- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Themes of Memories of Childhood: marginalisation, dignity and resistance
Explain the common theme of the two accounts, distinguish racial and cultural discrimination from caste discrimination, discuss whether children notice injustice, and write long answers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the commonality of theme in the two accounts.
- Name the kind of discrimination each writer faced.
- Discuss whether the seeds of rebellion are sown early in life.
- Write structured 120-150 word answers.
The two episodes are set on different continents and in different centuries, yet they belong together. This lesson identifies what unites them and how each writer's response points towards dignity and change.
The common theme
Both accounts show marginalised communities being humiliated by a dominant group, and both show children recognising that humiliation for what it is. Both writers lose some innocence: Zitkala-Sa through a forced change of identity, Bama through seeing an elder bow to a man who would not touch his hand's offering. Both stories assert the same claim that gives Bama's episode its title: we too are human beings, deserving dignity and respect.
Two kinds of discrimination
| Point | Zitkala-Sa | Bama |
|---|---|---|
| Kind of discrimination | Racial and cultural - against Native Americans and their way of life | Caste-based - untouchability practised against Dalits |
| How it works | Forcing children to give up their dress, language, customs and hair to fit the dominant culture | Refusing touch, making people run errands and bow, asking a person's street to know his caste |
| Also faced | Prejudice against women, as the introduction notes | Economic dependence on landlords |
| Response | Resistance; later, writing against oppression | Anger channelled into education |
What unites the two accounts
-
Marginalisation
- Native Americans in the USA
- Dalits in a Tamil village
-
Humiliation
- Forced haircut and dress
- Untouchability in everyday life
-
A child's awakening
- Feels the loss of spirit
- Laughter turns to anger
-
A response
- Resistance and later writing
- Education and achievement
Are the seeds of rebellion sown early?
Yes, the accounts suggest that even young children notice injustice. Zitkala-Sa does not understand the rules but feels their wrongness and fights them. Bama, still in the third class, quickly understands what the packet means and asks why her people should accept it. Their early anger becomes adult action: Zitkala-Sa grew up to criticise the school system in her writing; Bama wrote her autobiography about caste. Oppression may take a long time to be resisted, but resistance often begins with a child's sense of fairness.
Education as a path to dignity
Annan tells Bama that people of their community are denied honour and respect, but that study and progress can help them throw off such indignities. Bama's success - standing first and gaining friends - shows education as a tool of empowerment. (In India, untouchability is abolished by Article 17 of the Constitution, but the episode shows how long social practices can persist.)
Worked example 1: 'What is the commonality of theme?' (120-150 words)
Model answer: *Although the two accounts come from distant cultures - a Native American girl in a nineteenth-century American boarding school and a Dalit girl in a Tamil village - they share a theme: the humiliation of marginalised people by a dominant group, seen through a child's eyes. Zitkala-Sa is forced to give up her clothes, customs and long hair, which in her culture marked dignity; Bama sees an elder of her community bowing to a landlord and carrying food by a string so as not to 'pollute' it. Both children feel the injustice deeply and refuse to accept it - one by resisting, the other by studying hard. Together they assert that every person deserves dignity.*
Worked example 2: their responses
Model answer: Zitkala-Sa's response is immediate and physical: she hides and fights, and though overpowered, she never accepts the humiliation; as an adult she wrote against such schools. Bama's response is thoughtful and long-term: angry and hurt, she follows her brother's advice and uses education to win respect, standing first in her class.
We too are human beings: the claim both childhoods make, in two different worlds.
Key takeaways: both accounts show marginalised children discovering humiliation imposed by a dominant group - racial and cultural for Zitkala-Sa, caste-based for Bama. Both resist in their own way, showing that the seeds of rebellion are sown early, and that dignity can be reclaimed through courage and education.
Check your understanding
-
1. What kind of discrimination does Zitkala-Sa's account depict?
- Caste discrimination
- Racial and cultural discrimination
- Discrimination based on wealth only
- Age discrimination
Show answer
Answer: B. As a Native American child she is forced to abandon her culture's dress, customs and hair - racial and cultural discrimination.
-
2. What common theme links the two accounts?
- The humiliation of marginalised people by a dominant group, seen through a child's eyes
- The joys of school life
- Travel to new places
- Love of nature
Show answer
Answer: A. Both writers, from marginalised communities, recall a childhood experience of humiliation by the dominant culture.
-
3. What advice does Annan give Bama?
- To leave the village
- To work for the landlord
- To ignore the elders
- To study hard so that she can rise above indignity
Show answer
Answer: D. He says study and progress can help them throw off indignities, and people will come to her if she is ahead.
-
4. Which statement about children and injustice do the accounts support?
- Children do not notice injustice.
- Children only notice injustice when told.
- Children can sense injustice early, and resistance may begin then.
- Only adults can resist oppression.
Show answer
Answer: C. Both girls recognise injustice as children and respond, showing the seeds of rebellion are sown early.
-
5. Which article of the Indian Constitution abolishes untouchability?
- Article 14
- Article 21
- Article 32
- Article 17
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 17 abolishes untouchability and forbids its practice in any form.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.