- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Global commons and common property resources
Define global commons and common property resources, explain why cooperation over the commons is difficult, with the Antarctic and outer space as examples, and describe sacred groves in India as a common property regime.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define global commons and name the four the textbook lists.
- Explain the agreements and difficulties in managing the commons, including the Antarctic and outer space.
- Define common property resources and explain sacred groves as an example.
'Commons' are resources that are not owned by anyone but are shared by a community: a common room, a park, a river. Some areas of the world lie outside the sovereign jurisdiction of any one state and need common governance by the international community. This lesson looks at these global commons, and at the related idea of common property managed by a group.
Global commons
Areas outside any state's sovereign jurisdiction are called res communis humanitatis or global commons. The textbook lists four:
Global commons
-
Earth's atmosphere
- Affected by greenhouse gases and ozone depletion
-
Antarctica
- Coldest, farthest, windiest continent
- Disputed: some states claim sovereignty, most treat it as commons
-
Ocean floor
- Beyond national jurisdiction
-
Outer space
- Use shaped by technology and industrial capacity
Agreements and difficulties
Cooperation over the commons is not easy, but there have been path-breaking agreements: the 1959 Antarctic Treaty, the 1987 Montreal Protocol and the 1991 Antarctic Environmental Protocol. A major problem in all ecological issues is reaching consensus on common agendas when the scientific evidence and time frames are vague. The discovery of the ozone hole over the Antarctic in the mid-1980s showed both the opportunity and the dangers in tackling global environmental problems.
The Antarctic
The textbook describes the Antarctic continental region as covering over 14 million square kilometres, with about 26 per cent of the world's wilderness area, 90 per cent of all terrestrial ice and 70 per cent of planetary fresh water, plus a further 36 million square kilometres of ocean. It has limited land life but a highly productive marine ecosystem, including krill, central to the marine food chain. It helps maintain climatic equilibrium, and its deep ice cores record greenhouse gas concentrations and temperatures of the distant past.
Who owns the Antarctic? Two claims
-
Claims of sovereignty
- Made by the UK, Argentina, Chile, Norway, France, Australia and New Zealand
-
Global commons view
- Held by most other states
- Not subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of any state
These differences have not prevented innovative rules to protect the Antarctic environment. Since 1959, activities have been limited to scientific research, fishing and tourism, though even these have degraded parts of the region through waste and oil spills.
Outer space and the North-South divide
The history of outer space as a commons shows, the textbook says, that managing these areas is thoroughly influenced by North-South inequalities. As with the atmosphere and the ocean floor, the crucial issue is technology and industrial development: the benefits of exploiting outer space are far from equal for present and future generations, since only technologically advanced states can make full use of it.
Common property resources
Common property belongs to a group. Its members have both rights and duties concerning the nature and level of use and the maintenance of a resource. Through mutual understanding and centuries of practice, many village communities in India have defined members' rights and responsibilities. But privatisation, agricultural intensification, population growth and ecosystem degradation have made common property shrink in size, quality and availability to the poor in much of the world.
Sacred groves in India are the textbook's example: parcels of uncut forest dedicated to deities or to natural or ancestral spirits, traditionally managed by village communities, for instance along the forest belt of South India. They range from a few trees to several hundred acres. Deep religious reverence for nature, rather than scarcity, seems to underlie their protection, and researchers see them as preserving biodiversity, ecological functions and cultural diversity. Today expansion and settlement encroach on them, new forest policies blur their identity, and a real problem arises when legal ownership (the state) and operational control (the community) are held by different entities with different motives.
Global commons are areas outside any state's jurisdiction needing international governance; common property resources belong to a defined group whose members share rights and duties over them.
Worked example 1: commons or common property?
Question: Classify: (i) the ocean floor beyond national waters; (ii) a village pasture whose use the villagers have regulated by custom for generations; (iii) the Earth's atmosphere. Reasoning: (i) and (iii) lie outside any one state's sovereign jurisdiction, so they are global commons. (ii) belongs to a defined group with shared rights and duties, so it is common property. Answer: (i) global commons, (ii) common property resource, (iii) global commons.
Worked example 2: why outer space reflects inequality
Question: Explain how the management of outer space reflects North-South inequality. Step 1: outer space is a global commons, open in principle to all. Step 2: using it requires advanced technology and industry. Step 3: these are concentrated in the developed North, so the benefits of exploiting space are unequal. Conclusion: formal equality of access hides unequal capacity to benefit, which is why the textbook says management of the commons is influenced by North-South inequalities.
Key takeaways: global commons (the atmosphere, Antarctica, the ocean floor and outer space) lie outside any state's jurisdiction. Agreements such as the 1959 Antarctic Treaty, the 1987 Montreal Protocol and the 1991 Antarctic Environmental Protocol show cooperation is possible, but consensus is hard and North-South inequalities shape who benefits. Common property resources belong to a group with rights and duties; India's sacred groves are a traditional example now under pressure.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is NOT listed in the textbook as a global commons?
- The Earth's atmosphere
- Antarctica
- Outer space
- A village pasture
Show answer
Answer: D. The four global commons are the atmosphere, Antarctica, the ocean floor and outer space. A village pasture used by a community is common property, not a global commons.
-
2. The ozone hole over the Antarctic was discovered in:
- the 1950s
- the mid-1980s
- 1992
- 2005
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the discovery of the ozone hole over the Antarctic in the mid-1980s revealed the opportunity as well as the dangers of tackling global environmental problems.
-
3. Since 1959, activities in the Antarctic have been limited to:
- mining and oil drilling
- military bases only
- scientific research, fishing and tourism
- large-scale farming
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says activities have been limited to scientific research, fishing and tourism since 1959.
-
4. A real problem in managing sacred groves, according to the textbook, arises when:
- legal ownership and operational control are held by different entities
- no trees grow there
- they are too small
- they are located in South India
Show answer
Answer: A. When the state holds legal ownership and the community holds operational control, their differing norms and motives create problems.
-
5. Assertion (A): Management of outer space as a global commons is influenced by North-South inequalities. Reason (R): The benefits of exploiting outer space depend on technology and industrial development.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since technology and industry decide who can benefit, and these are concentrated in the North, the benefits are unequal.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.