Revision notes

Chapter 5 Through the Eyes of Travellers: Perceptions of Society (c. tenth to seventeenth century): Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Travellers as sources and Al-Biruni's Kitab-ul-Hind

Al-Biruni's usual chapter structure

  1. A question Each chapter generally opened with a question.
  2. A description Followed by a description based on Sanskritic traditions.
  3. A comparison Ended by comparing with other cultures.
The barriers Al-Biruni identified
BarrierExplanation
1. LanguageSanskrit was so different from Arabic and Persian that ideas could not easily be translated; he found it of enormous range in words and inflections
2. ReligionDifferences in religious beliefs and practices
3. InsularityThe self-absorption and consequent insularity of the local population

Kitab-ul-Hind: Al-Biruni's Arabic work in 80 chapters on Indian religion, science, customs and measures, usually moving from a question to a Sanskrit-based description to a comparison with other cultures.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: travellers noticed what locals took for granted. Al-Biruni (973 onwards; to Ghazni in 1017) learnt Sanskrit and wrote the Kitab-ul-Hind for frontier readers. He named three barriers: language, religion and insularity, yet relied on Brahmanical texts. He found parallels to caste in Persia, noted equality in Islam, accepted the varna description but rejected pollution as against nature.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Ibn Battuta's Rihla and the excitement of the unfamiliar

Ibn Battuta's journey, as the textbook describes it

  1. Before India Pilgrimages to Mecca; travels in Syria, Iraq, Persia, Yemen, Oman and East African ports. He left Tangier at 22.
  2. Sind, 1333 Arrived overland through Central Asia; went to Delhi via Multan and Uch, drawn by Muhammad bin Tughlaq's reputation as a patron.
  3. Qazi of Delhi Appointed judge; later fell out of favour and was imprisoned, then restored.
  4. Envoy to China, 1342 Sent to the Mongol ruler; travelled via Malabar, the Maldives (qazi for eighteen months), Sri Lanka, Bengal and Assam.
  5. China and home Sailed via Sumatra to Zaytun (Quanzhou), went as far as Beijing, left for home in 1347 and returned in 1354.

The two kinds of postal system Ibn Battuta described

  • Horse-post (uluq)
    • Royal horses stationed every four miles
  • Foot-post (dawa)
    • Three stations per mile (dawa means one-third of a mile)
    • Runners carried a rod with copper bells; the next runner heard the bells and got ready
    • Quicker than the horse-post
    • Often used to carry fruits of Khurasan

Ibn Battuta's strategy: describe the unfamiliar through comparison with the familiar, and highlight the curious and marvellous to entertain and instruct his readers.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: Ibn Battuta reached Sind in 1333, served as qazi of Delhi, went as envoy towards China in 1342 and returned home in 1354. The Rihla, dictated to Ibn Juzayy, aimed to entertain and instruct. He described the coconut and paan by comparison, found Delhi and Daulatabad vast and prosperous, praised two-crop agriculture and textile trade, and admired the uluq and dawa postal systems.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Bernier: comparing East and West and the question of landownership

Bernier's argument about crown ownership (as he presented it)

  1. The emperor owns all land He distributes it among his nobles; there is no private property in land.
  2. No inheritance Landholders cannot pass land to their children.
  3. No investment So they avoid long-term investment in production.
  4. No 'improving' landlords Unlike Western Europe, no class cares to maintain or improve land.
  5. Ruin Agriculture ruined, peasants oppressed, living standards falling for all but the aristocracy.

Binary opposition: presenting two societies as exact opposites, then ranking them, so that one always appears superior and the other inferior.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: Bernier (in India 1656-1668) served Dara Shukoh and Danishmand Khan; his printed works spread widely in Europe, unlike Persian and Arabic manuscripts. He used binary opposition to rank Europe above India. He blamed crown ownership of land for ruin and claimed India had 'no middle state'; Mughal documents show no sole state ownership, and Abu'l Fazl treated revenue as remuneration of sovereignty, a tax on the crop.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Oriental despotism and a more complex social reality

How an idea travelled

  1. Bernier (seventeenth century) The emperor owns all land; no private property; a ruined country of beggars and a tiny elite.
  2. Montesquieu (eighteenth century) Developed 'oriental despotism': Asian rulers held absolute authority over subjects kept in subjugation and poverty; all land belonged to the king.
  3. Karl Marx (nineteenth century) Developed the 'Asiatic mode of production': before colonialism the state appropriated surplus; autonomous, internally egalitarian village communities paid surplus to a court that left them alone; a stagnant system.
Bernier's thesis versus his own observations
Bernier's thesisWhat he also noticed
Artisans had no incentive to improve because the state took profits; manufactures were declining everywhereVast quantities of the world's gold and silver flowed into India in exchange for exported manufactures
No middle state, only poor masses and a tiny eliteA prosperous merchant community engaged in long-distance trade
The land was ruined and badly cultivatedMuch of the country was extremely fertile; Bengal surpassed Egypt in rice, corn, silks, cotton and indigo

Oriental despotism: the European idea, built partly on Bernier, that Asian rulers had absolute power over subjects kept poor and subjugated because all land belonged to the king.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: Montesquieu turned Bernier's picture into oriental despotism; Marx into the Asiatic mode of production. The textbook says rural society was in fact highly differentiated. Bernier's own observations (gold and silver inflow, prosperous merchants, fertile Bengal) contradict his thesis. About 15 per cent lived in towns of many kinds; merchants organised as mahajans under sheths and a nagarsheth; professionals and karkhana artisans show a complex society.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Women in travellers' accounts and the limits of the sources

Differentiation among slaves in Ibn Battuta's account
Kind of slaveRole
Female slaves in the Sultan's service, expert in music and dancePerformed at court occasions such as the wedding of the Sultan's sister
Female slaves employed to watch noblesPassed information to female scavengers who entered nobles' houses unannounced; the Sultan also kept a slave with every noble to spy on him
Domestic slavesDomestic labour, including carrying people in palanquins (dola); female domestic slaves were cheap, so most families who could afford it kept one or two

Travellers' accounts as sources

  • Strengths
    • Outsiders noticed everyday practices locals took for granted
    • Vivid detail on cities, markets, posts, crafts and customs
    • Some, like Bernier, reveal more than they intend through their own observations
  • Limits
    • Shaped by the contexts and assumptions travellers came from
    • Written almost entirely by men; almost no women's accounts
    • Many aspects of social life went unnoticed
    • Sometimes aimed to entertain or to argue a case at home
    • Experiences of people from the subcontinent who travelled abroad are still little known

A traveller's account reflects both the society observed and the observer's own background, audience and purpose; historians read it for both.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: Ibn Battuta shows slaves sold and gifted, most female slaves captured in raids, with differences among musicians, spies and domestic workers. Bernier chose sati to mark difference, noting both apparent willingness and coercion. Women's labour and commerce were crucial, so they were not confined to homes. Travellers' accounts are rich but partial, shaped by their contexts and blind to much of social life.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery