• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The narrators and the writers' craft in Memories of Childhood

Describe the two child narrators and their responses, and explain how each writer creates her effect: sound imagery and symbolism in Zitkala-Sa, a long joyful catalogue and a sudden turn in Bama.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe each narrator with qualities and evidence.
  • Explain the symbolism of long hair and of the packet held by its string.
  • Identify sensory imagery, lists and shifts in tone.
  • Explain the value of a child's point of view in autobiography.

Both pieces are autobiography - true accounts of the writer's own life - but told through the eyes of a child. How they are written matters as much as what happens, and long answers often ask about the narrators' responses and the writers' techniques.

The narrator of The Cutting of My Long Hair

The young Zitkala-Sa is proud, sensitive and spirited. She notices everything strange: the noise, the tight clothes, the loss of her blanket and moccasins. Unlike her friend Judewin, who believes they must submit because the others are strong, she decides to struggle. She hides, fights when found, and cries aloud during the haircut. Her defeat is physical, not moral: she lost the fight, but her resistance shows the spirit that would later make her a writer against oppression.

The narrator of We Too are Human Beings

The young Bama is curious, lively and observant, then sensitive and indignant. She enjoys every sight of the bazaar and laughs at the elder's odd way of carrying the packet - until she understands its meaning. Her laughter turns to sadness and anger, and she wonders why her people should run errands for those who despise them. She channels her anger into study, following her brother's advice, and succeeds.

PointZitkala-SaBama
QualitiesProud, defiant, sensitive to humiliationCurious, observant, indignant, determined
Moment of realisationHearing her hair will be cutLearning why the packet was held by its string
ResponseOpen resistance - hides and fightsInner anger, then hard study
OutcomeOverpowered; feels her spirit lostStands first in class; wins friends

Symbols

  • Long hair: for Zitkala-Sa, a sign of identity, dignity and courage; cutting it forcibly stands for stripping away her culture.
  • The blanket and moccasins replaced by stiff shoes and tight dresses: the forced change of identity.
  • Bells: mechanical control - eating by formula, obeying signals she cannot understand.
  • The packet held by its string: the absurd distance created by caste prejudice, even though the food was wrapped twice.
  • The muzzled cattle at the threshing floor: a quiet image of labour controlled by those who own the harvest - a reader may see in it the workers' own condition.

The writers' techniques

TechniqueZitkala-SaBama
ImageryHarsh sounds: a bell crashing, shoes clattering, voices murmuring an unknown tongue; the cold blades of scissorsColourful sights: a performing monkey, a snake-charmer, coffee poured between tumblers, seasonal fruits and snacks
StructureA steady build-up of fear to a single traumatic eventA long, joyful list that suddenly turns serious
ToneAnguish, fear, defianceHumour and delight, then sadness and anger
ComparisonHerself as a wooden puppet; children herded like animalsHer people treated as less than human: hence the title

How Bama's tone shifts

  1. Delight The bazaar's sights hold her back.
  2. Amusement The elder carrying a packet so oddly.
  3. Understanding Her brother explains the reason.
  4. Sadness and anger Why should our people be treated so?
  5. Resolve Study hard; claim dignity.

Why a child's point of view?

A child sees injustice without the excuses adults learn. Zitkala-Sa does not know the reasons behind the rules; she only feels the humiliation. Bama first finds the scene comic because she does not yet know the 'rule' of caste - and her innocent laughter makes the truth more shocking. The child's view lets readers see discrimination freshly, as something strange and wrong.

Worked example 1: their responses compared

Model answer: Zitkala-Sa responds with open resistance: she refuses to submit, hides under a bed and fights when she is dragged out, though she is finally overpowered. Bama's response is inward at first - sadness and anger at the elder's humiliation - and then constructive: on her brother's advice she studies hard and wins respect by coming first in class. Both refuse to accept their treatment as natural.

Worked example 2: Bama's long description of the bazaar

Model answer: The long, lively list of the bazaar's sights shows a child's joy and curiosity and draws the reader into her world. It also makes the turn that follows more powerful: from a world full of fun she suddenly sees an ugly custom, and her laughter changes to anger.

A child's eyes do not excuse injustice; they simply see it.

Key takeaways: Zitkala-Sa is defiant and resists openly; Bama is observant and responds with study. Sound imagery and symbols mark Zitkala-Sa's account; a joyful catalogue and a sharp change of tone mark Bama's. The child's viewpoint makes injustice vivid.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How does Zitkala-Sa respond when she hears about the haircut?

    1. She agrees calmly.
    2. She asks her mother.
    3. She hides under a bed and resists.
    4. She cuts her own hair.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. She refuses to submit, hides and struggles when she is found.

  2. 2. What does long hair symbolise for Zitkala-Sa?

    1. Identity, dignity and courage in her culture
    2. Fashion
    3. School rules
    4. Cold weather
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In her culture short hair meant mourning or cowardice; her long hair represented identity and pride.

  3. 3. What is the effect of Bama's long list of bazaar sights?

    1. It shows she was lazy.
    2. It describes the landlord.
    3. It explains caste.
    4. It shows a child's joy and makes the later turn to anger more striking.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The joyful catalogue draws us into her world, so the discovery of injustice hits harder.

  4. 4. How does Bama's tone change in the episode?

    1. From anger to joy
    2. From delight and amusement to sadness and anger
    3. From fear to boredom
    4. It never changes.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. She laughs at the elder until she learns why he carried the packet that way; then she feels sad and furious.

  5. 5. Which image from Zitkala-Sa's account shows loss of individuality?

    1. Feeling like one animal in a herd being driven along
    2. Coffee poured between tumblers
    3. A snake in a box
    4. The almond tree
    Show answer

    Answer: A. She feels she has become just one animal in a driven herd - no longer an individual.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery