• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Are constitutions static? Why India's Constitution has endured

Compare India's single, continuing Constitution with countries that rewrote theirs, explain the two reasons the chapter gives for its durability, and explain how the framers balanced the Constitution as sacred and as an instrument open to change.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Compare constitutional change in the USSR and France with India's experience.
  • Give the two reasons why the same Constitution continues to serve India.
  • Explain the dual role of a constitution and how the framers balanced it.

Many nations rewrite their constitutions after political upheavals or changes of ideas. India has been governed by the same Constitution since it came into force. This chapter explains how that has been possible: through amendment, through interpretation, and through political maturity.

Constitutions that changed

The chapter gives two examples. The Soviet Union had four constitutions in its 74 years (1918, 1924, 1936 and 1977); after Communist Party rule ended in 1991 and the federation disintegrated, the new Russian federation adopted a new constitution in 1993. France experimented continuously after its revolution: the First Republic followed the post-revolution constitution of 1793, the Second Republic began in 1848, the Third in 1875, the Fourth in 1946, and the Fifth Republic in 1958 with yet another constitution. A cartoon voice draws the lesson that constitutional change is closely linked to political developments.

India's Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949 and came into force on 26 January 1950, and the same Constitution continues to frame the country's government. (A cartoon voice also notes that the US Constitution, more than 200 years old, has been amended only 27 times.)

Changing and enduring constitutions
CountryConstitutional history described in the chapter
Soviet Union / RussiaFour constitutions: 1918, 1924, 1936, 1977; Russia adopted a new one in 1993
FranceConstitutions for the First (1793), Second (1848), Third (1875), Fourth (1946) and Fifth (1958) Republics
IndiaOne Constitution, adopted 26 November 1949, in force since 26 January 1950, amended many times

Why has India's Constitution lasted?

Is it so good that it needs no change, or were its makers so farsighted that they foresaw everything? The chapter says both are partly true: India inherited a robust Constitution whose basic framework suits the country, and its makers provided solutions for many future situations. But no constitution can provide for every eventuality. The real answers are two:

  1. The Constitution accepts the necessity of modification according to the changing needs of society.
  2. In actual working there has been enough flexibility of interpretation: both political practice and judicial rulings have shown maturity and flexibility.

These factors have made the Constitution a living document rather than a closed and static rulebook.

The contemporary and the durable

Those who draft a constitution naturally try to tackle the problems of their own time, but the constitution must also frame government for the future. So every constitution has something contemporary and something of more durable importance. It is a document made by human beings and may need revision. It reflects a society's dreams and aspirations, yet it is also a framework for democratic governance, an instrument that societies create for themselves.

This dual role raises a difficult question. Is the constitution so sacred that nobody can ever change it? Or is it so ordinary that it can be changed like any law? The framers struck a balance: they placed the Constitution above ordinary law and expected future generations to respect it, while recognising that it might need modification, especially where opinion was divided at the time and might later settle one way. So the Indian Constitution combines both approaches: it is respected as a sacred document and treated as an instrument open to change. It is not static, not the final word on everything, and not unalterable.

Two views of a constitution, and India's balance

  • Sacred document
    • Expresses a society's dreams and philosophy
    • Should not be changed lightly
    • Placed above ordinary law
  • Instrument of government
    • Made by human beings
    • Framework that may need revision
    • Must respond to new needs
  • India's balance
    • Respected and above ordinary law
    • Yet amendable by a special procedure
    • Kept alive by interpretation

A living constitution is respected as fundamental law yet able to change: India's has endured because it allows amendment and because political practice and judicial interpretation have applied it flexibly.

Worked example 1: evaluate the statements

Students made four claims. (a) 'The Constitution is like any other law.' (b) 'The Constitution should be changed every ten or fifteen years.' (c) 'The Constitution is the country's philosophy and can never be changed.' (d) 'Any talk of changing it is undemocratic.' Evaluation using the chapter: (a) is wrong because the Constitution is placed above ordinary law. (b) is wrong because a constitution needs stability; change should come when needs arise, not on a fixed schedule. (c) and (d) are wrong because the framers deliberately allowed amendment; the Constitution is not unalterable.

Worked example 2: why not rewrite it?

A made-up country replaces its constitution after every change of regime. Analysis: like the USSR and France in the chapter, its constitution follows political upheaval and never builds lasting respect. India avoided this because its Constitution could be amended and reinterpreted within a continuing framework, so changes did not require starting over.

Key takeaways: the USSR and France repeatedly replaced their constitutions, while India has kept one Constitution since 1950. It endures because it accepts amendment and because political practice and judicial rulings have interpreted it flexibly, making it a living document. Every constitution mixes the contemporary with the durable, and India's framers balanced respect for the Constitution as fundamental law with openness to change.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How many constitutions did the Soviet Union have in its 74 years, according to the chapter?

    1. Two
    2. Four
    3. Five
    4. One
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the Soviet Union had four constitutions: 1918, 1924, 1936 and 1977.

  2. 2. Which two reasons does the chapter give for the same Constitution continuing to serve India?

    1. It was never amended, and courts never interpreted it
    2. It was written by foreign experts, and it is short
    3. It accepts modification according to changing needs, and its working has allowed flexible interpretation
    4. It was approved by referendum, and it cannot be changed
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Constitution accepts the necessity of modification, and both political practice and judicial rulings have shown flexibility in interpretation.

  3. 3. Which statement best describes how the framers treated the Constitution?

    1. As an ordinary law changeable like any other
    2. As a sacred text that can never be changed
    3. As a temporary document to be replaced after ten years
    4. As above ordinary law, deserving respect, yet open to modification when needed
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The framers placed the Constitution above ordinary law and expected respect for it, while recognising it might require modification.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Every constitution contains something contemporary and something of durable importance. Reason (R): A constitution responds to the problems of its own time and must also provide a framework of government for the future.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because framers address present problems while building a lasting framework, a constitution combines contemporary and durable elements.

  5. 5. In which year did the Fifth French Republic come into being with a new constitution?

    1. 1848
    2. 1958
    3. 1946
    4. 1875
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter lists the Second Republic in 1848, the Third in 1875, the Fourth in 1946 and the Fifth in 1958.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → How the Constitution is amended

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery