- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Special majority and ratification by the States
Calculate whether an amendment bill wins the special majority required in each House, explain why the procedure demands broad consensus, and explain when and why the States must ratify an amendment.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Apply the two conditions of special majority to numerical cases.
- Explain why special majority forces a ruling party to seek broad support.
- Explain why some amendments need ratification by half the States and how the procedure stays workable.
The special majority is the heart of India's amendment procedure. Understanding it explains why amendments require wide political agreement.
What special majority means for amendments
Ordinary business of a legislature needs only a simple majority of members voting. For example, if all 247 members present vote on a bill, at least 124 must support it. An amendment bill needs two special conditions in each House:
- those voting in favour must be at least half of the total strength of that House; and
- they must also be at least two-thirds of those actually voting.
Both Houses must pass the bill separately in this way; there is no joint session for amendment bills. The textbook's illustration uses the total strength of the Lok Sabha: any amendment needs the support of at least half of the total strength, however few members are present, so even if only a small number attend, that absolute number must still vote in favour.
The principle: broad consensus
A party with a thin majority can pass ordinary laws and the budget without the opposition's agreement. But to amend the Constitution, it must usually take at least some opposition parties into confidence. So the basic principle behind the procedure is that amendments should rest on broad support among parties and parliamentarians. Dr B.R. Ambedkar argued, in substance, that if those dissatisfied with the Constitution cannot obtain even a two-thirds majority, their dissatisfaction cannot be considered to be shared by the general public. The chapter notes that he was pointing beyond parliamentary arithmetic to public opinion as the principle behind majorities.
Ratification by the States
For some articles special majority is not enough. When an amendment seeks to modify articles on the distribution of powers between the States and the centre, or articles on representation, the States must be consulted and give consent. Federalism means the powers of the States must not be at the mercy of the central government, so legislatures of half the States must pass the amendment before it takes effect. For these parts, wider consensus is expected, and States participate in amendment.
Even this stricter route is kept workable: consent of only half the States is needed, and a simple majority in each State legislature is enough. So the Constitution can be amended through large-scale consensus and limited participation of the States. The founders protected it from easy tampering yet gave future generations the right to amend it as needed.
Path of an amendment affecting the distribution of powers
- Introduced in Parliament Only Parliament can initiate.
- Special majority in House 1 Half of total strength and two-thirds of those voting.
- Special majority in House 2 Passed separately; no joint session.
- Ratified by half the States Simple majority in each State legislature.
- President's assent Cannot be returned for reconsideration.
Worked example 1: is the special majority met?
A made-up House has a total strength of 250. Case A: 180 members vote and 125 support the bill. Case B: 220 vote and 140 support it. Case C: 220 vote and 150 support it. Working: half of total strength = 250 ÷ 2 = 125, so at least 125 must vote yes. Case A: two-thirds of 180 = 120; 125 meets both 120 and 125, so it passes. Case B: two-thirds of 220 = 146.67, so at least 147 are needed; 140 fails. Case C: 150 meets both 147 and 125, so it passes.
Worked example 2: the binding condition
In the same made-up House of 250, only 150 members attend and vote. How many must support? Working: two-thirds of 150 = 100, but half of total strength is 125. Both conditions must hold, so at least 125 must vote yes, which is more than 100. When attendance is low, the total-strength condition is the one that binds; when attendance is high, the two-thirds condition binds.
Worked example 3: thin majority, big change
A made-up ruling coalition holds 135 of 250 seats in one House. Reasoning: with 135 seats it can pass ordinary bills (a simple majority of those voting). For an amendment, if all 250 vote, it needs two-thirds of 250 = 166.67, so 167 votes. It is 167 − 135 = 32 votes short, so it must win support from opposition members. This is the chapter's point: amendments demand broad consensus.
| Requirement | Ordinary bill | Amendment bill (special majority) |
|---|---|---|
| Votes needed | Simple majority of members voting | At least half of total strength and two-thirds of those voting |
| Both Houses | Yes; joint session possible for deadlock | Yes, separately; no joint session |
| States | Not involved | Half the State legislatures, only for federal and representation provisions |
| President | Can return once (non-money bills) | Cannot return |
Special majority: in each House, yes-votes must be at least half of the total strength and at least two-thirds of those voting. For federal and representation provisions, half the State legislatures must also ratify by simple majority.
Key takeaways: an amendment bill needs, in each House separately, support from at least half the total strength and two-thirds of those voting, with no joint session. This forces a ruling party to seek broad support, reflecting Ambedkar's link between majorities and public opinion. Amendments to the distribution of powers or representation also need ratification by half the State legislatures, by simple majority, which keeps the process demanding but workable.
Check your understanding
-
1. What are the two conditions of the special majority required for a constitutional amendment in each House?
- A simple majority of those present and the President's approval
- Two-thirds of the total strength and a referendum
- Three-fourths of total strength only
- At least half of the total strength of the House and two-thirds of those voting
Show answer
Answer: D. Supporters must be at least half of the total strength of the House and at least two-thirds of those actually voting, in each House separately.
-
2. A made-up House has a total strength of 300. If 240 members vote on an amendment bill, what is the minimum number of yes-votes needed?
- 120
- 160
- 151
- 200
Show answer
Answer: B. Half of total strength = 150, so at least 150 are needed. Two-thirds of 240 = 160. Both conditions must hold, so at least 160 yes-votes are needed.
-
3. If the two Houses disagree on an amendment bill, what happens?
- A joint session decides
- The President decides
- There is no joint session; each House must pass it separately
- The Supreme Court decides
Show answer
Answer: C. There is no provision for a joint session for amendment bills; both Houses must pass the bill separately with special majority.
-
4. Assertion (A): A ruling party with a thin majority usually needs some opposition support to amend the Constitution. Reason (R): An amendment requires the support of at least two-thirds of those voting, which is more than a thin majority.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: a two-thirds requirement exceeds a narrow majority, so the ruling party must win over some opposition members.
-
5. What is required from the States when an amendment affects the distribution of powers?
- Consent of all State legislatures by two-thirds majority
- No State involvement
- Consent of the Governors only
- Consent of the legislatures of half the States, by simple majority
Show answer
Answer: D. Legislatures of half the States must pass the amendment, and a simple majority in each State legislature is enough, keeping the procedure workable.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.