Revision notes

Chapter 9 Constitution as a Living Document: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Are constitutions static? Why India's Constitution has endured

Changing and enduring constitutions
CountryConstitutional history described in the chapter
Soviet Union / RussiaFour constitutions: 1918, 1924, 1936, 1977; Russia adopted a new one in 1993
FranceConstitutions for the First (1793), Second (1848), Third (1875), Fourth (1946) and Fifth (1958) Republics
IndiaOne Constitution, adopted 26 November 1949, in force since 26 January 1950, amended many times

Two views of a constitution, and India's balance

  • Sacred document
    • Expresses a society's dreams and philosophy
    • Should not be changed lightly
    • Placed above ordinary law
  • Instrument of government
    • Made by human beings
    • Framework that may need revision
    • Must respond to new needs
  • India's balance
    • Respected and above ordinary law
    • Yet amendable by a special procedure
    • Kept alive by interpretation

A living constitution is respected as fundamental law yet able to change: India's has endured because it allows amendment and because political practice and judicial interpretation have applied it flexibly.

Key takeaways: the USSR and France repeatedly replaced their constitutions, while India has kept one Constitution since 1950. It endures because it accepts amendment and because political practice and judicial rulings have interpreted it flexibly, making it a living document. Every constitution mixes the contemporary with the durable, and India's framers balanced respect for the Constitution as fundamental law with openness to change.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

How the Constitution is amended

Ways of amending the Constitution
MethodWhat is requiredExamples or scope
Like an ordinary lawSimple majority in ParliamentArticles that say Parliament may act 'by law', for example Article 2 (admitting new States) and Article 3 (changing a State's area)
Special majority (Article 368)Special majority in each House of Parliament separatelyMost provisions, for example Fundamental Rights
Special majority plus State ratification (Article 368)Special majority in Parliament and consent of the legislatures of half the StatesProvisions on the distribution of powers between the Union and States, and on representation

How the Constitution can be amended

  • Simple majority
    • Articles that say 'by law'
    • Same as ordinary law-making
    • Most flexible
  • Special majority in both Houses
    • Article 368
    • Most other provisions
  • Special majority plus half the States
    • Article 368
    • Federal distribution of powers
    • Representation

Three routes: simple majority for articles that say 'by law'; special majority of each House under Article 368; special majority plus consent of half the State legislatures for federal and representation provisions. Amendments begin only in Parliament, need no referendum, and the President cannot return them.

Key takeaways: India's Constitution is both flexible and rigid. Articles that say 'by law' can be changed by simple majority; most other provisions need a special majority in each House under Article 368; and federal and representation provisions also need ratification by half the State legislatures. Amendments start only in Parliament, need no outside body or referendum, and cannot be returned by the President, reflecting the sovereignty of elected representatives.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Special majority and ratification by the States

Path of an amendment affecting the distribution of powers

  1. Introduced in Parliament Only Parliament can initiate.
  2. Special majority in House 1 Half of total strength and two-thirds of those voting.
  3. Special majority in House 2 Passed separately; no joint session.
  4. Ratified by half the States Simple majority in each State legislature.
  5. President's assent Cannot be returned for reconsideration.
Ordinary bills and amendment bills compared
RequirementOrdinary billAmendment bill (special majority)
Votes neededSimple majority of members votingAt least half of total strength and two-thirds of those voting
Both HousesYes; joint session possible for deadlockYes, separately; no joint session
StatesNot involvedHalf the State legislatures, only for federal and representation provisions
PresidentCan return once (non-money bills)Cannot return

Special majority: in each House, yes-votes must be at least half of the total strength and at least two-thirds of those voting. For federal and representation provisions, half the State legislatures must also ratify by simple majority.

Key takeaways: an amendment bill needs, in each House separately, support from at least half the total strength and two-thirds of those voting, with no joint session. This forces a ruling party to seek broad support, reflecting Ambedkar's link between majorities and public opinion. Amendments to the distribution of powers or representation also need ratification by half the State legislatures, by simple majority, which keeps the process demanding but workable.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Why there have been so many amendments

Kinds of amendments described in the chapter

  • Technical or administrative
    • 15th: High Court judges retire at 62
    • 54th: judges' salaries
    • Ten-year extensions of SC/ST seats
    • Article 74(1) clarified
  • Differing interpretations
    • 1970-75: overcoming judicial rulings
    • Rights and Directive Principles, property, amending power
  • Political consensus
    • 52nd and 91st: anti-defection
    • 61st: voting age 18
    • 73rd and 74th: local government
    • 77th, 81st, 82nd: reservations
  • Controversial
    • 38th, 39th, 42nd during the emergency
    • Undone mostly by 43rd and 44th

Many amendments are technical, many settle clashes of interpretation, many reflect consensus, and a few, such as the 38th, 39th and 42nd, were deeply controversial and were largely undone by the 43rd and 44th; what matters is the content of amendments, not their number.

Key takeaways: the textbook records 106 amendments by 2024, but numbers mislead. Bursts of amendments came both under a dominant single party (1974-76) and under coalitions (2001-03). Amendments fall into technical changes, responses to differing interpretations (frequent in 1970-75), changes made by political consensus (many after 1984), and a few controversial ones (38th, 39th, 42nd), most of whose changes were reversed by the 43rd and 44th amendments.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The basic structure doctrine and the Constitution as a living document

Rigidity and flexibility after Kesavananda Bharati

  • Rigid side
    • Basic structure cannot be amended
    • Judiciary decides what it includes
  • Flexible side
    • Parliament may amend any other part
    • Amendment procedure remains relatively simple

Basic structure (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973; reaffirmed in Minerva Mills, 1980): Parliament may amend any part of the Constitution except its basic structure, and the judiciary decides what that structure is. Interpretation by the courts, accepted by political leaders, keeps the Constitution a living document.

Key takeaways: the Kesavananda Bharati ruling (1973) limited Parliament's amending power to everything except the basic structure and made the judiciary its final judge; Minerva Mills (1980) reaffirmed it, and all institutions, including the 2000 review commission, have accepted it. Judicial interpretation, such as the fifty per cent ceiling on reservations and the creamy layer, has informally amended the Constitution. Reading the spirit as well as the letter, and political leaders' maturity in accepting limits, have kept the Constitution a living document whose final authority is the people.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery