- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Common but differentiated responsibilities and India's stand
Explain the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities in the Rio Declaration, the UNFCCC and the Kyoto Protocol, and describe India's position and efforts on environmental issues as the textbook presents them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the North-South disagreement that led to the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities.
- Describe the UNFCCC (1992) and the Kyoto Protocol (1997).
- Explain India's stand on climate negotiations and the steps the textbook lists.
The North and the South approach environmental responsibility differently. The textbook explains how this disagreement shaped a key principle of international environmental law, and where India stands.
The disagreement
Who should bear responsibility?
-
Developed North
- Discuss the environment as it stands now
- Everyone equally responsible for conservation
-
Developing South
- Most degradation came from the North's industrial development
- Those who caused more damage should do more to undo it
- Industrialising countries should not face the same restrictions
- Special needs of developing countries must count in environmental law
The principle
The South's argument was accepted in the Rio Declaration at the 1992 Earth Summit as the principle of 'common but differentiated responsibilities'. In substance, the Declaration says states should cooperate in a spirit of global partnership to conserve and restore the Earth's ecosystems; because they contributed differently to degradation, their responsibilities differ; and developed countries acknowledge a special responsibility because of the pressure their societies place on the environment and the technological and financial resources they command.
Common but differentiated responsibilities: all states share the duty to protect the environment, but those that caused more damage and have more resources (the developed countries) must bear a larger share of the burden.
UNFCCC and the Kyoto Protocol
- The 1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) says parties should protect the climate system on the basis of equity and their common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities.
- Parties agreed that the largest share of historical and current greenhouse gas emissions came from developed countries, and that per capita emissions in developing countries are still relatively low.
- The Kyoto Protocol, agreed in 1997 in Kyoto, Japan, on UNFCCC principles, set targets for industrialised countries to cut emissions of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, methane and hydrofluorocarbons, considered at least partly responsible for global warming.
- China, India and other developing countries were exempted from its requirements.
India's stand
- India signed and ratified the Kyoto Protocol in August 2002. It was exempt because its emissions during the industrialisation period, believed to cause today's warming, were not significant. Critics, the textbook notes, point out that India and China will sooner or later be among the leading emitters.
- At the G-8 meeting in June 2005, India pointed out that developing countries' per capita emissions are a tiny fraction of those in the developed world; following the principle above, it holds that the major responsibility for curbing emissions rests with developed countries, which have accumulated emissions over a long time.
- India's negotiating position relies heavily on historical responsibility as enshrined in the UNFCCC, which also states that economic and social development are the first and overriding priorities of developing countries.
- India is wary of proposals within the UNFCCC to impose binding commitments on rapidly industrialising countries such as Brazil, China and India, which it feels contravene the spirit of the Convention. The textbook cites projections (from the year 2000) that India's per capita emissions in 2030 would still be well below the world average of 2000.
- In 1997 India reviewed implementation of the Rio agreements and concluded there had been no meaningful progress in transferring new financial resources and environmentally sound technology on concessional terms to developing countries; it wants developed countries to provide these at once.
- India believes SAARC countries should adopt a common position on major global environmental issues, so the region's voice carries more weight.
India's own efforts, as listed in the textbook
| Measure | Purpose |
|---|---|
| National Auto-fuel Policy | Mandates cleaner fuels for vehicles |
| Energy Conservation Act, 2001 | Initiatives to improve energy efficiency |
| Electricity Act, 2003 | Encourages renewable energy |
| Natural gas imports and clean coal technologies | Signs of real effort to cut pollution |
| Paris Climate Agreement | Ratified by India on 2 October 2016 |
| Renewable energy | The textbook says India has one of the largest renewable energy programmes in the world |
Worked example 1: applying the principle
Question: Two made-up countries: Northland industrialised a century ago and has high emissions per person; Southland is industrialising now and has low emissions per person. How would the principle divide responsibility? Reasoning: Step 1, both share a common duty to protect the climate. Step 2, Northland contributed more historically and has more technology and money. Step 3, so Northland should cut more and help Southland with finance and technology, while Southland is not held to the same restrictions yet. Answer: common duty, differentiated burden, as in the Kyoto Protocol's exemption for developing countries.
Worked example 2: per capita versus total
Question (illustrative numbers): Country A emits 100 units in total with 10 people; Country B emits 200 units with 100 people. Which has higher emissions, and why does India stress per capita figures? Working: totals: B (200) is higher than A (100). Per capita: A = 100 ÷ 10 = 10 units per person; B = 200 ÷ 100 = 2 units per person, so A is five times higher per person. Point: a populous developing country can have a large total but a small per person figure, which is why India argued at the G-8 in 2005 that per capita emissions of developing countries are a tiny fraction of the developed world's.
Key takeaways: the North wants equal responsibility now; the South says those who caused most damage should do most to repair it. The Rio Declaration accepted 'common but differentiated responsibilities', reflected in the 1992 UNFCCC and the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, which set targets for industrialised countries and exempted India and China. India ratified Kyoto in August 2002, stresses per capita emissions and historical responsibility, resists binding commitments on developing countries, seeks finance and technology from the North, and has its own clean energy laws and policies; it ratified the Paris Agreement on 2 October 2016.
Check your understanding
-
1. The principle of 'common but differentiated responsibilities' was accepted in:
- the Rio Declaration at the 1992 Earth Summit
- the 1959 Antarctic Treaty
- Limits to Growth
- the Montreal Protocol
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says the developing countries' argument was accepted in the Rio Declaration at the Earth Summit in 1992 and is called the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities.
-
2. The Kyoto Protocol set targets for:
- all countries equally
- only India and China
- industrialised countries to cut greenhouse gas emissions
- ocean floor mining
Show answer
Answer: C. The Kyoto Protocol, agreed in 1997, sets targets for industrialised countries to cut their emissions; China, India and other developing countries were exempt.
-
3. India signed and ratified the Kyoto Protocol in:
- June 1992
- August 2002
- December 1997
- October 2016
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says India signed and ratified the 1997 Kyoto Protocol in August 2002. October 2016 is when it ratified the Paris Agreement.
-
4. At the G-8 meeting in June 2005, India stressed that:
- developing countries should accept binding targets
- only SAARC should handle climate change
- the Kyoto Protocol should be cancelled
- per capita emissions of developing countries are a tiny fraction of those in the developed world
Show answer
Answer: D. India pointed out that per capita emission rates of developing countries are a tiny fraction of those in the developed world.
-
5. Assertion (A): Developing countries were exempted from the requirements of the Kyoto Protocol. Reason (R): The largest share of historical and current greenhouse gas emissions originated in developed countries, and per capita emissions in developing countries are still relatively low.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: these facts, agreed under the UNFCCC, are why China, India and other developing countries were exempted.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.