| Country | Constitutional history described in the chapter |
|---|---|
| Soviet Union / Russia | Four constitutions: 1918, 1924, 1936, 1977; Russia adopted a new one in 1993 |
| France | Constitutions for the First (1793), Second (1848), Third (1875), Fourth (1946) and Fifth (1958) Republics |
| India | One Constitution, adopted 26 November 1949, in force since 26 January 1950, amended many times |
Two views of a constitution, and India's balance
-
Sacred document
- Expresses a society's dreams and philosophy
- Should not be changed lightly
- Placed above ordinary law
-
Instrument of government
- Made by human beings
- Framework that may need revision
- Must respond to new needs
-
India's balance
- Respected and above ordinary law
- Yet amendable by a special procedure
- Kept alive by interpretation
A living constitution is respected as fundamental law yet able to change: India's has endured because it allows amendment and because political practice and judicial interpretation have applied it flexibly.
Key takeaways: the USSR and France repeatedly replaced their constitutions, while India has kept one Constitution since 1950. It endures because it accepts amendment and because political practice and judicial rulings have interpreted it flexibly, making it a living document. Every constitution mixes the contemporary with the durable, and India's framers balanced respect for the Constitution as fundamental law with openness to change.