- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Resource geopolitics and the rights of indigenous peoples
Explain resource geopolitics with the textbook's examples of timber, oil and water, and describe who indigenous peoples are, their concerns, and their place in India and in world politics.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain resource geopolitics and how industrialised countries secured resources during the Cold War.
- Explain why oil and water are sources of rivalry and conflict, with the textbook's examples.
- Define indigenous peoples and explain their main concerns, in the world and in India.
Resource geopolitics is about who gets what, when, where and how. Resources have been key means and motives of European global expansion and a focus of rivalry between states. The textbook then turns to the indigenous peoples, whose story brings environment, resources and politics together.
A history of resource rivalry
- Western geopolitical thinking about resources centred on trade, war and power, with overseas resources and maritime navigation at its core.
- Since sea power rested on access to timber, naval timber supply became a key priority for major European powers from the 17th century.
- The importance of uninterrupted supply of strategic resources, especially oil, was established in both world wars.
How the industrialised North secured resources during the Cold War
-
Military means
- Forces deployed near exploitation sites
- Forces along sea-lanes of communication
-
Economic means
- Stockpiling strategic resources
- Support to multinational companies
- Favourable international agreements
-
Political means
- Propping up friendly governments in producing countries
Western strategic thinking worried about Soviet threats to supply, especially Western control of oil in the Gulf and strategic minerals in Southern and Central Africa. After the Cold War, security of supply still worries governments and businesses, particularly for radioactive materials, but oil remains the most important resource in global strategy. The wealth it brings generates struggles to control it, and the textbook says the history of petroleum is also a history of war and struggle, most obviously in West Asia and Central Asia. It notes that the Gulf region holds a large share of the world's known oil reserves (with Saudi Arabia and Iraq the largest), while the main consumers (the US, Europe, Japan and increasingly India and China) are far away. (Shares of reserves and production change over time; the textbook's figures are a snapshot.)
Water
Regional variations and growing scarcity of fresh water suggest that disagreements over shared water may be a leading source of conflict in the 21st century; some commentators speak of 'water wars'. A typical dispute is a downstream (lower riparian) state objecting to pollution, excessive irrigation or dam construction by an upstream (upper riparian) state that reduces or degrades its water. States have used force to protect or seize water: the textbook cites violence between Israel, Syria and Jordan in the 1950s and 1960s over diverting water from the Jordan and Yarmuk rivers, and threats between Turkey, Syria and Iraq over dams on the Euphrates. Studies show that countries sharing rivers are often involved in military conflicts with each other.
How a river dispute arises
- Upstream state acts Builds a dam, irrigates heavily, or pollutes
- Less or poorer water flows down Quantity or quality falls
- Downstream state objects Sees a threat to its people and farms
- Tension or conflict Negotiation, or in some cases threats and force
Indigenous peoples
The UN defines indigenous populations as the descendants of peoples who inhabited the present territory of a country when people of a different culture or ethnic origin arrived from elsewhere and overcame them. Indigenous people today live more by their own social, economic and cultural customs than by the institutions of the country they now belong to. They live in Central and South America, Africa, India (where they are known as Tribals), Southeast Asia and the island states of Oceania, including Australia and New Zealand.
- Their voices call for the admission of indigenous people to the world community as equals, and for governments to accept the continuing existence of indigenous nations as enduring communities with an identity of their own.
- They use the phrase 'since times immemorial' for their continued occupancy of their lands; their worldviews about land and the life it supports are strikingly similar everywhere.
- The loss of land, which also means loss of an economic resource base, is the most obvious threat to their survival. The textbook asks whether political autonomy can be enjoyed without the means of physical survival.
Indigenous people in India
In India the description is usually applied to the Scheduled Tribes, who according to the textbook make up nearly eight per cent of the population. Apart from small communities of hunters and gatherers, most depend on cultivating land. For centuries they had free access to land; only after British colonial rule were their areas subjected to outside forces. They enjoy constitutional protection in political representation but have received few benefits of development; indeed the textbook says they have paid a huge cost, being the single largest group displaced by development projects since independence.
Indigenous rights were long neglected in domestic and international politics. Growing contacts among indigenous leaders in the 1970s created a sense of shared concern, and the World Council of Indigenous Peoples was formed in 1975; it became the first of 11 indigenous NGOs to receive consultative status in the UN.
Resource geopolitics: the struggle among states and other actors over who gets which resources, when, where and how.
Worked example 1: upstream and downstream
Question: River R flows from made-up Country X into Country Y. X builds a large dam. Which state is the upper riparian, and what objection might the other raise? Reasoning: the upper riparian is the state where the river flows first, so X. Y, the lower riparian, may object that the dam reduces the water reaching it or degrades its quality. Answer: X is upstream; Y would object to reduced or poorer water supply, a typical cause of water disputes.
Worked example 2: why land matters to indigenous peoples
Question: Using the chapter, explain why loss of land is the most obvious threat to indigenous peoples. Step 1: most depend on land for subsistence (in India, mainly cultivation). Step 2: their identity and worldview are bound to their lands, occupied 'since times immemorial'. Step 3: so losing land means losing both the economic base and the community's way of life; political rights alone cannot make up for it. Conclusion: land loss threatens their very survival as communities.
Key takeaways: resource geopolitics asks who gets what, when, where and how. From naval timber to oil, resources have driven rivalry; during the Cold War the North secured supplies through military deployments, stockpiles, friendly governments, support to MNCs and agreements. Oil remains central, especially in West Asia, and shared rivers can cause 'water wars' (Jordan and Yarmuk, Euphrates). Indigenous peoples, defined by the UN as descendants of original inhabitants who were overcome by newcomers, seek recognition as equals and protection of their lands; in India, Scheduled Tribes have borne a heavy cost of displacement. The World Council of Indigenous Peoples was formed in 1975.
Check your understanding
-
1. Resource geopolitics, as the textbook defines it, is about:
- the study of rocks and minerals
- who gets what, when, where and how
- only the history of oil
- the protection of wildlife
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says resource geopolitics is all about who gets what, when, where and how.
-
2. Naval timber supply became a key priority for major European powers from:
- the 12th century
- 1959
- the 20th century
- the 17th century
Show answer
Answer: D. Since sea power rested on access to timber, naval timber supply became a key priority for major European powers from the 17th century onwards.
-
3. Which example of violence over water does the textbook give?
- Israel, Syria and Jordan over the Jordan and Yarmuk rivers
- France and Germany over the Rhine
- India and Bangladesh over the Indus
- Brazil and Chile over the Amazon
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter cites violence between Israel, Syria and Jordan in the 1950s and 1960s over attempts to divert water from the Jordan and Yarmuk rivers.
-
4. The World Council of Indigenous Peoples was formed in:
- 1959
- 1972
- 1975
- 1992
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says the World Council of Indigenous Peoples was formed in 1975 and became the first of 11 indigenous NGOs with consultative status in the UN.
-
5. Assertion (A): Scheduled Tribes in India have paid a huge cost for development. Reason (R): They are the single largest group among people displaced by development projects since independence.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says that, despite constitutional protection in representation, they have been the largest group displaced by development projects.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.