• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

How the Constitution is amended

Explain why the Constitution is both flexible and rigid, describe the three methods of amendment, and state the features of the procedure under Article 368 that make it relatively simple and based on elected representatives.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish flexible and rigid constitutions and explain why India's combines both.
  • Describe the three methods of amendment with examples of articles.
  • State the features of the amendment procedure and the principle of parliamentary sovereignty behind it, and compare it with other countries.

The framers wanted the Constitution to be amendable when necessary but protected from unnecessary and frequent change. In other words, they wanted it to be both flexible and rigid.

Flexible and rigid

A constitution that can be changed very easily is called flexible; one that is very difficult to amend is called rigid. India's combines both. The framers knew the Constitution could not be free of errors and wanted mistakes to be easy to correct; some provisions were also temporary and could be altered once a new Parliament was elected. But the Constitution set up a federal polity, so the rights and powers of the States could not be changed without their consent; and some features were so central to its spirit that they had to be protected from change. These considerations produced different ways of amending the Constitution.

Three methods of amendment

Ways of amending the Constitution
MethodWhat is requiredExamples or scope
Like an ordinary lawSimple majority in ParliamentArticles that say Parliament may act 'by law', for example Article 2 (admitting new States) and Article 3 (changing a State's area)
Special majority (Article 368)Special majority in each House of Parliament separatelyMost provisions, for example Fundamental Rights
Special majority plus State ratification (Article 368)Special majority in Parliament and consent of the legislatures of half the StatesProvisions on the distribution of powers between the Union and States, and on representation

Where an article says Parliament may do something 'by law', as in Articles 2 and 3, Parliament can change it without using the Article 368 procedure, so there is no difference between such an amendment and an ordinary law. These parts are very flexible. Article 368 says, in substance, that Parliament may, in exercise of its constituent power, amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any provision of the Constitution according to the procedure in that article.

How the Constitution can be amended

  • Simple majority
    • Articles that say 'by law'
    • Same as ordinary law-making
    • Most flexible
  • Special majority in both Houses
    • Article 368
    • Most other provisions
  • Special majority plus half the States
    • Article 368
    • Federal distribution of powers
    • Representation

Features of the amendment procedure

  • All amendments are initiated only in Parliament.
  • Apart from the special majority in Parliament, no outside agency, such as a constitution commission or separate body, is needed.
  • No referendum is required to ratify an amendment.
  • An amendment bill goes to the President for assent like other bills, but the President cannot send it back for reconsideration.
  • The procedure is therefore relatively simple, compared with how complicated it could have been.

More importantly, the process underlines a principle: only elected representatives of the people can consider and finally decide amendments. So parliamentary sovereignty (the sovereignty of elected representatives) is the basis of the amendment procedure.

How other constitutions do it

Two principles dominate amendment procedures around the world. One is special majority: the US Constitution uses a two-thirds majority, and South Africa and Russia require three-fourths for some amendments. The other is people's participation: in Switzerland people can even initiate an amendment, and in countries such as Russia and Italy people initiate or approve amendments. India uses special majority and limited State participation but no referendum.

Three routes: simple majority for articles that say 'by law'; special majority of each House under Article 368; special majority plus consent of half the State legislatures for federal and representation provisions. Amendments begin only in Parliament, need no referendum, and the President cannot return them.

Worked example 1: which method?

Identify the method for each made-up change. (a) Increasing the area of a State. (b) Changing a provision of the right to freedom of religion. (c) Moving a subject from the State List to the Union List. (d) Changing a provision about the Election Commission. Answers: (a) simple majority, since Article 3 lets Parliament do this 'by law'; (b) special majority in both Houses; (c) special majority plus ratification by half the State legislatures, since it changes the distribution of powers; (d) special majority in both Houses.

Worked example 2: can a State start an amendment?

A made-up State wants the Constitution amended to give States more taxing powers. Reasoning: amendments can be initiated only in Parliament, so the State must persuade members of Parliament to introduce the bill. Because the change affects the distribution of powers, if Parliament passes it by special majority, at least half the State legislatures must also ratify it. A cartoon voice in the chapter sees the first point as another example of favouring the centre.

Worked example 3: India and Switzerland

Compare: in Switzerland, citizens can initiate an amendment; in India, only Parliament can. Reasoning: India's procedure rests on the sovereignty of elected representatives rather than direct popular participation. It avoids a referendum, keeping the process relatively simple, but still demands broad support through special majorities.

Key takeaways: India's Constitution is both flexible and rigid. Articles that say 'by law' can be changed by simple majority; most other provisions need a special majority in each House under Article 368; and federal and representation provisions also need ratification by half the State legislatures. Amendments start only in Parliament, need no outside body or referendum, and cannot be returned by the President, reflecting the sovereignty of elected representatives.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Articles 2 and 3 can be changed by Parliament through a simple law because:

    1. they are temporary provisions
    2. they concern Fundamental Rights
    3. they contain the words 'by law', so Parliament need not use the Article 368 procedure
    4. the States must always ratify them
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The wording 'by law' in Articles 2 and 3 indicates that Parliament can modify them like an ordinary law, without the Article 368 procedure.

  2. 2. Which kind of amendment requires ratification by the legislatures of half the States?

    1. Any amendment to Fundamental Rights
    2. An amendment changing the distribution of powers between the Union and the States
    3. Any amendment to Article 3
    4. Every amendment to the Constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: B. When an amendment affects the distribution of powers between the States and the centre, or representation, it needs special majority plus ratification by half the State legislatures.

  3. 3. Which statement about the amendment procedure is correct?

    1. Amendments can be initiated in State legislatures
    2. Every amendment needs a referendum
    3. The President can send an amendment bill back for reconsideration
    4. Amendments are initiated only in Parliament, and no referendum is required
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Amendments begin only in Parliament; no outside body or referendum is needed; the President cannot return an amendment bill for reconsideration.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Parliamentary sovereignty is the basis of the amendment procedure. Reason (R): Only elected representatives of the people are empowered to consider and finally decide amendments.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since only elected representatives decide amendments, without referendum or outside bodies, the procedure rests on their sovereignty.

  5. 5. In which country, according to the chapter, can people even initiate an amendment to the constitution?

    1. The United States
    2. India
    3. Switzerland
    4. South Africa
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says that in Switzerland people can initiate an amendment; India relies on Parliament.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery