- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Women in travellers' accounts and the limits of the sources
Analyse what Ibn Battuta and Bernier say about slavery, sati and women's work, and evaluate what travellers' accounts can and cannot tell historians.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Analyse Ibn Battuta's evidence on slavery and the differences among slaves.
- Explain why Bernier described sati and what else the evidence shows about women's lives.
- Evaluate the strengths and limits of travellers' accounts as historical sources.
Travellers who wrote accounts were generally men, interested and sometimes intrigued by women's condition. Sometimes they took social inequalities for granted as a 'natural' state of affairs. Reading them carefully tells us about the societies they saw and about their own assumptions.
Slaves
Ibn Battuta shows that slaves were openly sold in markets like any commodity and regularly exchanged as gifts. On reaching Sind he bought horses, camels and slaves as gifts for Sultan Muhammad bin Tughlaq; at Multan he presented the governor with a slave and a horse with raisins and almonds; the Sultan, pleased with a preacher's sermon, gave him a large sum of tankas and two hundred slaves. Most female slaves were captured in raids and expeditions.
| Kind of slave | Role |
|---|---|
| Female slaves in the Sultan's service, expert in music and dance | Performed at court occasions such as the wedding of the Sultan's sister |
| Female slaves employed to watch nobles | Passed information to female scavengers who entered nobles' houses unannounced; the Sultan also kept a slave with every noble to spy on him |
| Domestic slaves | Domestic labour, including carrying people in palanquins (dola); female domestic slaves were cheap, so most families who could afford it kept one or two |
Sati
European travellers often treated the treatment of women as a crucial marker of difference between Western and Eastern societies. So Bernier chose sati for detailed description. He noted that some women seemed to embrace death cheerfully, while others were forced to die. His most moving account describes a young widow at Lahore, about twelve years old by his estimate, who was terrified and was forced to her death by others, an event he says filled him with helpless anger.
Women's lives beyond sati
The textbook stresses that women's lives revolved around much more than sati. Their labour was crucial in agricultural and non-agricultural production. Women from merchant families took part in commerce, sometimes even taking mercantile disputes to court. So it seems unlikely that women were confined to the private spaces of their homes. Yet the lives of ordinary women workers rarely caught travellers' attention.
Travellers' accounts as sources
-
Strengths
- Outsiders noticed everyday practices locals took for granted
- Vivid detail on cities, markets, posts, crafts and customs
- Some, like Bernier, reveal more than they intend through their own observations
-
Limits
- Shaped by the contexts and assumptions travellers came from
- Written almost entirely by men; almost no women's accounts
- Many aspects of social life went unnoticed
- Sometimes aimed to entertain or to argue a case at home
- Experiences of people from the subcontinent who travelled abroad are still little known
Worked example 1: one source, two readings
Bernier describes a forced sati at Lahore. What can a historian conclude? Step 1, what it shows: the practice existed and could involve coercion; he also says some women seemed willing. Step 2, his purpose: Europeans used women's treatment to mark the East as different, so he chose this topic deliberately. Step 3, what it omits: women's work in fields, crafts and trade. Conclusion: the account is real evidence of a practice but a narrow, purpose-driven view of women's lives.
Worked example 2: why ordinary women workers were overlooked
Suggest reasons, using the chapter. (1) Travellers were men with limited access to women's spaces. (2) They highlighted the curious (Ibn Battuta) or the shocking (Bernier); routine labour seemed neither. (3) Their audiences at home expected marvels or lessons in contrast. Hence women's crucial everyday work appears only faintly, though other evidence shows it was essential.
A traveller's account reflects both the society observed and the observer's own background, audience and purpose; historians read it for both.
Key takeaways: Ibn Battuta shows slaves sold and gifted, most female slaves captured in raids, with differences among musicians, spies and domestic workers. Bernier chose sati to mark difference, noting both apparent willingness and coercion. Women's labour and commerce were crucial, so they were not confined to homes. Travellers' accounts are rich but partial, shaped by their contexts and blind to much of social life.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to Ibn Battuta, most female slaves were obtained through:
- purchase from Europe
- capture in raids and expeditions
- inheritance only
- voluntary contracts
Show answer
Answer: B. The book notes that most female slaves were captured in raids and expeditions; slaves were then sold openly in markets and exchanged as gifts.
-
2. Why did Bernier choose sati for detailed description, according to the textbook?
- Because it was the only custom he saw
- Because Dara Shukoh asked him to
- Because European writers often treated women's treatment as a crucial marker of difference between West and East
- Because he wanted to praise the custom
Show answer
Answer: C. Contemporary European writers highlighted the treatment of women as a key marker of difference, so Bernier chose sati for detailed description.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'The cloth-dealer's widow brought her late husband's partner before the qazi, demanding the money owed to the firm, and won her case.' What does such evidence suggest, according to the textbook?
- Women from merchant families participated in commerce and could take disputes to court
- Women were confined to their homes
- Only slaves worked outside homes
- Women could not own any wealth
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says women from merchant families took part in commercial activities, sometimes taking disputes to law courts, so they were unlikely to be confined to homes.
-
4. Assertion (A): Female slaves were employed by the Sultan to keep watch on his nobles. Reason (R): The price of female domestic slaves was very high, so only the Sultan could afford them.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is false, but R is true.
- A is true, but R is false.
Show answer
Answer: D. A is true according to Ibn Battuta. R is false: he says female domestic slaves were very cheap and most families who could afford it kept one or two.
-
5. Which is a limitation of travellers' accounts emphasised in the chapter?
- They were all written by women
- They never describe cities
- Travellers' observations were shaped by their own contexts, and many aspects of social life went unnoticed
- They were always written in Sanskrit
Show answer
Answer: C. The book concludes that travellers' observations were shaped by the contexts they came from, and that many aspects of social life were not noticed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.