• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why there have been so many amendments

Analyse the pattern of amendments described in the textbook and classify them as technical, products of differing interpretations, products of political consensus, or controversial, with the chapter's examples.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why the number of amendments does not depend only on the strength of the ruling party.
  • Classify amendments into the chapter's groups with examples.
  • Explain why the 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments were controversial and how the 43rd and 44th restored balance.

Given its relatively difficult amendment procedure, the number of amendments to India's Constitution seems high: according to the textbook, it had been amended 106 times by 26 January 2024, when it completed 74 years. Why so many, and what does this tell us?

The pattern of amendments

The textbook's graphs show that the two decades from 1970 to 1990 saw many amendments. They also show that ten amendments were made in just three years between 1974 and 1976, and again ten in three years between 2001 and 2003. These two periods were politically very different: the first was a period when one party had a very large majority in Parliament and in most State Assemblies; the second was a period of coalition politics, with different parties ruling different States and bitter rivalry among parties. So the frequency of amendments does not depend merely on the size of the ruling party's majority. Apart from the first decade, every decade has seen a steady stream of amendments, irrespective of the party in power.

Group 1: technical or administrative amendments

Many amendments only clarify, explain or slightly modify original provisions. They are amendments in the legal sense but make no substantial difference:

  • the 15th amendment raised the retirement age of High Court judges from 60 to 62 years;
  • the 54th amendment increased the salaries of High Court and Supreme Court judges;
  • reservation of seats for SC and ST in legislatures was originally for ten years and has been extended by ten years at a time through successive amendments; these extensions do not change the original provision;
  • an amendment to Article 74(1) made explicit that the Council of Ministers' advice binds the President, which is what had always happened in practice.

Group 2: differing interpretations

Many amendments arose when the judiciary and the government of the day interpreted the Constitution differently. Parliament then amended the Constitution to make one interpretation authoritative. It is part of democratic politics that institutions interpret the Constitution, and especially their own powers, differently. Between 1970 and 1975 this happened often: Parliament repeatedly amended the Constitution to overcome adverse judicial interpretations on the relationship between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles, the scope of the right to property, and the scope of Parliament's amending power. The chapter notes that this history can be fully understood only in the context of the politics of that period.

Group 3: amendments through political consensus

A large group reflects consensus among parties on changes needed to express prevailing political philosophy and aspirations. Many amendments after 1984 belong here, which explains the puzzle of many amendments in a coalition era. Examples include the anti-defection amendments (52nd and 91st), the 61st amendment lowering the voting age from 21 to 18, the 73rd and 74th amendments on local government, and amendments clarifying and expanding reservations in jobs and admissions (the 77th, 81st and 82nd), passed without much difficulty after a consensus emerged around 1992-93.

Group 4: controversial amendments

Amendments between 1970 and 1980 generated much legal and political controversy; the parties then in opposition saw many as attempts by the ruling party to subvert the Constitution. The 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments were the most controversial. They were made against the background of the internal emergency declared in June 1975 and sought basic changes in crucial parts of the Constitution. The 42nd amendment was especially wide-ranging: it tried to override the Kesavananda ruling, extended the Lok Sabha's term from five to six years, added the Fundamental Duties, restricted judicial review, and changed the Preamble, the Seventh Schedule and 53 articles; the textbook notes that many opposition MPs were in jail when it was passed. After the 1977 elections, in which the ruling party was defeated, the new government reconsidered these changes and, through the 43rd and 44th amendments, cancelled most of the changes made by the 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments, restoring constitutional balance.

Kinds of amendments described in the chapter

  • Technical or administrative
    • 15th: High Court judges retire at 62
    • 54th: judges' salaries
    • Ten-year extensions of SC/ST seats
    • Article 74(1) clarified
  • Differing interpretations
    • 1970-75: overcoming judicial rulings
    • Rights and Directive Principles, property, amending power
  • Political consensus
    • 52nd and 91st: anti-defection
    • 61st: voting age 18
    • 73rd and 74th: local government
    • 77th, 81st, 82nd: reservations
  • Controversial
    • 38th, 39th, 42nd during the emergency
    • Undone mostly by 43rd and 44th

Many amendments are technical, many settle clashes of interpretation, many reflect consensus, and a few, such as the 38th, 39th and 42nd, were deeply controversial and were largely undone by the 43rd and 44th; what matters is the content of amendments, not their number.

Worked example 1: classify the amendment

Classify each. (a) Lowering the voting age from 21 to 18. (b) Raising High Court judges' retirement age to 62. (c) An amendment in the early 1970s passed to override a court ruling on property. (d) An amendment passed during the emergency that restricted judicial review. Answers: (a) political consensus (61st); (b) technical (15th); (c) differing interpretations; (d) controversial (42nd).

Worked example 2: what does the 2001-2003 burst tell us?

Ten amendments were made in 2001-2003, a period of coalition government and sharp party rivalry. Which conclusion fits best? (i) One party had a strong majority. (ii) There were no differences among parties. (iii) The amendments were broadly non-controversial and parties agreed on their subjects. Reasoning: (i) is false for a coalition period; (ii) contradicts the bitter rivalry the chapter notes; (iii) fits, because in a coalition era amendments needed broad agreement to pass. So (iii).

Worked example 3: counting the extensions

SC and ST reservation in legislatures was originally for ten years from 1950 and has been extended by ten years at a time. Working: 1950 + 10 = 1960 (first expiry). The textbook mentions six such extension amendments. Each one changes only the date, not the principle, which is why the chapter calls them technical amendments.

Key takeaways: the textbook records 106 amendments by 2024, but numbers mislead. Bursts of amendments came both under a dominant single party (1974-76) and under coalitions (2001-03). Amendments fall into technical changes, responses to differing interpretations (frequent in 1970-75), changes made by political consensus (many after 1984), and a few controversial ones (38th, 39th, 42nd), most of whose changes were reversed by the 43rd and 44th amendments.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which amendment raised the retirement age of High Court judges from 60 to 62, given in the chapter as a technical amendment?

    1. 61st
    2. 42nd
    3. 15th
    4. 73rd
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The 15th amendment raised the retirement age of High Court judges from 60 to 62; the chapter treats it as technical.

  2. 2. Which amendment lowered the minimum voting age from 21 to 18 years?

    1. 44th
    2. 61st
    3. 52nd
    4. 91st
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 61st amendment brought the voting age down from 21 to 18; the chapter lists it among amendments made through political consensus.

  3. 3. Which three amendments does the chapter call the most controversial?

    1. 73rd, 74th and 91st
    2. 15th, 54th and 61st
    3. 38th, 39th and 42nd
    4. 43rd, 44th and 52nd
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments, made against the background of the 1975 emergency, are described as the most controversial.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The number of amendments does not depend merely on the size of the ruling party's majority. Reason (R): Bursts of ten amendments in three years occurred both in 1974-76, under a dominant party, and in 2001-03, under coalition politics.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since amendments came quickly under very different political conditions, majority size alone cannot explain their number.

  5. 5. How was much of the change made by the controversial amendments of the 1970s undone?

    1. By a referendum in 1980
    2. By the 43rd and 44th amendments after the 1977 elections
    3. By the Supreme Court abolishing them all
    4. By the President refusing assent
    Show answer

    Answer: B. After the 1977 elections, the new government used the 43rd and 44th amendments to cancel most changes made by the 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery