- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing from Memories of Childhood: an article on dignity for every child, a memory piece, and long answers
Write an article arguing that schools must protect every child's dignity, write a short autobiographical memory using the writers' techniques, and plan long answers comparing the two accounts.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Write an article on equality and dignity in schools.
- Write a short autobiographical paragraph with sensory detail and reflection.
- Plan a comparison answer on the two accounts.
- Write respectfully and accurately about discrimination.
The chapter invites writing that is both personal and public: memories of childhood, and arguments about how society should treat every child. This lesson models both, with care for accurate and respectful language.
Model article (original)
No Child Should Hide Their Tiffin Box
By Rhea Fernandes (a made-up student)
Every child carries something from home into the classroom: a language, a name, a festival, a way of dressing, a lunch. When that something is mocked, the child learns a painful lesson - that who they are is not welcome.
History shows how deep such wounds can go. Writers who were children in very different places have described being forced to change their appearance to fit in, or seeing their elders treated as less than human. Such memories stay for a lifetime. The Indian Constitution guarantees equality and abolishes untouchability, yet attitudes change more slowly than laws.
Schools can lead that change. Teachers can celebrate the many languages and foods in a class; seating and group work can mix students freely; any joke that targets a child's caste, religion, region or appearance can be treated as the serious harm it is. Most of all, every child should hear, in words and actions, that they belong.
Dignity is not a reward for good marks. It is every child's birthright. Let our classrooms be places where no child ever needs to hide.
Writing a memory (autobiographical paragraph)
Model (original): The first time I saw the sea, I was nine. I remember the smell before the sight - salt and frying fish - and then the sudden roar, like a crowd cheering somewhere I couldn't see. My father held my wrist so tightly it hurt. I ran anyway, straight into a wave that knocked me flat and filled my mouth with sand. I came up laughing. I did not know then that it was the last holiday we would take together, but I have kept that laugh ever since.
Shaping a childhood memory
- Choose one moment A single scene, not a whole year.
- Begin with a sense A sound, smell or texture.
- Add a vivid detail Something only you would remember.
- Show the child's feeling Fear, joy, confusion.
- End with adult reflection What it means to you now.
Long answer: comparing the two accounts
Worked example: plan for 'Compare the experiences and responses of the two writers.'
- Introduction: two marginalised women recall childhood humiliation.
- Zitkala-Sa: racial and cultural discrimination; forced haircut, loss of identity; open resistance, overpowered; later wrote against oppression.
- Bama: caste discrimination; elder's humiliation; laughter turns to anger; responds by studying hard and excelling.
- Similarities: child's view; sense of injustice; refusal to accept.
- Differences: physical resistance versus education; immediate defeat versus achievement.
- Conclusion: both assert human dignity.
Write about discrimination with accuracy and respect: describe what happened, name the injustice, and keep the people's dignity at the centre.
Key takeaways: an article on dignity should combine examples, a link to principles such as equality, practical suggestions and an appeal. A memory piece begins with the senses, focuses on one moment and ends with reflection. Comparison answers should set out similarities and differences clearly.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the central argument of the model article?
- Tiffin boxes should be banned.
- Every child's dignity and background must be respected at school.
- Students should eat only sandwiches.
- Schools should avoid festivals.
Show answer
Answer: B. It argues that schools must make every child feel they belong and protect their dignity.
-
2. Which is the best way to begin an autobiographical memory?
- With a list of dates
- With a sense impression of one moment
- With the writer's full address
- With a moral lesson
Show answer
Answer: B. Starting with a sound, smell or texture of a single moment draws the reader into the memory.
-
3. Which point belongs under 'differences' in a comparison of the two accounts?
- Both writers were children.
- Both faced humiliation.
- Zitkala-Sa resisted physically, while Bama responded through education.
- Both refused to accept injustice.
Show answer
Answer: C. Their responses differ: open struggle versus hard study. The other points are similarities.
-
4. Which closing line best suits the article?
- Let our classrooms be places where no child ever needs to hide.
- That is all.
- Tiffin boxes are useful.
- Please give me marks.
Show answer
Answer: A. It ends with an appeal that captures the article's argument.
-
5. Why does the model memory end with an adult reflection?
- To add a new character
- To give the date
- To show what the remembered moment means to the writer now
- To change the topic
Show answer
Answer: C. Autobiographical writing gains depth when the adult looks back and reflects on the child's experience.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.