- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Shared political ideals versus a common cultural identity
Explain why a shared vision of the future and political ideals distinguish nations from other groups, why the textbook argues democracies should define the nation in political rather than cultural terms, and what counts as the strongest test of loyalty.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the role of shared political ideals in distinguishing a nation from other groups.
- Explain the textbook's two reasons why basing a nation on a common religion or language can threaten democratic values.
- Explain why democracies should seek loyalty to constitutional values, and what the textbook calls the strongest test of loyalty.
Beliefs, history and territory create a sense of oneness. But many groups share a past and a place without becoming nations. What makes the difference? The textbook's fourth and fifth assumptions answer this, and lead to an important argument about what kind of nationalism suits a democracy.
4. Shared political ideals
It is a shared vision of the future and the collective aspiration to an independent political existence that distinguishes nations from other groups. Members of a nation share a vision of the kind of state they want to build, affirming values and principles such as democracy, secularism and liberalism. These ideals are the terms on which they come together and agree to live together: their political identity as a nation.
In a democracy, the textbook says, a shared commitment to political values and ideals is the most desirable basis of a political community or nation-state. Members are bound by obligations that arise from recognising each other's rights as citizens. A nation is strengthened when people accept these obligations to fellow members; indeed, recognition of this framework of obligations is the strongest test of loyalty to the nation.
In a democracy the best basis of a nation is a shared commitment to political values. Accepting our obligations to fellow citizens, which come from recognising their rights, is the strongest test of loyalty to the nation.
5. Common political identity, not a single culture
Many people believe a shared political vision is not enough to bind a nation, and seek a shared cultural identity such as a common language or descent. The textbook accepts that a common language eases communication and a common religion gives shared beliefs and practices; shared festivals, holidays and symbols can bring people together. But it warns that this can also threaten democratic values, for two reasons:
- Religions are internally diverse. All major religions have survived and evolved through dialogue within the community, and contain sects that interpret texts and norms differently. Ignoring these differences to forge an identity on a single religion is likely to create a highly authoritative and oppressive society.
- Most societies are culturally diverse. People of different religions and languages live on the same territory. Imposing a single religious or linguistic identity as a condition of belonging would exclude some groups, restricting their religious liberty or disadvantaging those who do not speak the national language. Either way, the democratic ideal of equal treatment and liberty for all would be severely limited.
For both reasons, the textbook concludes, it is desirable to imagine the nation in political rather than cultural terms: democracies should emphasise and expect loyalty to a set of values that may be enshrined in the Constitution, rather than adherence to a particular religion, race or language.
Two ways of imagining a nation, as the textbook compares them
-
Cultural terms
- Common religion, language or descent required
- Eases communication and shared practice
- Risk: oppresses internal diversity
- Risk: excludes minorities; limits equal liberty
-
Political terms
- Shared commitment to constitutional values
- Open to people of all religions and languages
- Loyalty shown by accepting obligations to fellow citizens
- Recommended by the textbook for democracies
A cartoon in the chapter makes the point gently: one person asks another why he does not cheer for the national team and whether he lacks nationalist spirit; the other replies that he votes, pays his taxes, respects the laws and is proud of his country. In the textbook's framework, the second person shows loyalty in the way that matters most in a democracy, through obligations to fellow citizens.
The five assumptions about a nation
- Shared beliefs
- History
- Territory
-
Shared political ideals
- Distinguishes nations from other groups
-
Common political identity
- Best defined politically, not culturally
Worked example 1: which basis is more inclusive?
A made-up country, Sundaria, has three religions and four languages. Proposal X: 'Only those who speak the majority language are true Sundarians.' Proposal Y: 'Every citizen who upholds the Constitution's values of equality and liberty is a true Sundarian.' Reasoning: X excludes speakers of three languages and disadvantages them, limiting equal treatment. Y includes all who share political values, whatever their religion or language. By the textbook's argument, Y is the more desirable basis for a democracy.
Worked example 2: the test of loyalty
Two made-up citizens: Pritam shouts slogans at every match but cheats on taxes and harasses neighbours of another faith. Salma rarely watches sport but pays taxes, obeys laws and stands up for her neighbours' rights. Applying the textbook: the strongest test of loyalty is recognising obligations that arise from fellow citizens' rights. Salma meets this test; Pritam's display does not, since he violates others' rights. This shows why the chapter links loyalty to obligations, not to displays.
Key takeaways: a shared vision of the future and aspiration to independent political existence distinguish nations from other groups; members affirm ideals such as democracy and secularism. In a democracy, the best basis of a nation is a shared commitment to political values, and recognising obligations to fellow citizens is the strongest test of loyalty. Basing nationhood on a single religion or language risks oppressing internal diversity and excluding minorities, so the textbook argues for defining the nation politically, through loyalty to constitutional values.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, what distinguishes groups from nations?
- A common diet
- A shared vision of the future and the collective aspiration to have an independent political existence
- Living in the same city
- Having the same sports team
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says that while territory and history create oneness, it is a shared vision of the future and the aspiration to independent political existence that distinguishes groups from nations.
-
2. What does the chapter call the strongest test of loyalty to the nation?
- Recognition of the framework of obligations to fellow members that arises from recognising their rights
- Cheering loudly at sports events
- Speaking only one language
- Following one religion
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says that obligations arise from recognising each other's rights as citizens, and recognition of this framework of obligations is the strongest test of loyalty.
-
3. Which is one of the chapter's reasons why basing a nation on a common religion can threaten democratic values?
- Religions have no festivals
- Religion is irrelevant to people
- Religions are internally diverse, and ignoring these differences can create an oppressive society
- Religions forbid national flags
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says all major religions are internally diverse, with sects that interpret texts differently; forging a single religious identity that ignores this is likely to create an authoritative and oppressive society.
-
4. The chapter concludes that democracies should expect loyalty to:
- a particular religion
- a particular race
- a single national language
- a set of values that may be enshrined in the Constitution
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says it is desirable to imagine the nation in political terms, with democracies expecting loyalty to values enshrined in the Constitution rather than to a religion, race or language.
-
5. Assertion (A): Imposing a single linguistic identity as a condition of belonging to a state would limit democratic ideals. Reason (R): Most societies are culturally diverse, so such a condition would exclude some groups and deny them equal treatment.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says that in culturally diverse societies, imposing one language would disadvantage those who do not speak it, limiting equal treatment and liberty. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.