- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Nationalism and pluralism: group rights, many identities and Tagore's critique
Explain how democracies accommodate cultural diversity through group rights and an inclusive national identity, why self-determination has been reinterpreted, why people's many identities matter, and Rabindranath Tagore's critique of narrow nationalism.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the group rights democracies grant to cultural minorities and how they are justified.
- Explain why independent statehood for every nationality is neither possible nor desirable, and how self-determination has been reinterpreted.
- Explain the importance of multiple identities and Tagore's critique of narrow nationalism.
If 'one culture, one state' is abandoned, a new question arises: how can different cultures and communities survive and flourish within one country? This is the question of pluralism, and it brings together the chapter's arguments about nationalism and democracy.
Recognising and protecting cultural minorities
Many democracies have introduced measures to recognise and protect the identity of cultural minority communities. The textbook notes that the Indian Constitution has an elaborate set of provisions for protecting religious, linguistic and cultural minorities. Group rights granted in various countries include:
- Constitutional protection for the language, culture and religion of minority groups and their members.
- In some cases, the right of identified communities to representation as a group in legislative bodies and other state institutions.
Such rights may be justified because they give members of these groups equal treatment and protection of the law, and protect the group's cultural identity. Groups need recognition as part of the national community, which means the national identity must be defined inclusively, recognising the importance and unique contribution of all cultural communities in the state.
Recognition may not satisfy every group: some may still demand separate statehood, which may seem paradoxical in an age of globalisation, but nationalist aspirations continue to motivate many communities. The textbook says that considerable generosity and skill are needed for countries to deal with such demands democratically.
Self-determination reinterpreted
The right to national self-determination was often understood to include independent statehood for nationalities. The textbook argues that granting statehood to every group that sees itself as a distinct nation would be impossible and probably undesirable: it could create many states too small to be economically and politically viable, and could multiply the problems of minorities. So the right has now been reinterpreted to mean granting certain democratic rights for a nationality within a state.
Two understandings of self-determination
-
Older understanding
- Independent statehood for each nationality
- Impossible for every group
- Risk of unviable small states
- Multiplies minority problems
-
Reinterpreted understanding
- Democratic rights for a nationality within a state
- Group rights and inclusive national identity
- Equal citizenship for all communities
Many identities, one citizenship
We live in a world deeply conscious of the importance of recognising identities, and many struggles for recognition use the language of nationalism. The textbook urges that while we acknowledge identity claims, we must not let them lead to division and violence. Each person has many identities, based on gender, caste, religion, language or region, and may be proud of all of them. As long as people feel free to express all dimensions of their personality, they may not feel the need to demand political concessions for any one identity. In a democracy, the political identity of citizen should encompass the different identities people have. It would be dangerous to allow intolerant and homogenising forms of identity and nationalism to develop.
In a democracy, the identity of citizen should embrace the many identities each person holds. Intolerant nationalism that tries to make everyone the same is dangerous.
Tagore's critique of nationalism
The textbook presents Rabindranath Tagore's view. Tagore opposed colonial rule and asserted India's right to independence; he felt that British colonial administration had no place for upholding the dignity of human relationships, an idea otherwise valued in British civilisation. In a famous statement, which we paraphrase, he said that patriotism could not be his final spiritual shelter; his refuge was humanity, and he would never let patriotism triumph over humanity as long as he lived.
Tagore's position (as the textbook presents it)
-
Opposed
- Colonial rule
- Narrow expressions of nationalism in parts of the freedom movement
-
Distinguished
- Opposing western imperialism
- from rejecting western civilisation
-
Advocated
- Being rooted in one's own culture and heritage
- Learning freely and profitably from abroad
- Humanity above patriotism
-
Feared
- Rejecting the west could turn into hostility to influences present in India, such as Christianity, Judaism, Zoroastrianism and Islam
A critique of what Tagore called 'patriotism' is a persistent theme in his writings. He made a distinction between opposing western imperialism and rejecting western civilisation: Indians should be rooted in their own culture but should not resist learning from abroad. He was critical of narrow nationalism in parts of the independence movement, fearing that rejecting the west in favour of what looked like Indian tradition was limiting and could turn into hostility towards other influences long present in India.
Worked example 1: is this an inclusive measure?
A made-up state allows a linguistic minority to run its own schools teaching in its language, while all citizens have the same voting and legal rights. Analysis: this is a group right protecting a minority's culture (language) while preserving equal citizenship. By the textbook's reasoning, it gives equal protection of the law and recognition as part of the national community, so national identity is defined inclusively.
Worked example 2: applying Tagore's distinction
During a made-up freedom struggle, one leader says, 'We must end foreign rule.' Another says, 'We must reject every idea, book and science that came from abroad.' Applying Tagore: the first opposes imperialism, which Tagore supported. The second rejects foreign civilisation altogether, which Tagore warned was limiting and could become hostility to others. Tagore would agree with the first and criticise the second.
Key takeaways: democracies accommodate pluralism through group rights (protection of minority language, culture and religion; sometimes group representation) and an inclusive national identity; India's Constitution has elaborate minority provisions. Independent statehood for every nationality is impossible and probably undesirable, so self-determination is now reinterpreted as democratic rights within a state. Each person has many identities, which citizenship should encompass; intolerant, homogenising nationalism is dangerous. Tagore put humanity above patriotism and opposed imperialism without rejecting learning from the west.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, the right to national self-determination has now been reinterpreted to mean:
- independent statehood for every nationality
- granting certain democratic rights for a nationality within a state
- abolishing minority rights
- a single language for all states
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says the right has been reinterpreted to mean granting certain democratic rights for a nationality within a state, since statehood for every group is neither possible nor desirable.
-
2. Why does the chapter consider independent statehood for every distinct cultural group probably undesirable?
- It would create states too small to be viable and multiply the problems of minorities
- Small states are always richer
- Minorities do not exist
- Globalisation forbids it
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says it might lead to states too small to be economically and politically viable, and could multiply the problems of minorities.
-
3. Rabindranath Tagore, as presented in the chapter, distinguished between:
- Hindi and English
- rich and poor nations
- opposing western imperialism and rejecting western civilisation
- democracy and monarchy
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says Tagore distinguished opposing western imperialism from rejecting western civilisation: Indians should be rooted in their culture but free to learn from abroad.
-
4. According to the chapter, what should the political identity of citizen do in a democracy?
- Replace all other identities
- Recognise only religious identity
- Exclude regional identities
- Encompass the different identities people may have
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says each person has many identities and that in a democracy the political identity of citizen should encompass them; intolerant, homogenising nationalism is dangerous.
-
5. Assertion (A): Group rights such as constitutional protection of minority languages and cultures can be justified. Reason (R): They provide equal treatment and protection of the law to group members and protect the group's cultural identity.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says such rights may be justified on the grounds that they provide equal treatment and protection of the law and protect cultural identity. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.