Revision notes

Chapter 7 Nationalism: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Introducing nationalism: a powerful and two-sided force

The two faces of nationalism (as the textbook describes)

  • Constructive effects
    • Inspired intense loyalties
    • United people
    • Helped liberate them from oppressive rule
  • Destructive effects
    • Inspired deep hatreds
    • Divided people
    • Caused conflict, bitterness and wars

Phases of nationalism (as the textbook traces them)

  1. 19th-century Europe: unification Small kingdoms united into larger nation-states; present-day Germany and Italy formed this way; new states also founded in Latin America.
  2. Consolidation of identity Local dialects and loyalties merged into state loyalties and common languages; a new political identity based on the nation-state.
  3. Early 20th century: break-up of empires Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires in Europe.
  4. Anti-colonial struggles Break-up of British, French, Dutch and Portuguese empires in Asia and Africa; India's freedom struggle was a nationalist struggle.
  5. Since 1960: demands within states Groups or regions in apparently stable nation-states make nationalist demands, sometimes for separate statehood.

Nationalism is one of the most compelling political creeds of the last two centuries: it has united and liberated people, and it has also divided them and caused conflict. That is why it must be studied critically.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: nationalism is hard to define precisely but must be studied because it has shaped history for two centuries. It has united and liberated people and also divided them and caused wars. It unified states such as Germany and Italy in the nineteenth century, broke up the Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires and colonial empires, inspired India's freedom struggle, and since 1960 has fuelled demands within existing states. The chapter asks what a nation is and whether nations have a right to statehood.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

What is a nation? An imagined community of belief, history and territory

Three kinds of collective belonging

  • Family
    • Face-to-face relationships
    • Each member knows the others personally
  • Tribe, clan, kinship group
    • Linked by marriage and descent
    • Links to members can be traced even if not known personally
  • Nation
    • Most fellow members never met
    • No need for shared descent
    • Yet exists, is lived in and valued

A nation is largely an imagined community: it is held together not by any one shared feature like language or religion, but by its members' shared beliefs, memories and hopes about belonging together.

— Key definition, in our own words

Assumptions that constitute a nation (first three)

  • Shared beliefs
    • Exists because members believe they belong together
    • Like a team
  • History
    • Continuing identity from past to future
    • Memories, legends, records
    • Nehru: unity in diversity
  • Territory
    • A homeland: motherland, fatherland, holy land
    • Rival claims can cause conflict

Key takeaways: a nation differs from a family (face-to-face) and from kinship groups (traceable descent): its members mostly never meet. No common feature, such as language, religion or descent, is present in all nations. A nation is largely an imagined community resting on assumptions its members share: belief that they belong together, a continuing historical identity (as Nehru expressed for India), and attachment to a homeland, which can also be a source of conflict.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Shared political ideals versus a common cultural identity

In a democracy the best basis of a nation is a shared commitment to political values. Accepting our obligations to fellow citizens, which come from recognising their rights, is the strongest test of loyalty to the nation.

— Key idea, in our own words

Two ways of imagining a nation, as the textbook compares them

  • Cultural terms
    • Common religion, language or descent required
    • Eases communication and shared practice
    • Risk: oppresses internal diversity
    • Risk: excludes minorities; limits equal liberty
  • Political terms
    • Shared commitment to constitutional values
    • Open to people of all religions and languages
    • Loyalty shown by accepting obligations to fellow citizens
    • Recommended by the textbook for democracies

The five assumptions about a nation

  • Shared beliefs
  • History
  • Territory
  • Shared political ideals
    • Distinguishes nations from other groups
  • Common political identity
    • Best defined politically, not culturally

Key takeaways: a shared vision of the future and aspiration to independent political existence distinguish nations from other groups; members affirm ideals such as democracy and secularism. In a democracy, the best basis of a nation is a shared commitment to political values, and recognising obligations to fellow citizens is the strongest test of loyalty. Basing nationhood on a single religion or language risks oppressing internal diversity and excluding minorities, so the textbook argues for defining the nation politically, through loyalty to constitutional values.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

National self-determination: claims, costs and a paradox

National self-determination is a nation's claim to govern itself and decide its own future, seeking recognition by the international community as a distinct political entity or state.

— Key definition, in our own words

Redrawing boundaries on 'one culture, one state' (as the textbook describes)

  1. Demand Each culturally distinct group wants its own state.
  2. Redrawing After World War I, the Treaty of Versailles creates small new states.
  3. Human cost Mass migration, millions displaced, communal violence.
  4. Outcome New states still contain minorities, often disadvantaged.
  5. Lasting problem Accommodating minorities as equal citizens.

Key takeaways: national self-determination is a nation's claim to govern itself and be recognised as a distinct political entity. 'One culture, one state' gained ground in nineteenth-century Europe and shaped boundaries after World War I (Treaty of Versailles), at the cost of mass migration, displacement and violence, while minorities remained. Anti-colonial movements also used self-determination, leading to the paradox of new states resisting minorities' claims. The textbook suggests the answer lies in making existing states more democratic and equal.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Nationalism and pluralism: group rights, many identities and Tagore's critique

Two understandings of self-determination

  • Older understanding
    • Independent statehood for each nationality
    • Impossible for every group
    • Risk of unviable small states
    • Multiplies minority problems
  • Reinterpreted understanding
    • Democratic rights for a nationality within a state
    • Group rights and inclusive national identity
    • Equal citizenship for all communities

In a democracy, the identity of citizen should embrace the many identities each person holds. Intolerant nationalism that tries to make everyone the same is dangerous.

— Key idea, in our own words

Tagore's position (as the textbook presents it)

  • Opposed
    • Colonial rule
    • Narrow expressions of nationalism in parts of the freedom movement
  • Distinguished
    • Opposing western imperialism
    • from rejecting western civilisation
  • Advocated
    • Being rooted in one's own culture and heritage
    • Learning freely and profitably from abroad
    • Humanity above patriotism
  • Feared
    • Rejecting the west could turn into hostility to influences present in India, such as Christianity, Judaism, Zoroastrianism and Islam

Key takeaways: democracies accommodate pluralism through group rights (protection of minority language, culture and religion; sometimes group representation) and an inclusive national identity; India's Constitution has elaborate minority provisions. Independent statehood for every nationality is impossible and probably undesirable, so self-determination is now reinterpreted as democratic rights within a state. Each person has many identities, which citizenship should encompass; intolerant, homogenising nationalism is dangerous. Tagore put humanity above patriotism and opposed imperialism without rejecting learning from the west.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery