• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Oriental despotism and a more complex social reality

Explain how Bernier's ideas shaped Montesquieu's oriental despotism and Marx's Asiatic mode of production, and use Bernier's own observations and other evidence to show a more complex society.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the ideas of oriental despotism and the Asiatic mode of production and their link to Bernier.
  • Identify contradictions in Bernier's own account that point to a more complex reality.
  • Describe Mughal towns, merchant organisations, professional groups and the imperial karkhanas.

Bernier's picture of a ruined Mughal India did not stay in his book. It shaped how European thinkers imagined 'the East' for two centuries. This lesson follows that influence and then tests his picture against other evidence, including his own observations.

From Bernier to Montesquieu and Marx

How an idea travelled

  1. Bernier (seventeenth century) The emperor owns all land; no private property; a ruined country of beggars and a tiny elite.
  2. Montesquieu (eighteenth century) Developed 'oriental despotism': Asian rulers held absolute authority over subjects kept in subjugation and poverty; all land belonged to the king.
  3. Karl Marx (nineteenth century) Developed the 'Asiatic mode of production': before colonialism the state appropriated surplus; autonomous, internally egalitarian village communities paid surplus to a court that left them alone; a stagnant system.

The textbook says this picture of rural society was far from true. In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries rural society showed considerable social and economic differentiation: big zamindars with superior rights in land at one end, 'untouchable' landless labourers at the other, and in between the big peasant using hired labour and producing for the market, and the small peasant barely producing for subsistence (Chapter 8 develops this).

Hints of complexity in Bernier's own account

Bernier's thesis versus his own observations
Bernier's thesisWhat he also noticed
Artisans had no incentive to improve because the state took profits; manufactures were declining everywhereVast quantities of the world's gold and silver flowed into India in exchange for exported manufactures
No middle state, only poor masses and a tiny eliteA prosperous merchant community engaged in long-distance trade
The land was ruined and badly cultivatedMuch of the country was extremely fertile; Bengal surpassed Egypt in rice, corn, silks, cotton and indigo

Towns: 'camp towns'?

In the seventeenth century about 15 per cent of the population lived in towns, according to the textbook, on average higher than the proportion in Western Europe at the time. Yet Bernier called Mughal cities 'camp towns': towns that arose when the imperial camp arrived and declined when it left, with no viable economic foundation of their own. The book calls this oversimplified: there were manufacturing towns, trading towns, port-towns, sacred centres and pilgrimage towns, whose existence shows the prosperity of merchants and professional classes.

  • Merchants: strong community and kin ties; organised in caste-cum-occupational bodies. In western India these were mahajans, headed by a sheth; in cities like Ahmedabad the mahajans were collectively represented by the nagarsheth.
  • Professional classes: physicians (hakim or vaid), teachers (pundit or mulla), lawyers (wakil), painters, architects, musicians, calligraphers. Some relied on imperial patronage; many served other patrons or ordinary people in bazaars.

The imperial karkhanas

Bernier is perhaps the only historian who describes the imperial karkhanas (workshops) in detail: large halls where embroiderers, goldsmiths, painters, lacquer-workers, joiners, tailors, shoe-makers and makers of silk, brocade and fine muslin worked under masters, coming each morning and leaving each evening. He presents a picture of much activity but little progress, implying that no one aspired to improve their condition.

Worked example 1: testing 'no middle state'

Bernier says India had only the very rich and the very poor. Test it with the chapter's evidence. Step 1: merchants organised into mahajans with sheths and a nagarsheth. Step 2: professionals: hakims, vaids, pundits, mullas, wakils, painters, architects. Step 3: big peasants who hired labour. Conclusion: many intermediate groups existed, so 'no middle state' is an oversimplification.

Worked example 2: why call them camp towns?

Reason through Bernier's view and its flaw. His view: he travelled with the imperial court and saw towns swell when it arrived and empty when it left, so he concluded towns depended on the camp. Flaw: he generalised from court-linked towns, ignoring ports, manufacturing and pilgrimage towns that thrived on trade and faith. A 15 per cent urban share (higher than Western Europe's average) does not fit a country of mere camps.

Oriental despotism: the European idea, built partly on Bernier, that Asian rulers had absolute power over subjects kept poor and subjugated because all land belonged to the king.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: Montesquieu turned Bernier's picture into oriental despotism; Marx into the Asiatic mode of production. The textbook says rural society was in fact highly differentiated. Bernier's own observations (gold and silver inflow, prosperous merchants, fertile Bengal) contradict his thesis. About 15 per cent lived in towns of many kinds; merchants organised as mahajans under sheths and a nagarsheth; professionals and karkhana artisans show a complex society.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who developed the idea of 'oriental despotism' using Bernier's account?

    1. Karl Marx
    2. Abu'l Fazl
    3. Montesquieu
    4. Tavernier
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The French philosopher Montesquieu used Bernier's account to develop oriental despotism; Marx later developed the Asiatic mode of production.

  2. 2. In western India, the collective representative of the mahajans in cities such as Ahmedabad was called the:

    1. sheth
    2. nagarsheth
    3. qazi
    4. wakil
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Each mahajan was headed by a sheth; in cities like Ahmedabad the mahajans were collectively represented by the chief of the merchant community, the nagarsheth.

  3. 3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'When the emperor's tents arrive, the town fills with sellers and soldiers; when he marches on, the streets fall silent and the shops close.' Which concept of Bernier's does it illustrate?

    1. Camp towns
    2. The karkhana
    3. The uluq
    4. The Asiatic mode of production
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Bernier called Mughal cities camp towns, believing they arose with the imperial camp and declined when it left. The book calls this oversimplified.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Bernier's picture of an undifferentiated rural society is described by the textbook as far from true. Reason (R): Rural society in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries included big zamindars, big peasants, small peasants and landless labourers.

    1. A is true, but R is false.
    2. A is false, but R is true.
    3. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book shows considerable differentiation, from big zamindars to landless labourers with big and small peasants in between; this is why the undifferentiated picture is called far from true.

  5. 5. According to the textbook, roughly what share of the population lived in towns in the seventeenth century?

    1. About 5 per cent
    2. About 40 per cent
    3. About 15 per cent
    4. About 60 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: C. About 15 per cent lived in towns, which the book says was on average higher than in Western Europe at the time.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery