinds of collective belonging

  • Family
    • Face-to-face relationships
    • Each member knows the others personally
  • Tribe, clan, kinship group
    • Linked by marriage and descent
    • Links to members can be traced even if not known personally
  • Nation
    • Most fellow members never met
    • No need for shared descent
    • Yet exists, is lived in and valued

No single common feature

It is commonly believed that a nation is formed by people who share features such as descent, language, religion or ethnicity. But the textbook says there is no common set of characteristics present in all nations. Many nations lack a common language: Canada includes English-speaking and French-speaking peoples, and India has many languages spoken in different regions and communities. Many nations lack a common religion, and the same is true of race or descent.

So what makes a nation? The textbook's answer is that a nation is to a great extent an 'imagined' community, held together by the collective beliefs, aspirations and imaginations of its members. It rests on certain assumptions people make about the collective whole with which they identify. The textbook identifies five; this lesson covers the first three.

A nation is largely an imagined community: it is held together not by any one shared feature like language or religion, but by its members' shared beliefs, memories and hopes about belonging together.

— Key definition, in our own words

1. Shared beliefs

A nation is constituted by belief. Nations are not like mountains, rivers or buildings that exist regardless of what people think. To call a people a nation is not to describe their physical features or behaviour, but to refer to the collective identity and vision for the future of a group that aspires to an independent political existence. The textbook compares a nation to a team: a team is a set of people who play together and, above all, think of themselves as a group; if they stopped doing so they would just be individuals. Likewise, a nation exists when its members believe they belong together.

2. History

People who see themselves as a nation have a sense of continuing historical identity, stretching into the past and reaching into the future. They draw on collective memories, legends and historical records to describe that continuity. Indian nationalists, for example, invoked India's ancient civilisation and cultural heritage to claim a long, continuous history whose civilisational continuity and unity form the basis of the Indian nation. The textbook quotes Jawaharlal Nehru's book The Discovery of India, where, in our words, he wrote that beneath the outward diversity and endless variety of India's people there was everywhere a strong impression of oneness that had held them together through the ages, whatever political misfortunes befell them.

3. Territory

Nations identify with a particular territory. Sharing a past and living together on a territory over a long period gives people a sense of collective identity and helps them imagine themselves as one people. So nations speak of a homeland, which has special significance for them and which they claim as their own. They describe it in different ways, as motherland, fatherland or holy land. A people dispersed around the world may still regard a particular land as their original homeland. The Indian nation identifies with the rivers, mountains and regions of the Indian subcontinent. But because more than one people may claim the same territory, the textbook warns, the aspiration for a homeland has been a major cause of conflict in the world.

Assumptions that constitute a nation (first three)

  • Shared beliefs
    • Exists because members believe they belong together
    • Like a team
  • History
    • Continuing identity from past to future
    • Memories, legends, records
    • Nehru: unity in diversity
  • Territory
    • A homeland: motherland, fatherland, holy land
    • Rival claims can cause conflict

Worked example 1: testing a common-feature definition

A made-up student, Aryan, claims: 'A nation is a group of people who all speak one language.' Test against the chapter's examples: Canada has English and French speakers; India has many languages. Both are nations. Conclusion: language is not a necessary feature, so the definition fails. The same test applies to religion or descent. This is why the textbook turns to shared beliefs and imagination instead.

Worked example 2: applying the team comparison

Eleven made-up players turn up at a ground, but each plays only for personal scores and none thinks of the others as teammates. Are they a team? Reasoning: by the textbook's comparison, no: a team exists because members conceive of themselves as a collective. Applying it to nations: a nation, likewise, depends on its members' belief that they belong together, not on physical features.

Key takeaways: a nation differs from a family (face-to-face) and from kinship groups (traceable descent): its members mostly never meet. No common feature, such as language, religion or descent, is present in all nations. A nation is largely an imagined community resting on assumptions its members share: belief that they belong together, a continuing historical identity (as Nehru expressed for India), and attachment to a homeland, which can also be a source of conflict.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which example does the chapter give of a nation without a common language?

    1. Canada
    2. Italy
    3. Germany
    4. Spain
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter gives Canada, which includes English-speaking and French-speaking peoples, and India, with many languages, as nations without a common language.

  2. 2. The chapter compares a nation to a team in order to show that:

    1. nations must play sports
    2. a nation exists when its members believe they belong together
    3. nations are physical objects
    4. nations need a captain
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says a team exists because members conceive of themselves as a group; similarly, a nation exists when its members believe they belong together.

  3. 3. Jawaharlal Nehru's book quoted in the chapter on the historical identity of India is:

    1. Hind Swaraj
    2. Long Walk to Freedom
    3. The Discovery of India
    4. On Liberty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter quotes Nehru's The Discovery of India on the deep oneness underlying India's outward diversity.

  4. 4. Why, according to the chapter, has the aspiration for a homeland been a major cause of conflict?

    1. Because homelands are always small
    2. Because only one nation exists
    3. Because territory has no meaning for nations
    4. Because more than one set of people may lay claim to the same territory
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says that since more than one set of people may claim the same territory, the aspiration for a homeland has been a major cause of conflict.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): A nation is to a great extent an 'imagined' community. Reason (R): There is no common set of characteristics, such as language, religion or descent, present in all nations.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter argues that because no shared objective feature defines all nations, a nation must be understood as held together by the collective beliefs and imaginations of its members. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery